At the sorority house Beta Theta Zeta, the girls were preparing their house for the annual Halloween party that they through every year. They have been in charge of the Halloween parties ever since the sorority came into existence. Their Halloween parties have been considered the best in all of the college.

The current head of the house, Carrie Xavier, was making plans for the party. She's a female wolf with gray fur and yellow eyes. She is a senior who is going to graduate this semester and she wanted to make this the best Halloween party of her final years here. While she and the girls of the house had everything planned and ready, she could not shake of this fear that this is not perfect enough. She was worried that she did not have it all right and that everyone would hate this party and she would be humiliated and everyone would hate it. As she was stressing over this, a yellow light appeared somewhere in the cabinet of the house. She opened the cabinet and a huge light filled the room.

In the cafeteria, Kate was busy eating her breakfast by she was eating, Humphrey came up to her and asked if he could sit with her. She said no and for him to go away now. Humphrey then said could he at least tell her one of his jokes. She said no and told him to go away. He told the joke about how a wolf who was at a comedy club and he ordered some meat. When he ate it, he gave a piece of it to the waiter and asked him if this tasted funny to him. Kate then got up and said: If you think that telling me a joke such as that will get me to go out or sleep with a pig such as yourself, think agains. She then slaps him in the face and walks away.

Behind Humphrey was Princess. She told him that he was the tenth person who flirted with Kate and got either smacked, punched, or kicked in the nuts for trying to flirt with her. Humphrey said that while he was flirting with her, he was also trying to make a friend out of her in case it did not work at all. Princess then told him that it's best that he not try and pursue her since she is stubborn and resentful when it comes to "males". Princess then told him that she thought the joke was funny. Humphrey then gave Princess to tickets to the Halloween party at the Beta Theta Zeta house that was going to happen in two days; the fliers are a student's way of getting into the party. He was going to give it to her, but he knows that's not going to happen anytime soon. Humphrey then told her if she was going to slap him too. She said no and said that she might see him there, if he was up for it.

While one of the Beta Theta Zeta girls was heading to the house, she was acting very happy since this was going to be a great Halloween party. When she entered, she noticed that the house was completely different from what was originally decorated. Shen then noticed someone sitting on the couch. She walks up to her and ask what happened to the original design here. The wolf then asked her what did she fear the most. The wolf that asked that turned out to be Carrie. She used the stone she had in hand and made the wolf she used the power on shee her greatest fear come to life.

At the penthouse, Eve noticed that the pendent glowing. This indicated that one of the stones of light has revealed itself: The stone of fear. Eve then texted the girls and told them to head over to the house as soon as possible. When they arrived at the house, she told them about the stone of fear. The stone can bring a wolves greatest fear to life. The location of the stone is at the Beta Theta Zeta house. The girls would head over there tonight and deal with this since it might be too dangerous to handle the stone right now and they needed to come up with a plan on how to deal with it.

While Lilly was getting ready for the mission, she got a text from Garth saying if she wanted to go to the Halloween party with him. She texted him back and said yes. When Kate came in and asked Lilly if she's seen her rope, she hid her phone so Kate would not see the message that she received from Garth. Lilly then gave Kate her rope and the two went to the car to head over to the house.

When they arrived at the house, they noticed that the stone was using its power on the house on both the inside and the outside. Eve explained that the stone can only be sealed at night since that is when it is at its most powerful and its most weakest.

As soon as the girls entered the room, Carrie was in there waiting for them. She asked all five of them what their greatest fear was. kate shrugged this of and began to attack. However, the stone consumed Kate into a big dark bubble and she disappeared. The girls were all caught in the same bubble. carrie would then laugh like a regular witch at how they will now be stuck in their greatest fears forever.