"Finn…" Rachel started.
"Rachel, no." Sebastian said, holding Rachel back.
Rachel strutted out of his arms and over to Finn and Quinn.
"YOU CHEATING BASTARD!" Rachel screamed and slapped Finn.
"Rachel!" Sebastian screamed. He ran out after her and pulled her back into the woods.
"Dammit Rach! You're gonna get us both killed!" Sebastian said when they got back to the hut.
"We need to leave. The note was in place, they're coming soon." The Killer said to them both.
"Finn cheated." Rachel said, sobbing.
"Then you can be the one to kill him." The Killer said, smirking and pulling Rachel in for a kiss.
Rachel smiled deviously and took the knife from the killer after she pulled away.
"The fuck was that?" Finn asked.
"Rachel…" Quinn trailed off.
"Guys! Guys! We gotta go find this hut thingy. Woah, what happened here? Yall look like you've seen a ghost." Puck said as he walked up to the shore.
"Rachel…" Quinn trailed off again.
"well, we're gonna find her. C'mon." Puck led them to the hut, which was surprisingly easy to find. He led them carefully into the hut, and found the freezer. Quinn was the last to walk into the hut, so if anything went wrong, it was her to die.
When Finn turned around, Quinn was nowhere to be found.
"Quinn?" Finn called out.
No answer.
"huh, wonder where she went."
"Rachel you are such an Idiot! Are you trying to get yourself killed? That was a risky move, coming out of hiding to slap him? You know nothing was going to happen between Finn and I!" Quinn whisper-shouted at Rachel.
"Quinn, I know. Its just, rage took over me and I don't know, I just didn't want Finn to have you." Rachel protested.
"Girls, whats going on? Quinn, do I have to kill you for going into another room, miss-last-to-enter?" The killer stated, before leaving a lingering kiss on Quinn's cheek.
"Technally Finn was last to enter. You wouldn't dare kill me." Quinn spoke confidently.
"You guys, shh. Theyre in the freezer." Sebastian said.
"guys, this is the freezer." Puck said as he opened the door.
"oh my god." Mike said and Tina screamed. Inside the freezer were the bodies of Artie Abrams, Sugar Motta, Sam Evans, Rory Flanagan, Blaine Anderson, Brittany S. Pierce, and Kurt Hummel.
"this is sick! Oh my god, im going to be sick." Finn said as he excused himself from the room.
He made the mistake of going into a nearby bathroom, which was inside the little hut.
"there! He left the freezer and went into the bathroom! Can I kill him now? Please?" Rachel asked, jumping up and down.
"Damn Rach, you sure are kill crazy." Quinn whispered.
"But you love me for it." Rachel answered, pulling Quinn in for a quick kiss.
"Go ahead Rachel." The killer stated.
Rachel giggled and headed for the bathroom. She opened the door slowly to reveal a dry-heaving Finn.
"Rach?" Finn asked when he saw who opened the door.
"Say Goodbye, Finn." Rachel said before she stabbed him. Finn let out a masculine scream, startling the others. Mike ran in and tried to get the knife away from Rachel, but he couldn't stop in time and ran into her knife.
"MIKE!" Tina screamed. Rachel made a run for it and easily made it out, Quinn sneakily planting the note through the bathroom window.
"Two kills with one shot, good job Berry." The killer said as they pulled Rachel in for a passionate kiss.
"If yall are done making out im going to 'scream' and 'find the note'. See yall later." Quinn whispered as she entered the hut.
"you guys, what happen- oh my god." Quinn said as she entered the bathroom. She saw Finn and Mike laying on the ground with stab wounds and carefully picked up the note, tears staining her face.
"It was Rachel…" Tina said, sobbing into Mercades shoulder.
Quinn read the note she had planted aloud. She already knew what it had to say.
"'Killing two birds with one stone is always fun. Finn was the last one to enter the house, and yet he was the one to leave the freezer. I hope you liked your reward. 9 down, 8 to go.
This game is getting close to an end, and soon you will know my true identity as well as getting your friends back. I had some help today, as well. The people left are the Black Diva, the Bitch, the teachers, the mohawked freak, the ex-cheerleader, and the Asian. Im going to give you all somewhat of a break, youll know when this game starts back up. Good luck, and be is good if you want to survive.' This guy is fucking physco!" Quinn stated.
"Guys, Im actually scared." Puck admitted. Quinn gave him a hug.
"We all are, Puck." Will said, holding a crying Emma. "I think we should all try to get some rest."
The gang noddedRa and headed back towards the mansion. Santana remembered that her and Rachel were the only ones with signal in the group.
'Rachel, I can't believe you're doing this. It's killing me, knowing you're with the killer. I hope you're safe. –S
'Rachel, I can't believe you're doing this. It's killing me, knowing you're with the killer. I hope you're safe. –S'
chel looked down at her phone. She had tears welling up in her eyes.
"can I answer her?" Rachel asked.
The killer nodded.
'I'm safe for now, but hes been doing things, San. Things I can't explain.-R'
Santana looked at her phone confused. Things? She sat down on her bed, Rachels bed being taken Quinn.
'what kind of things? Is he hurting you? –S'
'no, but hes making me kiss him, and stuff…-R'
Santana was starting to see red.
'Rachel, where are you?-S'
'can't say.-R'
"Who are you texting?" Quinn asked.
"Rachel. The killers making her kiss him." Santana answered.
"So it's a him." Quinn stated, knowing the answer already and feeling guilty that she and Rachel had kissed earlier.
'you need to be saved, Rachel.-S'
'I will be soon enough. Hopefully he won't hurt you. He already made me hurt Finn.-R'
'Rachel, if anything happens I want to make sure you're safe. If I get killed before anyone else I want you to confide in them. Please, for me. –S'
Rachel stared at her phone. She lie awake in her bed, Sebastian in the bed not too far from hers.
'I will San. He isn't going to hurt you though, I'll make sure of it.-R'
Santana hesitated before she sent the text.
'Rachel, I think I'm in love with you.-S'
A/N: threw a little Faberry in there for ya. Now you know that the killer is a guy, but who is it? And now you know who the traitor is :p
