Goosebumps Threeway

"I'm really sorry you couldn't find Gary, Jess."

"It's okay, maybe it just wasn't meant to be, yah know?"

Jess sniffles and looks up at Reagan giving her a weak smile, Reagan smiles back and takes a seat next to her, wrapping her arms around her in a very unexpected hug. "You're an incredibly sweet and beautiful woman, Jess. You'll find the right person eventually." Jess breaks the hug and leans back against her headboard, giving her another weak smile in response.

She feels Reagan shift and bring her hands up to her cheeks, cupping her face in her hands. "I mean it, Jess. You're gorgeous. I can totally understand why Nick couldn't keep his hands off you, I wouldn't be able to either if I lived with you." Jess's eyes felt like they were going to pop out of her head. Is she hitting on me…?

Reagan laughed and continued to gently caress Jess's soft cheeks. "I guess no one told you, I'm bisexual. I'm extremely attracted to you, Jess. Honestly, since I first laid eyes on you, all thoughts of Nick kind of disappeared." She whispered and leaned in, kissing Jess softly on the lips. Jess had to admit, it was a nice kiss but she wasn't into woman, was she? Reagan was very beautiful, obviously, but she had never been with a woman sexually ever.

"Um, Reagan… I'm not…" Reagan shut her up by leaning in a kissing her again, this time with more vigor. She felt Reagan's tongue trace along her bottom lip and opened her mouth to her, letting their tongues tangle. Jess wasn't sure what was happening right now, but she found herself becoming more and more aroused and decided to just… let it happen.

They continued kissing for a little while until Reagan broke the kiss and looked deeply into Jess's eyes. "You're an amazing kisser, Jess. What do you say we get a little more comfortable?" Jess couldn't speak, completely mesmerized by this woman in front of her, so instead she nodded and followed her lead, lying down on her bed as Reagan came to hover over her, leaning in to kiss her once more.

Jess felt Reagan's hands taking in her curves, sliding up and down her body until she brought one hand up to her breast, gently massaging her through her pajama top, Jess couldn't control the whimper that rose up from her chest. Reagan broke the kiss to trail her lips along Jess's jawline and down to her neck, biting her earlobe when she reached it. "I'm going to make you feel so good, Jess." She was just about to respond when suddenly her bedroom door was flung open, causing her to shoot up to a sitting position.

She looked over at her now open door to see a very confused and shocked Nick Miller, she guessed the expression on her face closely matched the one on his. "Uhh… I um.." She watched him go through an assortment of emotions before he walked fully into her bedroom and shut the door behind him. "Jess… Reagan… Uhh, what's going on here?" Jess looked over at Reagan to find her smiling at her, she reached up with her right hand and gently caressed Jess's cheek again.

"Jess had a rough day and I was just trying to make her feel better. I think the better question would be, what the hell are you doing, Nick? Don't know how to knock or what?"

Nick walked over to Jess's bed and sat down by their feet, his brows were furrowed and he was rubbing his thumbs along his index fingers, something he always does when he's nervous or anxious. "Well, I guess I'm just a little confused here… I mean earlier today we were making out and now you're in here making out with my ex-girlfriend. I mean…"

"Look, Nick… I'm sorry, but from the moment I saw Jess, I knew I had to have her. I mean, look at her?! She's gorgeous and just so… Sexy."

Jess felt herself blush and looked over at Nick, expecting a death glare, but instead he was looking at her with a softness in his eyes that she hadn't seen in a very long time. "Yeah, She really is." Nick said, not breaking eye contact with Jess. She smiled at him shyly and he smiled in return, making her heart flutter in her chest.

"Well, I guess that just leaves one more question… Since when are you into chicks, Jess?" He said with a chuckle. She didn't know how to answer that, because she honestly hadn't even really thought about it until tonight. "I don't… I don't know, she just kissed me and it felt nice and…"

Reagan shut her up by pulling her back down on the bed and hovering over her before leaning in and kissing her deeply, making Jess moan loudly into her mouth. Jess faintly heard Nick whisper "Oh my god" under his breath, making her feel brave and even more aroused, she flipped Reagan over and straddled her body without breaking their kiss.

She felt both of Reagan's hands slide up her stomach to her breasts, cupping them both in her hands. Jess decided to return the favor and brought her hands to Reagan's breasts, gently caressing them. It was an odd feeling having another woman's breasts in her hands, but when she heard Reagan's moans and Nicks heavy breathing behind her all her inhibitions flew out the window. She was doing this, she was going to sleep with another woman in front of Nick. Or with Nick? The more she thought about it, the more she wanted Nick to join in the fun.

She broke the kiss and sat up, still straddling Reagan and looked back at Nick. "Would you like to join us, Nicholas?" She bit her bottom lip and pulled her pajama top over her head, not bothering with the buttons, leaving her completely topless. "God, Yes!" Nick practically growled before leaning his and kissing her deeply.

She felt Reagan's hands come up to cup her now bare breasts, gently caressing them before rolling her hard nipples between her fingers, making her moan into Nick's mouth. "That's fine with me, But you get Nick all to yourself, Jess. I just wanna make you feel good. God, You're breasts are perfect…" Jess felt Reagan's hot breath on her hardened nipple as she spoke before taking the hardened nub into her mouth, licking and gently biting. She cried out into Nick's mouth and brought her hand up to tangle in Reagan's long, soft locks.

Jess broke the kiss and looked down at Reagan, her mouth expertly working her hardened nipples. She reached for the bottom of her shirt and pulled it over her head before reaching around her back and unsnapping her bra. It wasn't often that Jess could say that she had larger breasts than someone, but in this case she did. She brought her hands up and cupped another woman's bare breasts for the very first time. She rolled her nipples between her fingers, watching as her eyes closed and she tilted her head back in pleasure.

She felt Nick get up from the bed and she looked over at him to see him ripping his shirt off and then pulling his sweatpants down, leaving him in just his blue plaid boxers, his hard cock threatening to pop out of the hole in the front. Jess felt her mouth start to water as she stared at his cock, it was big, the biggest she had ever had and damn, did he know how to use it. She had no idea how she was able to stay away from him for so long.

Nick walked back over to the bed and sat down behind Jess, he moved her hair to one side and wrapped his arms around her waist. He gently started to kiss her neck, watching as she explored her first woman. He brought his hands up to her breasts and squeezed them gently, rolling her nipples between his calloused fingers causing her to arch her back against him. She continued to fondle Reagan's breasts as she brought her mouth back down to hers, slipping her tongue into her mouth.

Suddenly she felt Nick slide his right hand down her stomach and tease the elastic of her pajama pants. He slid his hand into her panties and right into her wet slit faster than she expected. He was slowly teasing her clit with his middle finger causing her to whimper into Reagan's mouth. Suddenly Reagan broke the kiss and looked down to where Nick's hand was stroking her. "God, Jess… I can hear how wet you are."

Reagan slid out from between Jess's thighs and sat in front of her. She kissed Jess gently on the lips before smiling at her wickedly and pulling her legs out straight so she was now leaning against Nick's solid, hairy chest. In one solid motion, she pulled Jess's pajama pants and panties off her body and threw them on the ground, before removing her own.

Jess let her eyes roam over Reagan's body, feeling a pang of jealousy as she took in her perfectly toned figure. That was until she looked up at Nick and saw that he only had eyes for her, she smiled as she watched his eyes roam all over her bare body.

Jess felt Reagan spread her legs and watched as she laid on her stomach between them, while Nick continued to gently kiss and bite his way along her neck, still stroking her clit. She watched in awe as Reagan began to kiss her way up her thighs, eyes locked on where Nick was still stroking. Once she reached his hand, she took it in her own, inspecting his glistening fingers before taking them in her mouth.

"Mmm… So sweet."

"She has the sweetest pussy I've ever tasted." She heard Nick say in her ear, taking her to a whole nother level of arousal. She tilted her head to look up at him, he was watching Reagan in awe and she brought her mouth to Jess's center, dipping her tongue inside a few times before making her way to her clit, licking and swirling her tongue, stopping every once in awhile to gently suck it between her lips.

She squeezed her eyes shut at the first touch of Reagan's tongue, but opened them to find Nick's dark eyes burning into her. She was panting and moaning, going out of her mind at the feel of another woman going down on her, but she couldn't take her eyes off of Nick. He leaned down and gently kissed her. "You look so fucking sexy right now, Jessica." He whispered against her mouth before taking her breasts in his hands and letting his tongue slip past her lips, kissing her slowly and deeply.

Although Jess didn't want this pleasure to end, she wanted to give Nick some pleasure as well, so she sat up and turned towards him. She looked over her shoulder at Reagan. "I think Nick deserves a little something now too." She just smiled at her and laid down, grabbing Jess's hips and pulling her up onto her face, burying her tongue between her folds once again. Jess let out a yelp of pleasure.

"Take your boxers off, Nick." He stood up and quickly pushed his boxers to the floor before kneeling in front of her on the bed. Jess wrapped her arms around his neck and kissed him before making her way down his neck to his hairy chest. She took his hard, pulsing cock in her hand and started to stroke it firmly.

"Fuck! Jess…"

She continued to stroke him until she couldn't take it anymore, she had to feel him in her mouth. She leaned down and licked the entire length before taking him all the way into her mouth, crying out as Reagan simultaneously sucked her clit into her mouth. She sucked Nick hard and fast, taking him deeper than she ever had before.

She could feel her orgasm building as Reagan continued to lick and suck her. The sensations of receiving oral sex while also giving it, the noises she was drawing out of Nick as Reagan moaned against her flesh was too much, she felt her orgasm rip through her body like a tsunami.

She sat up as her entire body started to shake with the most intense pleasure she had ever felt. Nick wrapped his arms around her and kissed her sweetly while she moaned loudly into his mouth as Reagan continued to ride out her orgasm with her, soothing her with her tongue until she stopped trembling.

Jess feels Reagan slide out from her place underneath her and Nick takes her even further into his arms, hugging her tightly to his body and burying his face in her hair. "You okay, Honey?" She wraps her arms around his neck and kisses his forehead, before bringing her hands around to his cheeks, she pulls his head up so she can look into his eyes. They smile at each other, before Nick chuckles and leans in to kiss her.

Reagan is watching from her place on the bed, she can't help the soft smile that spreads across her face as she watches them. Those idiots, they are still crazy in love with each other.

As Nick and Jess continue to kiss, Jess feels Reagan come up behind her and run her hands up her back before pulling her curls to one side and attacking her neck with her lips. She leans in and presses her bare body against Jess's back, the feeling of her bare breasts pressed up against her back makes Jess shiver.

"I want to watch you ride that big cock, Jess."

Jess breaks the kiss and looks deeply into Nick's dark eyes, she smiles at him before pushing him onto his back and straddling his naked body. She runs her hands up and down his hairy chest, eventually letting her right hand reach down and take his cock in her hand, rubbing it against her wet folds before taking him inside of her.

"Nick! Oh god, Nick!"

She begins to ride him, hard. Reagan is still behind her, kissing her neck and teasing her nipples with her fingers, she keeps her left hand on her breast and slides her right hand down to her slit so she can rub her clit as she rides Nick's big dick.

"Does her pussy feel good wrapped around your cock, Nick?"

"God, Yes! I missed you so much, Jess. You feel so fucking good! You're so tight and wet… FUCK!"

Jess can only moan in response as she keeps her eyes locked on Nick's. She reaches around and lets her fingers slide between Reagan's wet folds, wanting to make her feel good too. She slides her fingers in and out of her soaking canal a few times before focusing on her clit, hearing her cry out into her ear as she finds it.

"Fuck, Jess! Oooh, right there. You're gonna make me come!"

"Yes, come for me! I want you both to come for me!"

Jess feels her second orgasm building, ready to explode at any second. Suddenly she hears Reagan cry out loudly and her body tremble against her back as she climaxes. Once she calms down, she begins rubbing Jess's clit even faster, watching over her shoulder as she continues to ride Nick with everything she has.

"Ohh, Nick! I'm so close, are you gonna come for me baby?"

"Yes, Fuck! Jess, I'm coming! UH!"

Jess feels Nick grab her hips tightly as he pumps himself up into her, she feels the hot spurts of his release inside her then her entire world shatters around her. She comes harder than she ever has in her entire life.

"UHH Ohh my… UHHH!" She screams, not even caring if anyone hears her. As she comes to, Nick once again has his arms tightly wrapped around her body as her head rests on his shoulder. Nick slides himself out of Jess's body before gently laying her down next to Reagan, who appears to already be fast asleep. He lays down on the far end of the bed and pulls the blankets up over them, before reaching over and turning off the lamp.

Jess looks up at him with her bright blue eyes and he feels his heart in his throat. God, she's so beautiful. She smiles up at him sleepily and chuckles sweetly. "Well, that was unexpected, but fun… Very fun!" She winks at him, causing him to chuckle.

"Yeah, Jess… I gotta admit, I didn't think you had it in you, but watching you with another woman was the hottest thing I've ever seen. Like, ever."

"About that, I'm sorry I kind of… Stole her from you."

Nick looked deeply into her eyes as he spoke from the heart. "It was just a little crush, Jess. Nothing serious. And I definitely can't be mad when I have you back where you belong."

"And where is it that I belong, Nick?"

"Right here." He says as he pulls her body tightly against his own and kisses her forehead. "I missed you so much, Jess. You're never allowed to leave me again. Not seeing you for a month was torture." She lifts her head from where it was buried in his neck and kisses him sweetly before beaming at him.

"I missed you too, Nick. I promise I won't leave you again." She kisses him once more before burying her head in his neck once more and inhaling his masculine scent that she had missed so much.

"I love you, Nick."

"I love you too, Jess."

Reagan smiled as she heard those whispered words in the dark, still pretending to be asleep.

When Jess woke up in the morning, she looked over to see that Reagan was already gone, but there was a note resting on the pillow she had fallen asleep on the night before. She unfolded the paper and began to read…

Jess,

Thank you so much for letting me rent out your room for the month, it means more to me than you'll ever know. You're very lucky to have such great friends in your life and I am so happy that I was lucky enough to get to know all of them. My only regret is that I didn't get to spend more time with you, although I think we got to know each other pretty well last night, don't you? I will never forget you and your group of crazy and amazing roommates. Thank you so much for everything. I'm also very happy that I could help you and Nick find your way back to each other. He loves you completely, Jessica Day. Don't let that get away again.

Love,

Reagan

P.S, You better invite me to your wedding!

Jess smiles and sets the note on her bedside table. She looks over at Nick, hair sticking out from all angles with a blissful relaxed smile on his sleeping face and feels her heart skip a beat. She snuggles back under the blankets and presses a kiss to his lips. He cracks one eye open before lifting his arm and pulling her tightly against his body as they both fall back to sleep with smiles on their faces.

**I honestly hated Reagan and I'm still super bitter about her coming back at the end of the season, but with all the requests for this story, I figured I would give it a go. I tried to make her as like-able as possible in this story and I hope that I succeeded. And as always, Thank you all so much for reading! Next story will be some hot, rough sex, just have to figure out which storyline I want to use to base it off of! See you next time!**