A/N: Here's the new chapter, guys . Sorry for the late update, school is literally the main reason why I haven't had the time to sit down and write my heart out like I would want to and I'm currently on spring break right now so I should be able to give you guys more chapters. I'll be updating "The Way You Look At Me" soon and I also have another fic in the works. Other than that, Read. Enjoy. Review :)

- C.P


Chapter 8: Unthinkable

Mike's POV


I was on the phone with Tina. She asked me, if we could hang out today but I told her I couldn't. I was supposed to go ring shopping with Mila today. I hated making up excuses and lying to her about things like this. But in the end, it'll be worth it, right?

"I'm sorry, babe. I can't go today, I have to go to this family thing," I said.

"It's okay. But how long do you think that family thing is going to last?" She asked.

"Maybe all afternoon, I don't know. But I'll call you as soon as I get back and we'll see if we have time to hang out still. Is that okay?" I replied.

"Sounds good,"

"Well, I got to go now. Bye, love you,"

"Love you too, bye." She said as we both hanged up.


My sister and I were walking across the parking lot to the entrance of the Lima Mall. That's when the butterflies flooded my stomach.

"Mila, are you sure about this? What if we get caught?" I asked nervously.

"Would you calm down? We're not going to get caught? Our parents know, so there's nothing to worry about," She said with a very strict tone in her voice.

"I'm not worried about Mom & Dad. Lima's a small town and everyone knows everyone, pretty much. What if some McKinley kids see us? Are you forgetting that the only people that know you here asides from your family are Puck, Sam, Artie, and Finn?" I complained.

"Dude, we're related and I'm pretty sure it's noticeable. So I don't think anyone is going to even go there," she said as she rolled her eyes at me.

We went straight to Kay Jewellers. Our plan was get in, get the ring, and get out.

"So…where is this ring?" She asked.

"Right there, "I said as I pointed to it.

The ring was a clear-cut diamond with accents on a silver band. To me, it was different yet beautiful. Just like Tina.

"Okay, let's get it and let's go," she said firmly.

I just nodded in agreement and asked the clerk to get the ring from the glass case. I'm not even going to mention the price because my love for Tina is priceless. It's cheesy but it's true. Mila and I made our way to the store exit.

"Can I see it, please?" She begged in a childlike voice.

"Can you stop acting like your 10, please?" I asked.

She just stuck her tongue out at me as I handed her the velvet black box. We stood in front of the store as we stared at the ring in awe.

"She's going to love it," she said as she looked up and smiled at me.

Then all of a sudden…


"How can you do this to me?"

Mila and I turned around and saw Tina. She had that same look on her face as when she was singing My Funny Valentine to me during our Valentine's Day assignment in Glee. The look when she was trying to hold back her tears. As soon as I stepped forward to comfort her and to explain what was going on. She made a run for it and all that was on my mind was this can't be good.