Hey guys,so sorry this is late(That is all on me,AllyJoy!) We hope you guys enjoy this chapter and if so,please let us know by reviewing! We want to thank you all for your comments and also a quick shout-out to JessDaniel13 for a brilliant idea that we will be using later on in the story! We love you all for reading and reviewing!

Happy Reading:)

The team worked silently for awhile before Gideon realized something, "Reid is hiding another secret."

"What do you mean?" Elle asked as she shoved Derek's file away from her.

"The unsub,he said something. He said, 'I'll take that for now but I suggest you're more open in the future.' Reid is hiding something and now we need to figure out what."

"Great,we get to dive into the past of one of the most private agents ever. I'm so glad I came back for this because I SO missed it," Elle said as she shoved her chair back and left to go get coffee.

"Was she always this snarky?" Rossi asked.

Gideon let out a low chuckle, "You have no idea."


The three kidnapped agents sat in silence. The man had left them alone after making Morgan and Reid kiss.

Morgan let Emily lean against him as he watched Reid fight to stay awake on the other side of Emily.

"So,we know this guy is all about secrets so I think the three of us need to talk,"Morgan said.

"About what?" Emily asked as she watched Reid's eyes flutter shut again.

"If we already know what each other are hiding then we won't be so thrown off when something is revealed or feel so awful about saying it," Morgan said softly as he smiled at a sleeping Reid.

"I don't have anything else to hide," Emily said.

"Maybe not but apparently Reid and I do,and we still don't know what JJ was hiding."

Reid jolted awake and looked around.

"Go back to sleep,Reid. He isn't here," Emily said gently as she grabbed his hand.

"JJ's secret,he's going to make me tell," Reid said urgently.

"Shhhh,it's okay. JJ will understand,I know her Spencer and so do you. She won't be mad," Emily tried comforting the young agent but he pulled away.

"We need to get out,we need to get out now," Reid said as he attempted to stand up.

"Whoa,sit down pretty boy. Take a deep breath,we aren't going anywhere anytime soon. The team will find us though,you know they will," Morgan said as he shot a look at Emily who looked just as confused as he felt.

"The reason he kidnapped us was because of secrets. Once we reveal them,he has no use for us," Reid murmured as he scanned the entire room.

" is right," the man said as he entered the room, "Once all your pretty,little,hidden agendas are revealed I don't have a reason to keep you around."

"What else is there for us to tell? Emily is pregnant and Reid is gay. There is nothing left,"Morgan said looking the man straight in the eyes.

"Wrong ,there is much more to tell. For instance,you have a secret that you don't think anyone knows about but trust me I do. Emily has a little something that could ruin a friendship. And you , the one everyone loves and adores has a couple secrets that could change everything,do you disagree?"

Reid didn't say anything but pulled his knees to his chest which made the unsub laugh, "Try and shrink up into yourself but I'm not going anywhere."

Morgan looked over at Reid and saw something he had never seen before, Reid looked scared and angry and that scared Morgan more then anything.


"Garcia,do you have anything yet?" Hotch asked as handed out more in-depth files on his missing agents.

"I have six cases. And unfortunately,all of them involve Morgan,Prentiss,and Reid."

"Any that involve JJ as well or maybe JJ instead of Prentiss?" Rossi asked.

"No,sir. None at all."

"Okay,Garica go back three years. Keep the ages the same and everything. We need to find this guy. Elle,I want you to look through Emily's file. You don't know her as well so it is a fresh set of eyes looking. Gideon,I want you to go through Morgan's file. You were closer to Reid so I don't want that to be an issue."

"What about me?" JJ asked looking at Hotch.

"I want you to answer any questions that Gideon or Elle have and help Garcia. You and Reid are close,it could cloud your judgement as well. I'm taking Reid's file for myself."


"So,who is the lucky one now? ,I think you have revealed enough for now. But,I am really excited for your biggest reveal. I think that will be last. Except you should tell us JJ's secret so Morgan's and Emily's make sense."

Emily and Morgan looked at each other and then at Reid who visibly paled.

"Yes yes yes,that is how it should go. ,you're up."


"Dammit," Hotch swore as he came back into the briefing room, "We have another reel."

"What if we didn't watch?" Elle asked.

"What good would that do us, we couldn't gain anything from not watching," Rossi said as Hotch set up the reel.

"How does he know we are watching though? I mean,he wants us to know their secrets but what if we took matters into our own hands and didn't watch or listen. He doesn't win that way," Elle shot back.

"As much as I would love to agree with you Elle,we can't take that risk. We need to see what we can find out from what he sends us," Hotch said.

"It was just a thought."

Hotch flipped the switch and the reel started turning.


"Hello yet again my dear BAU team. Are you any closer to figuring me out? Or finding out where I'm keeping your agents?"

No one answered and the unsub laughed like he knew they didn't have an answer for him.

"I'm going to assume that is a no because if you did,I would know about it. I know everything and trust me when I say that I am watching you and every move you make. Anyways,the reason for this lovely little reel is because we have another thing to reveal but first a little background information for you all. I originally took Jennifer but swapped her for and you are probably wondering why. Well,I have an answer. I didn't need JJ when I had Reid. Yes,JJ,Reid knows all your dirty little secrets and since Emily had her whole secret pregnancy thing plus a couple other dirty secrets,she was more valuable. Now I present to you ."

The masked unsub stepped back to reveal Reid tied to the chair. The team could see Reid was in worse shape then the others.

The unsub let out a little laugh as he dragged a knife along Reid's face, "So tell me,what is JJ hiding?"

Reid didn't say anything and JJ silently urged him just to tell. The team already knew Will cheated on her and she was hoped that was all the unsub knew.

"Time is running out ,tell them now or I'll have to hand out punishments."

Reid clenched his jaw and refused to answer. It was the sudden slash of the knife to his arm that made him gasp, "Next time I'll do that to your lover over there."

Reid didn't say anything until the man dragged Derek over and held the knife to his stomach, "NOW !"

"Will cheated on JJ," he said quietly as Morgan held his breath.


Elle rolled her eyes, "We already knew that."

"But the unsub didn't," Hotch reminded her.

"Point taken."


"There's more to the story . What else. Why did Will cheat on JJ?"

Pain filled Reid's eyes and Morgan knew there was a lot more that Reid wasn't saying and that caused his heart to break.

"Answer the question or I hurt Morgan."

"It's okay,Reid. I can take it," Morgan tried to comfort the conflicted agent.

"5...4...3...2...1," the unsub jabbed the knife into Morgan's side and Morgan cried out in pain.

"One last chance," the man taunted.

"JJ was cheating on Will. JJ I'm so sorry. I am so so so sorry. I just,I can't-"

"Shut up or I'll hurt you."


Everyone turned to JJ who buried her face in her hands.

"Are you kidding me right now?" Elle asked looking around.

"Watch it,Elle," Gideon ordered shooting her a look, "JJ,you need to tell us everything right now."

"I ca-can't. I mean,I don't know. Reid is right,I cheated on Will but it was a one time thing."

"With who?" Hotch asked as Garcia wrapped her arms around JJ.

"It was one time,it was a mistake," JJ sobbed.

"Who?" Hotch asked a little more forcefully.


"I'm going to stop for now. I think Derek Morgan needs some medical attention. Have no fear,I shall be returning," the unsub smiled beneath his mask, "And if you're looking for who I am maybe the name Andy will ring a bell."

The unsub kicked the chair over knocking Reid to the ground and dragged Morgan out of the view of the camera.


The team watched as Reid's eyes unfocused and then closed and then the reel came to an end.

"Garcia,look up Andy right now. I don't care what files you have to hack or anything like that. We need to find out who he is and we have to hurry."

Garcia leaped up and went to her computer and started typing.

"JJ,you need to start talking and start talking NOW," Hotch demanded.

JJ took a shaky and breath and started speaking.