Allyssa: (Flips hair) What?

Jack: Nothin'...it's just...ye've been "Elisabet-fied". Ye don't have to do that ye know?

Norrington: Alright! Take your seasts, please! I have something to say and very little time to say it. This is my last day here as I am no longer permitted to give you your pirating lessons. I want to thank you for sharing your enthusiasm, your essays, not matter how feebly structured, and even, on occasion, your lunch.

Barbossa: Commodore Norrington! I'm so sorry, mate.

Allyssa: Cap'n, we've got to do something.

Norrington: Miss Allyssa, they can take away my job, but I shall continue to live as a pirate...They are not telling you everything! Remember that! Remember that...

Allyssa: Commodore Norrington! Well, are you just going to sit here in silence?

Barbossa: Miss Allyssa, there's nothin' we can do. Take yer seat.

Cameo: Good afternoon!

Barbossa: Good afternoon.

Cameo: Every day, with every tick of the Time Dragon Clock, in every corner of Tortuga, one hears the silence of progress. For example; this is called a cage! Now, we will be seein' more and more of 'em in the future. This remarkable innovation is actually for betrayers' own good...

Allyssa: If this is good for them, then why is the dog trembling?

Cameo: He's just excited to be 'ere, that's all! Now, as I was sayin', one of the benefits of cagin' a dog while 'e's young is that he never, in fact, can run and betray, just like the ex-Navy men.

Allyssa: What?

Cameo: That's right. Come closer!

Allyssa: Can you imagine a world where people are kept in cages? So they can't betray others? It's so silly.

Cameo: Now, he may seem a bit agitated but that's easily remedied.

Allyssa: What should I do?

Jack: I don't know.

Allyssa: Well, somebody has to...Do Something!!!!

(Everyone moves uncontrollably except Jack and Allyssa)

Jack: What's happenin'?

Allyssa: I don't know...I got mad and...

Jack: Alright, just don't move! And don't get mad at me...(Grabs cage) Well are ye comin'?

Allyssa: Careful! Don't shake him!

Jack: I'm not!

Allyssa: We can't just let him loose anywhere, you know. We have to find someplace safe...

Jack: Don't ye think I know that? Ye must really think I'm stupid or somethin'!

Allyssa: No, not really stupid.

Jack: Why is it, every time I see ye, ye're causin' some sort o' commotion?

Allyssa: I don't cause them, I am one.

Jack: That's for sure.

Allyssa: Oh! So you think I should just keep my mouth shut? Is that what you're saying?

Jack: No, I'm...

Allyssa: Do you think I want to be this way? Do you think I want to care this much? Don't you know how much easier my life would be if I didn't?

Jack: Don'cha ever let anyone else talk?

Allyssa: Oh, sorry...but can I just say one more thing? You could have just walked away back there.

Jack: So?

Allyssa: So, no matter how shallow and self-absorbed you tend to be...

Jack: Excuse me, there be no pretense 'ere. I 'appen to be genuinely self-absorbed and deeply shallow.

Allyssa: No you're not. Or you wouldn't be so unhappy.

Jack: Fine, if ye don't want me help...

Allyssa: No, I do! Poor little poochie. It's heart is trembling...I didn't mean for...

Jack: What did ye mean to do? Why was I the only one ye didn't do it too?

Allyssa: Oh, look, you're bleeding...it must have scratched you.

Jack: Aye, or maybe it scratched me...I better get to safety...I mean the dog...get the dog to safety.

Allyssa: Jack...

(Sung)

Hands touch

Eyes meet

Sudden silence

Sudden heat

Hearts leap in a giddy whirl

He could be that boy

But I'm not that girl

Don't dream too far

Don't lose sight of

Who you are

Don't remember that rush of joy

He could be that boy

But I'm not that girl

Every so often

We long to steal

To the land of "What-might-have-been"

But that doesn't soften the ache we feel

When reality sets back in

Blithe smile, lithe limb

She who's winsome, she wins him

Gold hair with a gentle curl

That's the girl he chose

And heaven knows

I'm not that girl

Don't wish

Don't start

Wishing only wounds the heart

I wasn't born for the rose and pearl

There's a girl I know

He loves her so

I'm not that girl...