Carry Me Home Tonight
Chapter Eight
Finn's eyes opened to a crash coming from the kitchen. He reached out for Rachel but his bed was empty, he sat up and noticed that it was just him in the room. Not even Max was lying at the foot of the bed, Finn groaned and stood up, throwing on some basketball shorts and itching his head lazily.
"Rach." He called groggily as he walked to the kitchen, "What are you-" He stopped in his tracks noticing his house was full of people. Full of ex-mermaids.
Kurt and Ariel were at the kitchen table and Melody was dancing in the living room while Eric was frying up some eggs in the kitchen with Rachel, he looked to be teaching her how to cook and she was thoroughly engrossed.
Rachel turned around as Finn backed up slowly into the bedroom, "Hi love." She chirped happily, running towards him. She jumped in his arms and he pulled them both into the bedroom shutting the door quickly, "What's wrong?"
"I'm half naked." Finn said, pulling away.
Rachel nodded, "I know, I like it. Can you do that thing with your mouth to me before breakfast?" She asked, biting her lip in anticipation.
Finn choked in surprise, "Rachel, baby, that's private stuff. We have company."
Rachel furrowed her eyebrow, "It's just Ariel and Kurt. No big deal." She giggled and put her hands down the front of his shorts. "See, you're ready."
Finn backed away from her again, "Well when you talk like that I get excited but we can't do that with people in the house."
Rachel pouted, "You're no fun." She whimpered walking towards him again, her hand reaching to cup his package and Finn moved out of her way, "Fiiiiiiiinn" She whined. "Please."
Finn licked his lips nervously as he attempted to get out of her way again tripping and falling on the bed, giving Rachel and chance to jump on him and straddle him. Finn was rock hard underneath her and was beginning to think it wasn't such a bad idea. Rachel leaned over him, whispering in his ear, "I'm not wearing underwear."
Within moments, Finn rolled them both over, pulled off his shorts and had his hand over her mouth as he began to enter her, "Not a peep." He murmured, "Promise me."
Rachel nodded and he kept his hand over her mouth until he completely entered her, she titled her head back in ecstasy and bit his hand and thrust into him. Their pace was rapid and needy and Finn found himself biting down on her neck to silence his own cries.
It was over in moments, both were sweating and his cum was dripping out of her onto her dress as she finished riding out her orgasm.
Finn smirked at his small girlfriend and pulled out of her reluctantly, "You are nothing if not persistent." He told her with a wink and kissed her cheek, "But I sure do love you."
Rachel giggled and pulled off her dress and looked for a new one to throw on, "You better." She teased, "Go get showered and dressed and then we can eat. Eric is making Ranch Eggs or something."
Finn thought for a moment before correcting her, "Huevos Rancheros?" He asked.
Rachel nodded and scampered over to kiss him, "That's it. You, Finn Hudson are just so smart." She said with a cute shrug before making her way back with the group. Finn shook his head and got ready.
The rest of the day was spent exchanging stories and ideas. Ariel suggested that Rachel be honest about the baby and the seawitch and that the King could over throw her but Rachel was reluctant.
"You'll have to be on earth." Ariel told her, "For the birth."
Finn grabbed Rachel's hand and kissed it, "I'd like you to stay for always, Rach."
Rachel frowned, "But I'd miss Daddy so much."
Ariel shook her head, "You can visit him and vice versa, but you really should live with Finn and the baby."
"Won't the baby be magic like Melody?" Kurt asked from the couch, he was braiding her hair and she was painting his toenails.
"The baby will be magic." Eric said, "But there is no telling what kind of abilities she or he might have. She might not be able to turn as an infant and you should really keep her in a stable environment at first."
Melody piped up, "But we'll help you go back and forth." She offered, "If the little one can't."
Eric laughed, "Yeah, but we might have to move here. My tire shop can't run without us forever."
Ariel nudged Eric, "Burt is taking good care of it, Eric. Relax."
Rachel seemed sad, "So I have to choose." She said, it wasn't a question. It was a realization.
"You'll be happy here." Ariel promised.
Finn nodded and pulled her into his side, "I'm going to make you really happy, I promise." He murmured and rubbed her arm and she shook her head and looked at Kurt.
"But what about you, Kurt?"
Kurt seemed dumbfounded, Rachel had tears in her eyes at this point and Finn was trying so hard to wipe them away, "Where will you be?"
Kurt's mouth dropped open, he didn't want to answer her, "Rachel… you know I'll be in the-"
KNOCK! KNOCK!
Melody jumped and Rachel let out a sad sigh. "Open the door, sweetheart." Ariel asked Melody and she looked at the floor.
"I can't Mama." She groaned, attempting to clean up the nail polish she spilled into the carpet. Kurt stood, maneuvering around her to open the front door for her.
"Hey-" Blaine's voice emerged from the open door and Finn stood up quickly, walking towards it, "I'm sorry, is Finn around?"
"Oh." Kurt said, obviously flustered as he took Blaine's outstretched hand and attempted a grin.
"Hey man." Finn said, opening the door and trying to push Kurt aside, to no avail. Kurt's eyes were wide and his lips were curled up just a bit in a sly smith, "This is Rachel's friend Kurt."
Blaine smiled at Kurt in his dreamy way and shook his hand once again. Kurt didn't let go, obviously not familiar with the pleasantries of a handshake. "Kurt." Finn called awkwardly, "Maybe go help Melody?"
Kurt finally released his grip on Blaine's hand and turned away reluctantly. He was very clearly starstruck. "Sorry, brother. What's going on?"
Blaine looked Finn up and down with a chuckle, "Uh, you forgot." Blaine said with an incredulous look.
Finn's head fell backwards, "Shit, Blaine. I'm sorry."
Blaine rolled his eyes, "It's fine just get your stuff and we'll play some volleyball."
"Volleyball?" Melody asked stupidly, "You play volleyball?"
"Every month." Blaine answered matter-of-factly, "Who are you?" Blaine asked the girl with a raised eyebrow.
Finn shook his head, "That's Rachel's…" He trailed off, "Niece. Her sister is in town. It was a surprise to us too, sorry." He rambled, "But I'll catch the next game?" Finn said nodding his head and beginning to shut the door. Blaine's hand stopped him.
"You're kickin' me out?" He scoffed, "If we're going to ditch volleyball at least invite me in for a beer?"
Rachel jumped up and grabbed Finn's hand, "Yeah, invite him in." She looked at Kurt, "We'll have fun, right Kurt?"
Kurt nodded, "Come on it, Blaine." He said nervously.
Blaine chuckled, "Great. I'll call Sam and Mercedes too." He said with a grin, "We'll make a night of it."
Finn's face fell in frustration, "Perfect. Sounds… just… perfect…"
