At the BBQ, they're playing Pictionary and Puck's drawing a picture of a wolf with a tutu.

"Dress! Ballerina!" guesses Emma.

"Puppy! Puppy with a tutu!" guesses Quinn.

"No, no," says Puck.

"A dog! Hound dog!" guesses Emma again.

"'Dances with Wolves'," says Mason.

"Mason wins…again," says Puck with a smirk on his face.

"How is that a wolf?" asks Emma, looking at the picture.

Kurt is in the kitchen, taking the pie out of the box.

Puck joins Kurt in the kitchen. "Aunt Emma is getting a little tipsy."

"Will you stop plying her with alcohol?" pleads Kurt.

Puck shrugs. "I want her to like me."

Kurt sighs. "How is operation Abrams?"

Puck smiles. "He's my new BFF."

Emma comes into the kitchen. "There you are. Isn't this fun?" she asks Kurt.

"Yes, thank you so much for inviting me," says Puck.

"Did I have a choice?" she asks annoyed.

"I know what you must think about me."

"No, you don't. You've never dated you. I have dated many you's."

"I'm a work in progress."

Kurt gives her a cake knife from a set.

Puck sees it. "These are fancy."

"Thank you. My mother's silver set."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"Hearing the truth after a century and a half of denial must be overwhelming," says Kristian, still locked up.

"It wasn't real, I remember you compelling me," says Blaine, still in denial.

"Only after I showed you who I really was. You were so scared of me; I had to take away your fear."

"Well, whatever feelings I had back then, they all turned to hate."

"Love, hate, such a fine line, I can wait. Anyway, George Abrams was causing all sorts of trouble. He used the vampires to cover up his own tracks. He told the founding families about us. But he was willing to strike a deal."

"What kind of a deal?"

"A deal to rid the town of vampires."

1864

Kristian and George are walking on the grounds of the Anderson estate.

"I just spoke to Giuseppe Anderson. The round up happens tonight," George informs Kristian.

"Good. Insist they do a body count before the church is set ablaze."

"I will."

"27 vampires."

"Once the flames create chaos, crawl to the exit under the quire loft. I'll be there to set you free."

"Make sure you're not followed. I need everyone to believe I perished in that fire."

2009

"You knew that they were gonna burn the vampires in the church?" asks Blaine.

"I practically lit the match," replies Kristian, no ounce of remorse in his voice.

"They were your friends, they were your family and you just sold them out."

"Without blinking."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Back at the BBQ, Puck puts the pie on the table along with the cake knife made of silver. "Mason, why don't you start us off?"

"Sure." He takes a piece with his hands, not with the knife. "I apologize, I'm an animal," he laughs awkwardly.

"So, Mason, you and Emma never date?" asks Will.

"She was always lost in Logan Fell land," replies Mason.

"My first mistake. Mason was a catch; he had girls lining up," replies Emma.

"Really? I always pegged you for a lone wolf," says Puck, cutting in.

"I'm sure I wasn't half the lady killer you were," says Mason.

Quinn and Kurt are in the living room.

"Would I be the worst friend in the world if I abandoned you and went to Blaine's?" asks Kurt.

"You want to leave?"

"It's just that he hasn't gotten back to me and I'm starting to get this bad feeling."

"I don't think that's a good idea, Kurt."

"Puck's got it under control here."

"Take it from me, there's nothing worse than a clingy significant other."

"I'm not being clingy, I'm just concerned. You understand, right?"

"How about I drive you?"

"Yeah, okay, that'll be great, thank you."

They leave the house and go to Quinn's car. Kurt gets into car while Quinn deflates a tire then gets into the car.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

"What did George get in return? For giving you your freedom," asks Blaine.

"Something he wanted desperately," replies Kristian cryptically.

Blaine gets down to Kristian's level. "So, you sent 26 of your friends to their death, just to fake your own?" Blaine shakes his head. "No, you were running from something. What was it?"

"Everyone has a past, Blaine. Mine needed to stay far, far away, but thanks to you my plan nearly failed before it even began. Once George told me that the round up was imminent, I made sure I could see you one last time, but your father used your love for me against you. He poisoned your blood. Then Puck being Puck, nearly ruined everything."

1864

Blaine, in 1864, runs back to the cart holding the captured vampires. Both Blaine and Noah grab Kristian out of the cart and untie him. Noah gets shot, and then Blaine gets shot.

2009

"We came for you, we tried to save you," says Blaine.

"I didn't want to be saved," replies Kristian.

"So, then Puck and I died for nothing! For nothing!"

"No, Blaine, you died for love!"

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Puck is in the kitchen and Mason comes in.

"Will just brought out 'Guitar Hero'. Might be time to mutiny," says Mason.

"Well, I just happen to like 'Guitar Hero'. So, you, my friend, are barking up the wrong tree."

"Okay. Enough with the innuendos. You win, you're hilarious."

"Thank you."

"Come on, man. You don't think I know what this barbecue is about?"

"How do you know about me? Your brother was completely clueless."

"It doesn't matter; I'm not your enemy, Puck."

"You tried to kill my brother."

"That was a mistake."

"Really?"

"There was confusion; I couldn't chain myself up in time. I have no control once I shift."

"What, no obedience school?"

"I'm serious. Let's not spark some age-old feud that doesn't apply to us.

"You expect me to believe that you're in Lima because you're homesick?"

"I lost my brother, my nephew lost his father. I'm here for my family. Let's be above this."

They shake hands. Mason leaves and Puck takes a silverware knife from the cutlery box.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Quinn is driving toward the boarding house with Kurt.

"Thanks for this, I appreciate it," says Kurt.

"Here we come, to the rescue," replies Quinn passive aggressively.

"Why are you being so snippy?"

"That's my own drama. I'm sure that you two will beat the odds. Not that there is any study to pull odds from. What is the ratio of success for vampire-human couplings? I'm guessing nil."

"Thanks Quinn."

"Sorry."

Kurt turns up the radio. "I love this song!"

Quinn pushes a button on her steering wheel. "What's playing?"

"'Born this Way' by Lady Gaga."

The tire bursts.

"Oh shit."

Kurt sighs, annoyed.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

The barbeque is winding down.

"No more takers for drinks at the Breadstix? It's like I'm with a bunch of adults here!" says Mason.

"I prefer the term 'role model'," replies Emma.

"Okay. Well, thanks for having me, it was awesome. Will, catch that game next week?"

"Yeah, I look forward to it," says Will.

"You know, I should probably head out too," says Puck.

Mason leaves the house.

Puck kisses Emma's hand. "Emma, you are a wonderful hostess."

"And you are a terrible artist," replies Emma.

"Is that the only thing that makes me terrible?"

"I'm still deciding, Puck."

"Good enough for me. Will, let's not catch that game next week." He leaves, wanting to follow Mason.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

It's now nighttime and Kurt and Quinn are still waiting for the tow truck.

"Are you sure the tow's coming? We've been waiting forever," says Kurt, annoyed.

"I know, it's weird. They said they'd be here by now," replies Quinn, trying to be nonchalant.

"Yeah. I'm just gonna call Emma."

"No! Just let me try the tow people again. And I'll use my aggressive voice."

"We can just walk from here."

"I can't just leave my car!"

"We'll come back for it."

"Just give me a minute, Kurt."

"Quinn, what part of 'I'm worried about Blaine' didn't sink in?"

"What's the rush? Why are you hurrying to get to a relationship that will never work?" asks Quinn curtly.

"Okay, look. I know that you're upset over Sam, but will you stop projecting it onto me and Blaine please?"

"I'm not projecting anything! You're human, he's a vampire. You're gonna be 70 and in diapers and he's still gonna be smoking hot and you will never have children together, Kurt! And you are too paternal to not have children!"

"Where is this coming from?"

"I'm just trying to be your friend."

"Okay, well, do me a favor and stop trying."

The tow truck arrives.

"There's the tow, I'm gonna walk," says Kurt.

"No, Kurt, don't!" She grabs Kurt's arm forcefully.

"Quinn, you're hurting me."

"Don't leave me alone."

"What's wrong with you, Quinn?"

"Hey there, someone called about a flat tire?" asks the tow truck guy.

Quinn lets Kurt's arm go.

Kurt looks at Quinn. "She did." He leaves.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Mason parks his car in the Breadstix parking lot, gets out and is approached by Puck.

"What Puck? More dog jokes?"

"Nah, those got old." He stabs Mason with the silver knife and walks over to and opens the trunk of Mason's car.

Mason struggles and removes the knife from his chest. "You know, I think it was werewolves who started this whole silver myth. Probably for moments like this." Mason closes the trunk of the car.

"Noted."

Mason gets in Puck's face. "I was really looking forward to last call. Now you made an enemy."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Kristian is still tied to the chair in the basement.

"Are you gonna tell me why you came back here or you're just playing another game?" asks Blaine.

"Have you not heard a word that I've said? I've answered that question five times over now."

"Oh good, make it six."

"I want what I want, Blaine and I don't care what I have to do to get it. My list of victims is a long one, and I have no problem adding one more name to that list."

"Come on Kristian. If you wanted Kurt dead, you would have done it by now."

"Still can. If I must, I will snap his neck like a twig and you know it."

Blaine rushes over to Kristian with a stake that he pulled from a chair and hovers over him with it, but he regains control of his senses and throws it away.

"I guess you don't hate me as much as you thought you did. I don't want you seeing Kurt anymore. If you don't remove him from your life, I will kill everyone that he loves while he watches and then I will kill him while you watch."

Blaine rushes over him again and strangles him. Blaine's face has changed and he has a stake in his hands. "Don't you ever think for one moment that I will not kill you."

Kristian throws him against the wall and easily snaps the restraints of his arms and legs. He stands up. "I have been sipping vervain every single day for the last 145 years. You caught me by surprise once, I wasn't gonna let it happen again. It doesn't hurt me, Blaine."

"What? Why?"

"I told you, I missed you Blaine. I just wanted to spend some time with you."

Kurt enters the house. "Blaine?"

Kristian looks at Blaine, smiles and puts a stake in his leg and he leaves. Blaine groans loudly and tries to get the stake out of his leg.

Upstairs, Kurt's in the living room. "Hello? Blaine?" calls Kurt. "Blaine?" He turns around and sees Kristian. He gasps.

"You must be Kurt," says Kristian.

"How is this possible? How do we look exactly alike?"

Kristian doesn't answer, but looks at him from top to bottom. He touches Kurt's neck with a finger as he speaks and walks behind him. "You're asking the wrong questions."

Blaine arrives. "Kurt?!"

Kurt turns his head to look at Blaine. But when he turns back, Kristian's not there anymore.

"Are you okay, baby?" asks Blaine.

"Not really." Kurt sees Blaine's wound. "Are you okay?"

"Not really."

They embrace each other.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

At the Lima Bean, Quinn is in the bathroom washing her hands. She looks in the mirror. Kristian is behind her.

She gasps. "Kristian."

"Care to share how you couldn't follow through with one simple task, Blondie?"

"I tried okay? But I couldn't exactly kidnap my best friend."

Kristian gets in her face. "Occupy him. That's all I asked."

Quinn turns her head away from him. "I told him that his relationship was doomed and all that mortality stuff. I think…I really think that I got to him."

"I hope so because let's not forget." Kristian grabs her face. "I already killed you once; I can easily do it again."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

At the Abrams estate, Artie is searching online about the moonstone as Mason arrives.

"How was that barbecue?" asks Artie.

"Not great. Are you still pissed?"

"Are you still keeping secrets?"

"Yep."

"Then I'm still pissed. Hey, you know I was thinking about that stone you were looking for. I might know a couple places it could be."

"Do you think this is a joke? If you know where it is, tell me."

"Tell me how the curse's trigger."

Mason sighs. "If I tell you, you won't be able to think about anything else. I don't want that for you."

"I think I can handle knowing."

"You think that you can handle it, tough guy? You have no idea."

"You want your stupid rock or not?!"

Mason holds Artie up by collar, lifting him out of his chair. "Tell me where it is!"

"Tell me what triggers the curse!"

"You have to kill somebody! Human blood! You take another person's life away from them and then the curse is yours forever! Can you handle that?"

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Quinn is sitting alone at a table at the Lima Bean. Kurt and Blaine enter.

"Kurt," greets Quinn.

"Hey," replies Kurt.

Blaine goes to a table while Kurt talks with Quinn.

"Oh, my god. I am so sorry about earlier today. I don't know what came over me," says Quinn.

"It's okay, Quinn. Everything that you were saying was right. It's just hard for me to hear, you know?" says Kurt.

"So…you're not mad at me?"

"You were just being a good friend…in your own way."

"My own head case, horrible way. Kurt, I really am sorry."

Kurt smiles and rejoins Blaine at a table.

"I'm starving," says Blaine.

"Well, spending the day with your jealous ex will do that to you," replies Kurt tersely.

"Listen, I know you're upset, but we have to take him seriously. Today, was all about the lengths he would go to."

"If he was going to hurt me, he would have. I was standing right in front of him."

"Kurt, you caught him off guard. It doesn't mean that you're safe."

"I'm not afraid of him."

"Well, you should be."

"If Kristian had his way, we'd be breaking up right now."

"If today taught me anything, is that Kristian is used to getting his way."

Kurt gives Blaine a look. "You're not actually saying that we should what he says?"

"Listen, he's sadistic, okay? He threatened you, he threatened everyone."

"Yeah, no, I get it. He's dangerous. But every day that we are together, it's dangerous," points out Kurt. "Why are you giving him so much power over our relationship?"

"This is the reality of our situation."

"Well, reality sucks."

Quinn is listening to their whole conversation.

Kurt starts crying. "This is what he wants. He wants us to fight. He wants to get between us."

"He already has, Kurt!"

They look at each other and Kurt runs out. Puck is sitting at the counter with a smirk on his face. He's heard everything too.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Later, Puck is going out of the Lima Bean.

Kristian is waiting for him. "Bad day?" he asks, leaning on the wall.

"Bad century. I heard you were on the loose," replies Puck.

"What's the matter? Jealous I spent the day with Blaine?"

"I don't do jealous. Not with you, not anymore."

"Then why so pouty?"

"I tried to kill a werewolf, I failed. Now I feel like I'm not living up to my best self."

"Well, werewolves aren't easy prey."

"What do you know about werewolves?"

"Why don't you ask your brother? Don't try to be the hero, Puck. You'll end up dead."

"Been there, done that. At least this time it'll be worth it." And he walks away.

Kristian looks after him with an annoyed look on his face.

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Kurt goes in his bedroom, getting ready for bed.

Blaine is there. "Are you okay?"

Kurt smiles and embraces him. "I hated that fight."

"I know me too. It felt too real."

Kurt kisses him. "Did you see Quinn?"

"Yeah."

"We were right. Kristian got to her. She was hanging on to every single word."

"It won't be long before Kristian gets a play by play."

"I wish I was wrong, but I know Quinn too well. It was so obvious that something was up today."

"You're not wrong. It's pure Kristian. He's always finding somebody to do his dirty work."

"I think Puck was listening to us fight too. Are you gonna tell him that it wasn't real?"

Blaine sighs. "The only way Kristian is gonna believe it is if everybody believes it. That's the best way to make him think he's getting what he wants."

"All this…just to get you back."

"It's not why he's here, okay? No matter what he says, I know him. Kristian doesn't care about anybody, but himself, he never has. He's incapable of love. He's here for another reason."

NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB~NKB

Kristian is walking alone in the town square. He looks at the three-quarter moon, reminiscing.

1864

Kristian is in the woods. He turns around and sees Noah and Blaine dead on the ground. George Abrams approaches.

"George," greets Kristian.

"Your carriage is just waiting," says George.

"All done, George. Thank you."

"Now onto your part of the deal."

Kristian pulls out the moonstone from his pocket. "If anyone learns of my escape, I will find you and I will kill you. Don't think that I won't." He gives George the moonstone.

"We shall take each other's secrets to the grave. Now, you must hurry." He leaves.

Kristian hesitates, then he runs toward Blaine's body. He touches his face and looks at him. "I love you, Blaine. We'll be together again, I promise." He kisses him.

2009

Kristian touches his lips and smiles.