Toby's POV (a little bit before Spencer woke up and screamed)

I was going way over the speed limit. Like 50 or 60 mph. I didn't care if I got a ticket. I had to save Spencer. That text I got seemed so real I couldn't think why it wouldn't be. But A could be tricking me into saving Spencer. The girls were probably going to be there too. But if I was right and it was a trick, we would all be screwed. I finally reached the lake house. I got out of my truck and started to slowly look around for Spencer. I couldn't find her. But I was only looking outside. She was probably inside. I was about to open the front door when I saw a car approaching. It was headed right for me. I stood there, not knowing what to do. I don't think the car saw me. I jumped to the side just as the car came to a screeching halt. I dusted myself off and looked to see who was driving the car. It was none other than Emily, Hanna, and Aria.

Aria's POV (obviously before Toby's POV and Spencer waking up and screaming)

I was yelling at Hanna that she was driving too fast, but she just started bitching at me. But I was right, she almost hit Toby. We got out of the car and ran over to see if he was hurt. He looked ok as far as I could tell. We just stood there, not knowing what to do or say. A loud cell phone broke the silence. It wasn't any of our phones. It had to be Toby's. Except, he was holding his in his hand and it wasn't making any noise at all! Slowly, he pulled something out of his pocket. It looked like… Spencer's phone?. Why on earth does he have her phone?! Could he have kidnaped her, and was really against us? Nothing made sense.

H- why do you have Spencer's phone?!

E- (really angry) ANSWER. NOW.

T- if you are thinking I did something to Spencer, you are wrong!

A- then why do you have her phone, huh?

H- yah, PROVE to us you didn't kidnap Spencer!

T- I didn't take her phone I swear! We ran into each other at some park. Long story short, I got mad at her and left. But after I had left, someone send me this video. (plays the video on his phone)

E- (gasps in horror) Oh my god!

A- Spencer!

T- it gets worse.

H- A was strangling Spencer! How could things get worse?!

T- A also sent me a text with the video. It said

Oh, Toby. I bet you Are wondering who I Am huh? Or who is strAngling your 'girlfriend?' You thought there was only A right? WAit who is A? Spencer didn't tell you? Oops. I guess the cAt is out of the bAg.
Kisses-
A

A- since when do you get texts from A?

T- I don't know!

E- maybe because he got involed?

H- maybe.

T- anyway, I ran back to where we were and Spencer was gone. Her phone was on the ground. I picked it up and read that S.O.S text that Aria sent. Then I got another text from A

Oh Toby, didn't your mom ever tell you thAt you shouldn't reAd other people's texts? How will Spencer feel when she finds out? Oh wAit, she won't feel Anything when I Am done with her.
Kisses-
A

E- so A had seen Toby read Spencer's phone?

T- yah.

H- well did you see anyone?!

T- I couldn't see anyone for miles. But I didn't look very long, I was too worried about Spencer.

H- (thinks carefully) Toby?

T- what is it?

E- Han, maybe you shouldn't-

H- (blurts out) Did you and Spencer see each other before Jenna got blinded?

A- Hanna!

T- what? No! We didn't even know each other then! Why would you think that?

H- well, Spencer told us she likes you.

E- and it is kind of obvious you like her.

T- so?

H- well, after you took the blame for blinding Jenna, Spencer would always say how she felt bad and that Alison shouldn't have done that. But a month or so after, every time we brought up the subject, she refused to talk about it.

A- hold on, Han. What is all this 'we' stuff?

E- yah, this was all your thoughts, not ours.

H- ok fine, I thought all that. But you didn't see Spencer before you took the blame?

T- no! I already told you no! I thought she was a stuck up snob to be honest.

A- and now?

T- and know I see her as a different person.

H-(snickers)

E- Hanna!

H- sorry.

A- ok, now that that is cleared up, what now?

T- well, we should probably start to look for Spencer and maybe-

Toby was cut off by a faint screaming. I looked from Emily to Hanna to Toby and back to Emily again. I gulped, I didn't dare make a sound.

H- what was that?!

T- was that Spencer?!

E- it has to be!

A- come on! (runs up to the door but it is locked) Damn it!

H- now what?

T- move. (they all move away.)

Toby took a couple of steps back. He ran towards the door and charged at it with his shoulder blade. He did that 2 more times until the door broke down. He grinned at us and walked inside. I looked at Emily and Hanna. They just shook their heads and walked inside. I looked around me quickly, sighed, and followed them in.