Jackie sits back on the couch and stares at the pile of discarded board games, all rejected by her group of friends who deem them too lame to actually play. After spending the previous day running around town buying these games, she is annoyed that none of her friends want to play them. She crosses her arms across her chest and tries to be patient as they figure out what to do.

"Oooh I got it," Fez starts as he jumps up from his seat enthusiastically, "candyland" he says. The suggestion elicits several groans and shaking heads as everyone else disapproves of the suggestions.

"Fez, the idea is to play games that aren't lame, that's why we haven't played any of these" Eric exclaims, pointing at the games in front of him.

"Lame? Lame!? Candyland is not lame you sonofabitch. It's filled with delicious, sweet goodies" Fez says offended.

"Fez man, you know there's no actual candy in the game right?" Hyde adds.

Fez turns to look at Hyde and glares at him.

"Uh.." Kelso says and everyone turns in time to see him counting the people in the room with his index finger. Jackie scrunches her face in confusion, bracing herself for whatever idiocy Kelso was coming up with. "There's eight of us Fez, only four people can play Candyland" Kelso says.

Huh Jackie thinks and nods his head. Not so stupid after all.

Fez takes a look around the room and starts to mentally count the people around him. This takes a little longer than the others would have liked but when he finally realizes that there are in fact more than four people in the room, he reclaims his seat in disappointment.

"It really shouldn't be this hard to choose a game to play" Donna says. She did not leave the Forman's basement to go sit somewhere else. She could also see how annoyed Jackie is that her game night is not going according to plan. "Let's just pick one to start off and we'll go from there" she suggests.

Everyone thinks for a moment and eventually start throwing around suggestions.

"Hide and seek"

"Red light green light"

"Tag...TAG!" Kelso says.

"NO," Jackie quickly interrupts. "You are not playing tag in my house. They'll be nothing left standing by the time you leave." She can just picture what a disaster it would be if she let Kelso and Fez run around her apartment, destroying everything in their path just so they can tag each other. That and they'll probably take whatever opportunity possible to be pervy and touch the girl's behinds.

"See what I mean about you always ruining the fun?" Kelso says which makes Jackie rolls her eyes.

"Never have I ever" Taylor says quietly.

"What?" Matthew asks.

"Never have I ever" Taylor repeats, louder this time.

"I like it" Donna says.

Eric and Matthew nods while Jackie stays silent. She looks around the room and notices that Hyde is stoic and doesn't immediately agree with the idea. Perhaps, like her, he knows that the only way that game could end is in disaster as everyone starts exposing secrets and getting progressively more drunk.

"How do you play that?" Kelso asks.

Taylor appears to cheer up a bit as people are going with her idea. She gladly starts explaining the game to Kelso. "We all have a drink in front of us and take turns making a statement, but whatever you say has to be something you have never done. So I would say I have never traveled out of the country. Whoever has gone out of the country has to drink and if no one has then I have to drink" she explains.

"Ah hah..." Kelso exclaims but everyone can see the confusion in his face so Donna tries to explain the game in a way he would understand.

"Kelso, if I say something and you've done it drink. If you haven't done it, don't drink. Got it?"

"Got it big red" he says.

"Fez?" Donna asks, hoping the foreign friend doesn't need further explanations.

"Got it" he replies much to her relief.

"Does everyone need a beer for the game?" Matthew asks.

Eric, Donna and Jackie raise their hands and Matthew stands up to grab them a beverage. Jackie looks after her boyfriend, grateful that he is so helpful and seems to be fitting in with her friends. A few seconds later he comes back balancing four cans of beer, one for each person who needs one and one for himself. He sits next to Jackie and places his left hand on her knee, giving them a little affectionate squeeze. Jackie smiles and turns over and kisses his cheek. Matthew looks at her and smiles before popping open his can. "Who's going to start?" he asks.

Across from them, Hyde watches the interaction tensely and he swigs some of his beer.

"I'll start with the question I used in my example," Taylor starts. "Never have I ever been out of the country" she says and looks around the group to see who takes a drink. Only Eric and Matthew gulp back their beer.

"Where did you go?" Donna asks Matthew.

"Spain" he replies.

"What's in Spain?" Hyde asks curiously, his eyebrows raised above the top of his aviators.

"It was a business trip" Matthew replies.

"What kind of business you in?" Hyde pushes on and he can feel Jackie glaring at him from across the table but he ignores her.

"Marketing. It's a family business so I'm still trying to get the hang of it but it's good so far" Matthew answers with a quick nod.

Hyde slowly nods his head up and down a few times. Though he is wary of this game, he can use it as an opportunity to get to know the guy in front of him, if for anything else to see the person who might join their group, though Hyde doubts it.

"I'll go" Donna volunteers. "Never have I ever been a cheerleader" she says and looks directly at Jackie with a smile.

Jackie shrugs her shoulders and takes a sip of beer and is surprised when Taylor does also. "You were!?" she asks enthusiastically, "where?"

"Over at Our Lady of Perpetual Sorrow" Taylor says, "it was hard cheering for a school with such a sad name, but we managed" she continues with a laugh.

"Our Lady..." Donna jumps into the conversation. "It was a sad place" she says, laughing along with Taylor.

"Such a small world, two cheerleaders in the same room!" Jackie says.

"I need to get out of Wisconsin" Eric says as he realizes just how small the state really is. Hyde nods his head in agreement.

"My turn" Fez says. "Never have I ever had sex with someone in this group." Everyone around him drinks their beer and Fez frowns. "Look at that, Fez is left out yet again."

"Wait, you mean you didn't sleep with Jackie when you two dated?" Hyde says, surprised.

"Ew" Jackie exclaims.

"Hey!" Fez says giving her an offended look. "She wouldn't let me touch her fun parts so no, we never did it."

"That's because we dated for like a week and you were always being a pervert."

"You knew that before you agreed to be my girlfriend."

"He has a point" Eric interrupts.

"You dated him?" Matthew asks.

"Oh you didn't know? Well this should be fun" Hyde says and he sits back on his chair looking amused.

"Shut up Hyde" Jackie says, finally acknowledging him since they sat down. "Technically I did date Fez, but we only kissed like twice so it doesn't even really count" Jackie says looking at Matthew, hoping he would not be mad for not telling her. He looks from Fez to Jackie and seems satisfied with her response. Besides, he can't bring himself to be jealous of the foreigner, who seems incredibly harmless and naive. He nods his head and presses his lips against Jackie's forehead.

Not satisfied with how anti-climactic that was, Hyde decides to have make things more interesting. "Never have I ever..." he says and pauses to look around the group. He sees everyone patiently waiting to see what he would say, figuring anything Hyde hasn't done they haven't either. He finally stops when his eye fall on Jackie and he sees her eyes widen. She can anticipate that he's up to no good. He likes that she can still predict what he's up to, and he wasn't going to disappoint.

"Never have I ever..." he starts again, "dated more than one person in this room."

Jackie narrows her eyes, sending death glares in his direction. Slowly, she lips her beer can to her lips and takes a small sip. She can sense Matthew turning to look at her, his stare burning deep into her skin. She can't bear to turn and face him. They're both probably embarrassed now and she can't bring herself to explain things to him, especially when she should have given him a heads up before everyone arrived. "Oh, by the way honey, you'll be surrounded by three of my ex-boyfriends." She should have said that, but didn't, and now she's stuck.

Hyde purses his lips, trying not to smirk. He knows he's upped the ante and that everyone around him can feel the tension he created, but he doesn't care. It serves her well for throwing her happy little relationship in everyone's face. Perfect life, perfect boyfriend...yeah right.

"Jackie?" Matthew says quietly, not wanting everyone else to hear but the deafening silence in the room makes that impossible.

Jackie has no choice but to turn and look at her boyfriend, her face flushed with shame and all she can bring herself to say is "I'm sorry...I should have told you."

"Um...never have I ever reached the top of the rope at gym class" Eric says in an attempt to alleviate the tension. Donna puts her hand on his shoulder and offers him a small smile to show her appreciation for this gesture.

Everyone in the room drinks with the exception of Jackie, Eric and Taylor.

"You're in good company Eric" Kelso says before bursting out into a loud laughter. Eric leans over towards where Kelso is sitting and frogs him as hard as possible.

For the next several minutes, everyone takes turns saying "never have I evers" but the tension between Jackie, Matthew and Hyde would not let up. Jackie knew Matthew was upset and she couldn't blame him. He was basically ambushed by her asshole ex-boyfriend who reveled in everyone else's misery.

"Never have I ever" Hyde says, finally speaking up after several rounds of having passed. Immediately, Jackie tenses up and is silently praying that he won't say anything that will be more damaging to her relationship. "...Gone to a wedding and pretended to be married" he said. Jackie clenches her jaw and drinks. Once again, she can see Matthew looking at her from the corner of her eyes but this time, he doesn't say anything.

Again, everyone goes around trying to lighten up the situation, until it was Hyde's turn. "...Given someone an ultimatum to marry them" he says and this time he didn't look around the room but kept his eyes on Jackie. Jackie looked at Taylor sitting next to Hyde and could see how embarrassed she felt. Here is the guy who she's been dating and instead of enjoying his time with her and letting her into his circle of friends, he is focusing his attention on making his ex-girlfriend look bad.

As bad as she felt for Taylor and as embarrassed as she was for Matthew, she was mostly angry. Angry that Hyde would come to her house with the sole intention of hurting her and possibly destroying her relationship. This is just further prove that the indiscretion that happened between them was the biggest mistake she has made since the time she decided to start a relationship with him in the first place.

"How about it Jackie, not going to drink up?" Hyde asks, a smirk now wide across his face.

"Never have I ever cheated on someone with a slutty nurse...never have I ever failed to be there when my partner needed me the most...never have I ever had a whore stripper for a wife...Never have I ever been a complete fucking idiot" Jackie said angrily, her voice raising with each statement she made and on the last one, she was up on her feet, leaning across the table looking directly at Hyde. Her tone spewed all the hate she had been harboring for him since he got back from Vegas with his stripper wife and threw their relationship in her face. Every horrible emotion that had been bubbling inside her had just been unleashed on him and she had never felt so good.

She didn't have to look around to know that all eyes were on them and that there was no way she could safe game night. Her special night has been ruined, just as she suspected it would be when Hyde first stepped through the threshold of her apartment. She just hoped to hell that that was all that was ruined and that she didn't just hit the last nail on the coffin of her relationship with Matthew.

As her chest heaves up and down from the adrenaline of having told him off, Hyde simply sits back calm on the chair and stares at her through his brown shades. Though impressed by the outburst and her finally coming out and saying everything she's wanted to for two years, he isn't about to let her win.

"Never have I ever slept with an ex-girlfriend while dating someone else...oh wait" he says and brings his can near his mouth. "You might want to drink up too" he tells Jackie before chugging back a large amount of beer. He sees her eyes widen and just behind her, Matthew finally speaks up.

"Jackie, what the fuck is he talking about?"

Author's Note: I want to thank Prissy (Nannygirl) for giving me the idea of "never have I ever" for this chapter!