Phoebe ran up the steps to the Manor before Prue could even get out of the car. Piper was coming out of the dining room when she heard the door close and Prue waking through the front entrance. "Hey what's going on?"
"Phoebe what else." Prue replied as she made her way quickly up the stairs of the Manor.
Piper thought quickly but then ran up the stairs after Prue and Phoebe.
"Phoebe what is going on?" Prue walked into her sisters' room without even so much as a knock.
"Prue I just want to be alone right now."
"Not this time sister. First you don't tell Piper you are talking to Jane then you wake up in the middle of the night scarred more then I have seen you even fighting demons. Now I find you down at the cliffs where Jack was killed. And none other then the one person everyone thinks killed him there.
"I didn't know Caleb was there. I just go there sometimes... to think about Jack." She brushed back the tear that was escaping down her face. "I still miss him." She said quietly as she sat ion her bed defeated.
Prue saw the look Piper was giving her as she then slowly walked up the to bed and sat down beside Phoebe. Pulling her baby sister into her hug she held on to her letting her cry out the loss once again.
"Phoebe you can talk to us about this you know. Don't hold it in." Piper spoke as she too sat beside her sister.
"I can't. There was so much blood. He just laughed." She caught herself, she wasn't thinking straight, words were just coming out of her mind and she spoke them.
Prue looked at Piper but didn't say anything.
"I keep seeing him. In my nightmares. I couldn't save him. He told me …"
"He told you what honey?" Prue asked, she was starting to piece bits together.
Phoebe didn't say anything. She gripped onto Prue's shirt not wanting to see it again. Not wanting to see him again.
"Get some rest Phoebs. One of us will come up and get you for dinner." Prue suggested as she let Phoebe lay on her bed. She wanted to walk to Piper about her thoughts
"Stay." the word was near silent, but to Prue it rang in her ears as loud as a jackahmmer. It was one small word but it reminded Prue of that same night five years ago when Mr Trudeau brought her to the apartment.
"I'll let you know." Piper said as she cast Prue a glance before she gave Phoebe a kiss on the top of her head. "Get some rest sweetie."
Piper gave Prue a saddened look as she walked from her sisters' room. There was an unspoken word between the two older Halliwell's. There was something more then just see Jane and going to the cliffs. That they both knew.
Prue came down the stairs a few minutes later and picked up the cordless as she stepped briefly in the kitchen.
"Prue?"
"I'm going back up, she's sleeping right now. I need to talk to Andy."
"Andy?"
"I'm not sure. But I just have this feeling that more happened that night then what Phoebe has told us."
"Like what?"
"Like the fact that I think she was there that night and I think she saw something."
"Prue no. She would have said."
"Not unless she was to scared or even in such shock she forgot. It happens." She heard the phone ring a third time and was about to hang up when she heard his voice. "Andy its Prue. I need to talk to you."
She hung up the phone and looked at Piper. "He is on his way over here. It's just things she said tonight Piper. And I know she went out with him that night. Why wasn't she with him down there?"
Andy took the steps by two as he knocked once then opened the door. "Prue?"
Piper came out of the living room and saw the anxious look on his face. "She's upstairs with Phoebe. Andy we don't know for sure its just a few things that Phoebe has said tonight. And Prue and I were putting the pieces together."
"Well if you are right then Caleb is going to jail for a very long time."
"For Jacks murder."
"And the two this past week. After I was talking to Prue the other day I did some investigating and Morris made a comment that made sense. I compared the slugs from the two dead bodies we got to the ballistic report on Jacks Murder."
Piper saw the determination in his eyes.
"Who ever killed those two also killed Jack or at least used the same gun."
"Caleb." Prue's voice answered the questions from the stair landing. "And I think Phoebe witnessed Jacks murder."
"You may be right Prue. Remember when we used to go down there. We went to that little cave in the cliff."
"Yeah."
"I stopped there on my way here. Kids still use it today. The brush cover is the same and if someone was in there, they had a clear line to the beach where Jack was found."
"He told her to stay." Prue was lost in thought.
"What?"
"Tonight Phoebe said he told me.. Then she stopped. I am guessing he told her to stay and wait for him but to stay out of sight."
"Good reason too, if Caleb knew she was there he would have killed her too. Or worse." Andy let his words stop not even wanting to think what Caleb and his boys would have done to Phoebe that night if the knew she was there. "Where is she?"
"Sleeping." Prue said
"Right here."
They all turned and looked at Phoebes. Her eyes were puffy from crying Prue stepped up to her sister and felt her almost crumble in her arms. "I didn't know. Jack came to me the other night."
"Your nightmare?" Piper added in not letting Andy know what her sister meant.
"He said I saw it he looked right at me before he died. I didn't believe him. But then I saw it. I was in the cave. I waited forever and before I went looking for him. I pushed it away."
Prue held her sister as she relieved her own nightmare.
"He just laughed as he pulled the trigger. There was so much blood." she once again felt the tears start down her face
Prue closed her eyes knowing what her sister had to have gone through that might. "Ok baby shhh its ok its over now."
"It isn't Prue. We need to find him before he knows there was a witness and even then. He'll have someone come after Phoebe, Until we lock him away this isn't over."
Piper held on to Phoebe as Prue showed Andy to the door. "Now what?"
"Now. I get a police car outside the house and get a warrant for his arrest. I got enough to get him." He gave Prue a hug, "Don't worry Prue. I'll send over the best. No one will hurt her or any of you."
"Thanks for all of this Andy."
"Hey she is my little sister too remember?" he gave her a quick kiss. "I'll talk to you later. In fact I'll see you later. I'm sleeping here till we get this guy."
Prue closed the door and held her hand a moment on the back of it. Taking a deep breath she walked into the living room seeing her sister still in Pipers arms. She sat on the couch and Phoebe instantly went to her older sister her protector.
"I'm sorry."
"Its ok honey. You said yourself you pushed it out of your mind. So Jack was at the cliffs to see you all this time?"
"He has been trying to get me to remember ever since. And then the other night I saw him. I guess its cause we are witches now."
"Probably. Bet that freaked him out a little." Piper said as she ran her hand over Phoebes head.
"Yeah a bit. But he thinks its cool now."
"I am just glad I was dead when I found out."
They all jumped as Jack spoke to them as she walked in the room.
"So Andy is gonna set this right?"
"Yeah as soon as he finds Caleb." Prue said still holding on to her sister.
"Well I hope he find him before he finds you three."
"Witches Jack, remember. Trust me you don't want to see Prue pissed off." Piper said with a slight smile.
"I remember that part Piper."
Caleb sat on the back of his car twisting the gun in his hand ever now and then holding it up and looking down the barrel.
"We got a problem."
He didn't even look off the sight he had lined up, "I don't like problems Mac."
"Trudeau."
He cast a glance to his friend. "What about him?"
"He just was spotted running into the Halliwell house and came out a hour later. There are at least two cars heading there. A black and white and an unmarked one for a block down."
"Is he protecting his girl or someone else." He thought as he placed his gun away. "I can't take the chance. Let's move."
Piper moved though the kitchen as she had so many times before. Growing up in the Manor she knew where everything was. It was her domain.
She spun around at the sound of the glass breaking but not fast enough to freeze the room. She felt the arms pulling her own arms behind her and felt the tip of the gun press into her temple.
"Now Piper. Where are your sisters?"
