"You moron! That doesn't make any sense!" he hissed. "How could I be in the gift shop if I was in my room the whole time?" he asked with frustration in his voice. "You weren't in your room, you were in the gift shop killing Beary!" Tiger insisted. "Hold on, Tiger." I interjected. "Dennis couldn't have killed Beary in that way." I told her. Tiger looked a bit surprised. "How could he not have?" she seemed a little irritated that I questioned her theory. "Well, not only did you leave out the part about Beary being stabbed in the abdomen, but" I turned to Melvin. "Melvin, you saw someone at 8:25 when you went into the gift shop, right?" I asked him. He nodded. "I saw Beary Nice at 8:25" he told me again like he did earlier. "Yes, so that means even if Dennis went in after 8:25, he wouldn't have killed Beary out of surprise since Beary was already in there to begin with" I told everyone. Everyone nodded, but Tiger shook her head. "He could have not noticed him at first! I mean, this was a pretty sloppily put together murder!" she refuted. "You're absolutely right about the sloppy murder, which is why Dennis couldn't have done it anyways." I explained. Dennis seemed to sigh out in relief. "Wow finally! Someone with a goddamn brain!" I ignored his commentary and continued on. "Dennis is not very tall, so he'd need to move the boxes to climb up to the shelf to get the murder weapon. However, the boxes looked untouched when I saw them."

"He could have had someone take it down for him before hand, or maybe he used an item to get it down!" Tiger pressed on. "He could have used something to get it down, but it would seem like a lot of effort for someone who sloppily put the murder together." I explained to her.

"Actually, now that I think about it, I don't think this murder was as sloppily put together as one would think." Pizza Steve interjected. "Mr. Gus, remember how you were telling us earlier that putting the body in the freezer was the only thought out thing the killer did?" he pointed to Mr. Gus as he asked. "Yes, what about it?" Mr. Gus raised his eyebrow. "If this murder was as sloppy as we're claiming it to be, why would the murderer think ahead to do that?" he seemed skeptical. "Something doesn't add up there. Honestly, now that I'm thinking about that, I do think this murder was premeditated."

"If they poorly planned the murder, then they risk themselves getting put into a death match. I feel like that would be highly unlikely." Mr. Gus shook his head. "Maybe, but it would be even riskier to murder on a whim, because you could get caught even more easily." Pizza Steve explained to us. Dennis rubbed his chin. "Actually, Pizza Steve sounds like he's getting onto something. All this time we were accusing the murderer of being sloppy, but perhaps this person was planning to murder Beary this whole time!" Dennis speculated. A few people gasped. Festro sighed. "How is that even remotely important? Whether premeditated or not, whoever killed Beary did an awful job cleaning up the evidence!"

"It's important because it ties in with the time the murder took place," Pizza Steve began to explain to us. "If the murder took place at 8:30 and the notes Melvin and Festro received were set to meet at 8:45, that could only mean whoever killed Beary did not write those notes." He crossed his arms. Ramona squealed. "My Pizza Prince is so smart~" she giggled. "Then Dennis did do it! You're the murderer!" Festro accused Dennis. "What? NO!" Dennis slapped his palms against his cheeks in frustration. "How would whoever wrote the notes know Dennis was planning to murder Beary, though?" Gweelok asked. "If they knew wouldn't they have tried to stop it themselves?"

"Perhaps the victim himself wrote the notes out before hand?" Eric speculated with a shrug. "Why would he address the sender as me then? That seems kind of stupid!" Dennis huffed as he crossed his arms. I looked at Festro and Melvin. "Do either of you have the notes in question?" I asked. Melvin shook his head, but Festro nodded and began to fish into his pocket. When he found the note he placed it in the middle of the table. Dennis immediately took it and read it. After reading it, he began to laugh. "Wow, you REALLY think I wrote these?" he asked as he turned over the letter so we could see it. "Look at this handwriting! It's so feminine and artsy!" he pointed out. I leaned in to get a better look, and sure enough the handwriting was very girly.

"T-That looks like Beary's handwriting" Frank admitted. "So Beary did write them himself?" Eric asked. I shook my head. "That wouldn't make sense, Beary ran into the gift shop around 8:15" I told everyone. "I bumped into him around that time, he told me he was getting a surprise for Frank." Izzie sighed. "It's my handwriting, guys" she told us. We were all surprised. Dennis sighed in frustration. "What the hell? Why would you write down my name?" he asked. "Well, you see, I was playin' a little prank on you guys," she giggled. "Dennis, I gave you a note from Melvin, I'm not sure how you didn't get it!" Dennis shook his head. "I saw a piece of paper on my floor this morning, but I threw it out because I thought it was something stupid from Tanezumi." he admitted. "I was asleep by 8:30 because I had a massive headache!" he told us. "Why would you want to prank us?" Festro seemed irritated. "Why not? Mildly irritating people is funny!" she giggled. "I figured when you went to the gift shop for no reason you would get frustrated for running there for nothing!" she laughed.

"Well, this information is able to rule out Izzie as the murderer, then" Pizza Steve concluded. "However, I find it strange that Melvin went earlier to the gift shop than the note specified." Pizza Steve tapped his chin. "W-What do you mean? I just wanted to make sure there was no danger!" Melvin told him. "Yeah, but you didn't have to go that early to check," Pizza Steve seemed skeptical. "I mean you coulda went 10 minutes earlier than the meeting time to check."

Melvin huffed. "Are you accusing me of MURDERING Beary Nice?" he seemed offended. "Well, I'm not saying you definitely did, but you're kind of a huge suspect right now." Pizza Steve told him. Melvin gasped. "How?! How am I a suspect?!" he tugged on his hair. "You saw Beary Nice at around 8:25 when you went to the gift shop. I told you all that this murder was most likely premeditated, but poorly planned. This means, possibly, that you could have been planning to kill someone that night, and Beary happened to be available." he nodded. Melvin gasped, almost tearing up. "Why would I plan to kill someone?!"

"I'm sure, like all of us, you want to get out of here. Maybe more so than all of us." Pizza Steve speculated. "Festro could have done it, though!" Melvin told us. Festro looked angry when he got accused. "You dare accuse me?" he tried to intimidate Melvin. "Well you said you received a note, too. For all we know you could have came in right after I left and killed Beary!"

Festro clenched his teeth. "That's such a crock of shit coming from the real culprit!" he pointed his finger at Melvin as he accused him. "I didn't kill Beary!" Melvin shouted. "I don't think it was Festro." I admitted to everyone. Everyone turned their attention to me. Melvin put his hands on his hips. "Oh really? How was it not Festro?"

"Well, I found this behind the faux counter Dennis found the murder weapon under." I pulled out the small piece of blue cloth I had found. "This was hanging on one of the nails on the wall." Everyone gasped at the evidence I presented. "This actually just might confirm it. Melvin, you killed Beary Nice" Pizza Steve accused. Melvin let out a cry. "No! That doesn't prove anything! I didn't kill Beary!" he seemed very panicked. "Your shirt color matches this small piece of cloth I found" I pointed out. Melvin began to sob. "No! It wasn't me! That's not part of my shirt!"

"You are a huge suspect right now, Melvin," I began to tell him. "That isn't my shirt! Dennis's sweater is blue! It could have been Dennis!" he accused Dennis. "For the last goddamn time, there is no way in hell it could have been me!" Dennis hissed. "I do think there is another suspect that might be even more likely than Melvin, but it's not Dennis." Everyone leaned in to listen to what I had to say. "Though this cloth matches the color of Melvin's shirt and Dennis's sweater, this cloth seems like it came from some kind of jacket lining. Look how thin it is" I told everyone as I held it out for all of them to see. "You're right." Mr. Gus confirmed as he nodded. "The only people who wear jackets are Tiger and Frank. However, Tiger couldn't have murdered Beary because she was with Pizza Steve, Ramona, and Dingle on the rides." I told them. Frank made a small whimper sound. "A-Are you saying that I-I would kill my best friend?" Frank's eyes welled up with tears. "Tiger's jacket is also kind of tight and hugs her body closer. Your jacket is long and flowy, and could easily get caught on something." I explained. Frank bit his lip. Slog seemed very upset with what I was saying. "Mary! Why are you accusing Frank of killing his best friend?"

"I'm not accusing him, I'm just wondering why he'd need to hide behind the faux check-out counter in the gift shop" I tried to sound as non-accusing as possible, but I knew there was something up with Frank's story and his supposed alibi after going over all the details. "I wasn't!" Frank tried to convince me. "May I see your jacket lining?" I asked him. Frank sighed. "Why would you need that? Clearly the cloth you are holding is from Melvin's shirt."

"Frank, it would be very important to the conclusion if you showed all of us your jacket lining." I told him. He sighed and opened up his jacket, revealing the same blue lining I was holding in my hand. "It's the same color, but that doesn't mean anything" Frank told us. "Well, it kind of does, because this would imply you were hiding behind the faux check-out counter at one point." Pizza Steve pointed out. Frank shook his head. "I was just checking to see if Beary was there when he went missing!" he told us. "I mean, I even checked the janitor's closet and found nothing! I don't know how this person was able to kill Beary without any of our knowledge that night!" he told us. "Wait a minute, Janitor's closets are usually locked unless someone has a key!" Eric pointed out. "The door opened up fine for me" Frank admitted. "How did you miss the smeared blood in the next aisle, then?" Mr. Gus raised his eyebrow. "I-I guess I overlooked it" Frank frowned. Pizza Steve shook his head. "You realize none of what you are saying adds up, right?" Frank whimpered and tapped his fingers together. "W-What are you talking about? I'm telling you the truth!"

"Only one way to find out," Pizza Steve turned to Billy. "Do you remember seeing Frank watch your roll-a-ball game?" he asked. Billy nodded. "I glanced over and saw him there around 8:15, after that I was focused on the game. He then spoke up at around 8:30 and asked if we had seen Beary." he admitted to us. "Crafty, aren't we Frank?" Pizza Steve chuckled. Frank sobbed. "W-What do you mean?" Frank's eyes welled up with more tears. "What I mean is, you could have slipped away without their knowledge between 8:15 and 8:30, and then come back to create a fake alibi for yourself." Pizza Steve took off his sunglasses to look Frank in the eye. Frank whimpered and sank in his chair. "T-That's not true! I would never think to kill Beary!" he sobbed to us. "Well, if you searched the gift shop like you said you did and found out how the Janitor's closet was able to easily be opened, you would have seen the evidence of Beary's death!" Mr. Gus pointed out. "I didn't have a lot of time to look because Izzie came to me around 9" he told me. "I would have helped you find Beary, Franky~" she told him. "I-I didn't want to burden you with my problems." he looked down. "Billy, when Frank asked about where Beary was, did he leave immediately after that question was asked?" Mr. Gus asked him. "Yes, he did. I watched him run towards the Gift Shop before going back to the game." Billy told us. "You had a full half an hour to check the Gift Shop, you would have found him before then." Mr. Gus told Frank. "Yeah, we were able to find Beary within 2 minutes of searching" Izzie told us. "I looked in other places too" Frank told us. "When I found you at 9 you were in the gift shop!" Izzie told him. Frank whimpered again. "We have our 2 culprits!" Festro shouted out.

"Finally!" Tanezumi jumped up. "You're meeting is done! Let's get o-" Tanezumi didn't have a chance to finish her sentence because Frank cried out. "No! No you don't know what you're all talking about! I can't be a suspect I would never hurt Beary!" he cried. Tanezumi let out a frustrated sigh. "Well, everyone else has decided," Pizza Steve told him before looking around at everyone else who nodded in agreement. "we're all ready to place in our decision." Frank whimpered. "Izzie, help me!" he sobbed. Izzie gave him a sad look. "I'm sorry Franky..." she closed her eyes.

Tanezumi giggled. "So, who will it be?"