Fumes43: Aww, I'm sorry I made you hate Abbie in this story. I'm usually a big Abbie fan, myself.

nattie89: Abbie might just get a taste of her own medicine. No bad deed goes unpunished. :)

dove in love: I wish I were wrapped around Abbie's finger just like Serena is. haha.

girlnextdoor15: Liv and Connie are too awesome to not do anything. haha.

Jessica: Abbie's being a bitch, but perhaps she can redeem herself. Or not. haha.


Casey stood by the parking lot before school on Monday morning in hopes that she would see her girlfriend. Abbie had told Serena about Alex's punishment and Serena finally relayed the details to Casey the night before. She knew Alex wasn't allowed to use the phone or visit, so she figured this would probably be the only time other than their lunch period that she would be able to talk to Alex. After five minutes of waiting around, Casey finally spotted Alex getting out of her car with Abbie and Olivia. She was grateful to see that Serena had started getting rides from Connie. Casey felt the less Serena saw Abbie, the better. She noticed that Abbie seemed happier than usual. Her walk was different and Casey could have sworn she was strutting.

As soon as Alex saw Casey, she ran over to her and gave her a hug.

"Honey, I missed you so much," Alex said as she embraced her girlfriend.

"I can't believe I actually get to hear your voice," Casey told her. "I wish I could kiss you right now."

"Wait til after 7th period," Alex said excitedly. "Abbie told me about a secluded make-out spot that she and Serena discovered."

"Are you sure you discovered that spot with Serena?" Casey asked Abbie and Abbie just rolled her eyes.

"What's going on?" Alex asked, completely oblivious to what had happened Saturday night.

"Lex, there's so much we need to fill you in on," Olivia told her.

"No, there isn't," Abbie said and then glared at Olivia. "I have to go to my locker before class starts. I'll see y'all at lunch."

They all watched as Abbie strutted toward their campus in her black, spandex dress. Casey knew she was up to something; she had to be.

"Abbie Carmichael going to her locker ten minutes before class?" Alex asked, confused. "She usually lingers in the parking lot until the last possible second. And why is she dressed that way? Just last Friday, she came to school in leggings and a t-shirt. Today she's in a short dress and her hair is teased. And her make-up? Am I the only one missing something here?"

Casey gave Alex another hug. "Babe, there is so much I have to tell you."


The moment Abbie opened her locker, she fussed with her hair and applied another coat of lipstick. When she finished re-applying her eyeliner, she felt a pair of hands on her waist.

"Miss me?" She heard a guy ask and she immediately knew who it was.

"Trent!" Abbie said excitedly and turned around to give him a hug. "I was hoping you'd show up here."

"Because seeing me in first and fourth period isn't enough?" he asked and she playfully hit him on the arm.

"What am I going to do with you?" she teased.

"I can think of a few things," Trent answered. "You look so hot right now. Why don't we blow off first period so I can have you all to myself?"

"Trent Abernathy, do I have to stick another thumbtack on your chair like I did in 4th grade?" Abbie asked him playfully.

She expected him to laugh, but instead he kissed her right then and there. She knew it was wrong, but Abbie couldn't help but enjoy being kissed by her locker where everyone could see. With Serena, she had to hide, but with Trent she could be openly affectionate and the envy of almost every girl at school.

"What are you doing Friday night?" he asked her.

"Going to your game," Abbie responded even though she had plans with Olivia.

"That's my girl," Trent said and then kissed her again. "We're cool with what happened Saturday, right?"

Abbie started smiling. "Trent, for the last time, yes. I wanted to."

"Cool. You busy after school today?" He asked.

"Well, I'm supposed to babysit my little sister," Abbie answered.

"Get someone to cover for you," he urged her. "I have the house to myself until 8. It'll just be me and you."

Abbie knew her parents would want a good explanation why she wouldn't be able to stay with her sister, but she figured she could come up with an excuse before the end of the school day. Trent Abernathy was asking her to keep him company at his house today and there was no way she'd say no to him.

"I'll just get my sister Addie to do it," Abbie said. "She owes me anyway."

"I knew you were down for anything," Trent told her. "That's one of the things I like so much about you."

Abbie couldn't help but blush after hearing that. She pulled Trent closer to her and kissed him.

"Hey, Trent!" Abbie heard a girl say, interrupting their kiss.

"Oh, hey, Connie," Trent said to the girl and Abbie wanted to hide. "What's up?"

"Not much," Connie replied. "I just thought I'd say hi before I go to class. I'm supposed to meet my friend Serena right now so we can walk together."

For the first time in her high school career, Abbie wished she could squeeze herself into her locker and hide there for the rest of the day. She wondered how much Connie had seen and heard. Then she realized it didn't matter. Connie was going to tell Serena everything, regardless.

Abbie hoped Connie would leave them alone, but instead she stayed there and looked at Trent. "Would you excuse us?" she asked him. "Abbie and I have to talk about girl stuff."

"Yeah," Trent replied. "No problem. Abbie, I'll see you in class."

"Abbie, what do you think you're doing?" Connie asked. "You really hurt Serena."

Abbie started to scoff. "Serena knew I wasn't her girlfriend. I'm free to date whoever I want and now I'm dating Trent."

"I don't know why I'm telling you this after you hurt one of my best friends, but watch out," Connie warned her. "I'm a cheerleader so I know a thing or two about the football players at this school. Trent doesn't really like you. You're just his September slut. My squad captain says he has a new girl each month. So, don't come crying to Serena when he breaks your heart in October."

"He's not my boyfriend," Abbie informed her. "So it's not like he could break my heart."

"I don't care," Connie told her. "And, by the way, you look like a slut."


When lunchtime arrived, Serena felt bad that her friends sat with her instead of eating lunch with their girls. Connie assured her that she could always see Olivia outside of school, but Serena knew that Casey didn't have that luxury with Alex.

"It's okay," Casey assured her. "Alex and I will find time and once she hears what happened I'm sure she'll understand."

"You girls are the best," Serena said and then gave them a hug. She's close to tears, but she didn't want her friends to know.

Serena glanced a few tables over and saw Abbie talking to Alex and Olivia. She put her lunch away and started to cry.

"Quad?" Casey suggested and she and Connie led Serena to the quad area, where they could be alone.

Once they sat down, Serena rested her head on Casey's shoulder and Connie held her hand.

"So, tell me about Claudia," Connie said in an attempt at changing the subject. "Did you go out with her yesterday?"

"No," Serena said, disappointed. "I didn't get home from Abbie's until 5 and by the time I was able to call her she was already heading back to Yale. But we're probably going to hang out sometime next month."

"Why the hell would you stay at Abbie's so late?" Casey asked.

"Please don't tell me you had sex with her," Connie added.

"It's Abbie," Serena said, frustrated. "Of course I did. We sixty-nined each other and everything."

"What's that?" Casey and Connie asked in unison.

"You girls are so innocent," Serena said. She was able to start smiling once she realized how virginal her friends were. "It's when two people go down on each other and the same time."

"That's possible?" Connie asked.

"How?" Casey asked, intrigued.

"You guys," Serena groaned.

"Sorry," Connie replied. "But Casey and I have to live vicariously through you."

"Yeah," Casey added. "Remember, I've never made it past second base."

"And I haven't been up to bat in a few months," Connie said, feeling embarrassed.

"Sex isn't that great," Serena said to her friends as she started crying again. "It complicates everything."

"Then why do you do it?" Casey asked.

"Because she's gorgeous and I thought if I did it with her, she'd want to be with me," Serena sobbed. "You don't see what I see in Abbie. When it's just the two of us we get along great, even when we're not having sex. She holds me and we tell each other things that we don't tell anyone else."

"She thinks of you as her girl toy," Casey said to her. "Alex told me."

"I'd rather be her girl toy than nothing to her," Serena said as she started sobbing even more. "I love Abbie Carmichael and I'm not going to give up on her. Trent doesn't know how to make love to her. She told me that it hurt when he was inside her. She didn't have an orgasm with him, but she had one with me. That just proves she should be with me."

"Because of an orgasm?" Connie asked. "I just can't believe you went down on her after she had sex with someone else. I hope he used a condom."

"Of course he did," Serena told them. "Do you honestly think Abbie is that stupid?"

Casey and Connie exchanged glances. They both knew how they wanted to answer that question, but because one of their best friends was crying hysterically, they decided to hold their comments.


It was the moment Alex had been dreading for over a week; the moment she had to be naked in front of Casey and dozens of other girls. She hurried into the girls' locker room as soon as her sixth period class ended. Her goal was to put her bathing suit on before Casey arrived, but she soon realized that Casey had beat her there.

"Hi," Alex said nervously.

"Hey," Casey responded as she began digging for her bathing.

There were so many things Alex wanted to do in that moment. She wanted to hide in her locker, she wanted to have her way with Casey in one of the shower stalls, but most importantly she wanted to…

"I think I'm going to be sick," Alex said and then covered her mouth as she ran to the bathroom stalls.

Casey followed right behind her and was shocked to hear the sound of Alex vomiting in the bathroom.

"Lex, are you okay?" Casey asked as she knocked on the door.

"I think so," Alex responded. "Ask Mrs. Simmons if I could go to the nurse's office."

As soon as she was holding that pass in her hand, Alex was grateful that Mrs. Simmons let her go to the nurse's office instead of dressing out for P.E. She was even more grateful that Casey was able to go with her to ensure she made it there okay.

"What happened, babe?" Casey asked as they made their way over to the nurse.

"I think it was something I ate," Alex answered her. "I had a tuna sandwich for lunch."

"But tuna has always made you throw up, ever since you were a little girl," Casey said, confused.

"I know," Alex told her and Casey could see her girlfriend start smiling.

"You did that on purpose?" she asked.

"I had to!" Alex responded. "I'm still nervous about changing into my bathing suit in front of you."

Casey started laughing. "This is one of the reasons I love you so much. What do you have planned for tomorrow?"

"Tomorrow is your turn," Alex told her and Casey looked surprised.

"No way!" Casey replied. "I can't fake an illness. Campbell is already on to me for my beanie and my skateboard."

"Fine, but you owe me," Alex teased. "Make out session right after school today in that secluded spot Abbie told me about."

"Deal," Casey said with a huge smile on your face. "But only under one condition."

"What's that?" Alex asked.

Casey wrapped an arm around her girlfriend. "After everything that happened in the locker room, promise me you'll brush your teeth first."