Disclaimer: I don't Glee but I strongly believe that Mark Salling will come to his senses and show up on my front porch someday.
"Puck will be back tomorrow." Tina said to Rachel during last period.
"I know." Rachel sighed. "I've just missed him this week."
"Do you wanna come over to Kurt's later?" Tina asked. "Mercedes, Kurt, and I are giving each other makeovers."
"I don't know if Kurt would want me there." Rachel bit her lip.
"I'll deal with Kurt, you just show up at six." Tina smiled. "And you're staying over too, so bring some clothes."
"Bye, Tina." Rachel said when the bell rang and all but ran to her car.
"Are you going to see Puck?" Quinn asked when Rachel sprinted past her.
"Yea." Rachel waved at her.
"Hi, Rachel." Mrs. Puckerman opened the front door of Puck's house. "Noah is in his room."
"Thanks." Rachel quietly slipped up the stairs and knocked on Noah's bedroom door.
"I said I'm trying to sleep." Puck called out.
Rachel smiled as she pushed his door open slightly. "Should I just leave then?" She asked.
Puck shot up out of his bed and pulled Rachel into his room. "Sorry, I thought it was my mom. She's been bugging me all day." Puck kissed Rachel's neck greedily as he smushed her between him and the door. He pulled back when a thought occurred to him. "Did you tell her-?"
"No, she thinks I'm just dropping some homework off." Rachel told him. "Why don't you want your mom to know we're dating?"
Puck pulled Rachel over to his bed. "Because I know my mom and if she found out that we're together she'll want to lock you in the basement until we get married." Puck smiled.
"Oh." Rachel let Puck pull her into his lap.
"I haven't seen you in almost three days." He groaned trying to kiss every part of her that wasn't covered by clothes.
"I know." Rachel tilted her head back. "But you're coming back to school tomorrow."
"I never realized how much I like walking you to class or sitting next to you at lunch." Puck whispered against her neck.
"Mm-hmm." Rachel wasn't really paying attention to what he was saying. She was too busy concentrating on the way his hands were crawling up her thigh under her skirt. Her breath hitched in her throat when his fingers pressed against her panties.
"You like that?" He chuckled and she nodded fiercely because she couldn't form the words. "What about this?" Puck pressed down harder over her clit.
"Yes." Rachel's eyes fluttered shut as he leaned her back on the bed.
"Do you want more, Rach?" He asked huskily.
She thrust her hips towards his hand in response. "More." She choked out.
Puck's fingers hooked under her panties and gently tugged them down. She lifted her hips to help him. Rachel gasped as a finger slipped inside of her. Her eyes shot open to find Noah staring back at her.
"Rach, you feel so good." He bent to kiss her lips as he slipped another finger inside of her. She was so tight and warm.
Rachel knew what masturbation was and she had definitely tried it out a few times. She knew what it felt like to orgasm and she knew what it felt like to have fingers inside of her but they had always been her fingers. Now it was Noah's fingers inside of her. He was touching her in places she didn't even know she had. Making her feel things she didn't even know were possible.
"Noah." Rachel breathed.
"Are you close?" He asked but he knew she was. He had been with enough women to know when they were about to come. He just wanted to hear Rachel say it.
"So close." She nodded pushing her hips closer to him to feel him deeper inside of her.
Puck pumped his fingers into a few more times as he felt her start to spasm around his fingers. He groaned biting into her neck slightly. Never again would he have to wonder what it was like when Rachel Berry came because now he knew. He had made her come. He had felt her come.
"Rachel." Puck kissed her lips hungrily.
"Oh God." Rachel smiled. Her breaths were coming out quick and ragged. "Noah."
"You okay?" He breathed against her cheek.
"I'm more than okay." Rachel laughed and looked at her watch. "But I have to go. It's almost five and my dads' will be getting home soon."
"Rach, you can't leave now." Puck groaned when she slipped her panties back on.
"I have to." Rachel looked torn. "If I'm not home when my dads' get there they'll want to know where I was. I can't exactly tell them what we just did."
"Can I come over tonight?" He asked sitting up in his bed.
"I guess you could but I won't be there." She smiled nearing his door.
"Why?"
"I'm staying over at Kurt's with Mercedes and Tina." She explained. "I'll see you later."
When Kurt answered the door for Rachel he looked a little surprised she was here.
"Didn't Tina tell you I was coming over?" Rachel asked when she saw the look on his face.
"You're late. I figured you weren't coming." He gestured for her to come inside.
"I got a little caught up with Puck." Rachel explained. "I had to shower before I came over."
"Scandalous." Kurt laughed leading Rachel into the living room where Mercedes and Tina were already sitting.
"We thought you weren't coming." Tina said.
"She lost track of time when she was over at Puck's." Kurt smiled suggestively.
"Spill. We want every detail." Mercedes smiled.
Rachel couldn't help but giggle and was about to tell them everything that had happened when something caught her attention across the room. Finn was sitting on the other couch playing a video game pretending not to be listening.
"We just studied." Rachel mumbled.
"Let's take this conversation downstairs." Kurt said noticing that Rachel had noticed Finn. "Some people in this room don't know that they shouldn't eavesdrop on other peoples' conversations."
"I wasn't eavesdropping." Finn turned to them but then swore under his breath when he realized he had given himself away accidentally. "Whatever. You guys' go have your girl fest downstairs. Puck will be here in a little bit anyway."
"Puck's coming over here?" Rachel asked.
"Yea." Finn turned back to his game.
"Come on." Kurt urged Rachel downstairs.
They hadn't been downstairs long when they heard four loud feet bounding down the stairs.
"Seriously dude? They're like giving makeovers down here or something." Finn complained.
Rachel look up to see Puck and Finn come into the room.
"This is for girls' only." Mercedes told them.
"Kurt's in here. He's a guy." Puck shrugged.
"Barely." Kurt snickered.
"Besides, this is Finn's room too." Puck looked around the room.
"The only way you can stay down her is if you get a makeover." Rachel told the two boys'.
"Come on, dude. Let's just go back upstairs." Finn suggested.
"I could use a facial or whatever the hell you girl's call them." Puck smirked.
Rachel rolled her eyes. "You really want a makeover, Noah?"
"Yep." He rubbed his hands together. "Where do I sit?"
Kurt led Finn and Puck into two empty chairs. Rachel sat down on Puck's lap and starting to apply the cream with the help of Tina.
"You know this is really girly?" Finn told Puck.
"Fuck you. I make this work." Puck laughed looking at himself in the mirror.
"Alright. We're done." Kurt said after they had cleaned off the boys' faces.
"It does make my skin softer." Finn noted rubbing his cheek.
"If that's all you wanted you two can go back upstairs now. We have some girl talk to tend to." Kurt said trying to usher the boys upstairs.
"We can do girl talk." Puck said. "Right, Finn?"
"Right." Finn nodded along with Puck.
"Fine." Mercedes groaned and the six of them all took seats in the middle of the room in a circle.
"…then she told me that they snuck out to her dads speed boat—" Kurt was saying.
"This is boring." Puck complained. "Let's play a game."
"We are not playing truth or dare again." Rachel shook her head.
"I was thinking something a little more fun." Puck smirked.
"Like what?" Rachel raised an eyebrow.
"Spin the bottle." His smirk grew bigger.
"That is so childish." Rachel scoffed.
"I've got the bottle." Kurt sat a lotion bottle on the floor in the middle of the circle. "I'll spin first."
Kurt spun the bottle and it landed on Mercedes. He laughed kissing her cheek. Mercedes spun and got Tina. Tina spun and got Finn. Tina leaned crawled across and kissed Finn on the cheek.
"Oh come on, don't be a bunch a pussy's." Puck groaned. "We need some tongue action here. No more grandma kisses. From now on it has to be on the lips."
"Spin, Finn." Tina smiled.
Finn spun the bottle hard and it felt like forever before it finally stopped spinning.
"Oh hot damn." Mercedes laughed.
"I should have gotten out my camera." Kurt shook with excitement.
Tina's eyes widened as she looked over at Rachel. Rachel looked up from the bottle pointing at her and over at Finn.
"I-I can spin again." Finn reached for the bottle again.
"It's okay." Puck shrugged. "It's the rules of the game."
Finn cleared his throat and looked at Rachel. She was wedged between Puck and Finn. She took a deep breath as Finn leaned closer to her.
His lips met hers and Rachel noticed that the kiss lingered for longer than it should have. She broke away from Finn and looked at Puck. She grabbed his hand and squeezed it. She chose to ignore the widened stares of Tina, Kurt, and Mercedes.
"My turn." Rachel turned the attention back to the game. She spun the bottle but before it could stop spinning Puck reached out and stopped it himself.
"Lookie there." Puck smirked. "It landed on me."
"Noah." Rachel swatted his chest. "That's cheating."
Puck rolled his eyes and pulled Rachel to him. His tongue forced its way into her mouth. After what felt like minutes Puck finally let go of Rachel. "That is how you play the game." He said defiantly.
