It had been about a month since the wedding. Jason had moved back to Hong Kong, Piper had had Chris, Paige and Richard were still together, Chris was almost killed by Gideon but Cole was there to save him.

"Oh God. No this can't happen. Oh my God." Phoebe cried. She was sitting in the bathroom. There was a pregnancy test in her hand. It was positive. "All the summoning fireballs and having strange powers, I should've known"

"PIPER!!!! We gotta talk"

"Ok but shhhh I just got Chris to sleep." She said as she rocked Chris.

"There is no easy way to say this. Do you remember when that demon attacked me and Cole saved me??"

"Yeah..what about it??"

"Well.....after you left for work ummm.....I ummmm..... me and Cole kinda......did something that I regret.."

Pipers jaw dropped. Her face paled.

"YOU HAD DID IT WITH COLE?!?!"

"Yes but I found some of that memory dust in the attic and used it on him so he doesn't remember and now I'm pregnant!!"

"Jesus Christ!!! Do you know what your going to do??"

"I'm gonna go tell Cole...but Piper please don't tell anybody.......at least not yet."

Cole had been working at the dining room table on his laptop. Since the wedding he had gotten a job as a lawyer. He heard the elevator and went to see who it was. Phoebe walked in.

"What are you doing here??" he grumbled.

"I have something to tell you....I'm pregnant."

"That's great....tell the father I said congratulations."

"Ummmm.... you're the father."

"That's weird because I THOUGHT YOU HAD TO HAVE SEX TO GET PREGNANT!!!"

"The thing is....we did. But the next morning I woke up and it was a mistake so I sprinkled memory dust on you and now you don't remember."

"Hah! That's one I haven't heard yet."

"What?! Do you honestly think that I'm joking?!"

"I think you want me to think that I'm the father so that you don't have to deal with any shit from Jason. That's what I think."

"Ok then how can I summon fireballs??"

"I don't know and frankly I don't give a damn."

Cole began to walk away until he heard Phoebe say....

"Yes you do. You want this baby to be yours....you want me to run back to you and ask you for help and for protection but guess what!! I don't need your fucking help!! I have my sisters and they will take of me and this baby and I don't want the baby to know you because you'll probably turn it evil!! I HATE YOU AND I WISH YOU WOULD'VE STAYED DEAD!!!" after she said this she began to cry uncontrollably

Cole stood with his mouth open. He felt tears stinging his eyes. He didn't want her to say anything else because it hurt so much.

"Tell me something will you??" Cole asked in a gentler tone, "How bad was I, I mean when I did those things.."

"You were awful, you created a reality where Paige had never been born. It was a twisted reality where you and I were married. It was horrible. You kidnapped me and sent a shapeshifter so you could take control of the manor. You made bad things happen to Piper Paige and me. You were totally insane......but I still didn't want to vanquish you..deep down if it had been totally up to me, we wouldn't have gone through with it. It took a little bit for me to get over you."

"I'm sorry" he quietly said

She glared at him.

"Is it too much to ask for your forgiveness?!" He shouted

"No its not too much to ask!! I just can't forgive you like that. Everytime I see you all the hurt comes back!! I completely trusted you. You were my husband damnit!! I loved you!! And you did those things!! I know the seer tricked you but that's not enough!!"

Phoebe stormed out of the penthouse. It had begun to rain. Suddenly without anyone noticing, Phoebe disappeared.