It was halfway through the summer and I was still with Oliver. I was seeing a psychologist so I wouldn't have anymore freak-outs about Mike. She was really helping me. So there I was at the beach with Oliver. Miley walked up reading a text and giggling.
"Who's the guy Miley?" I asked.
"Someone." She smiled.
"I have to tell the story first." Miley added.
"Tell!" I said.
"Ok so there's this website online like e-harmony but for teens. Anyways, I was getting lonely and wanted a boyfriend. So I got a profile on it and now I'm talking to this guy! And he's my age!" Miley smiled.
"What's his name?" I asked.
"Tim." Miley smiled.
"He texted me back!" Miley said.
Miley read the text.
"He says to meet him at the mall now." She said.
"Lilly, Oliver, come with me please." Miley begged.
"We'll come." I said.
Oliver and I went to the mall with Miley.
"He just texted me to meet him by Hot Topic." Miley said.
We walked over to Hot Topic.
"Miley?" a hooded guy asked.
"Tim?" Miley asked.
He nodded.
"Show yourself." Miley said.
"Um can we be alone without your friends?" he asked.
"Sure, see you guys later." Miley said.
Oliver and I walked away towards the exit. I turned and saw Miley and Tim following. They were going towards the exit too. Once outside, Oliver and I walked towards his car. When I opened the car door, I heard a scream. I looked around and saw nothing.
At 11:30 p.m., I was asleep in my bed. Suddenly, my phone rang.
"Hello?"
"Lilly! It's Mr. Stewart! Have you've seen Miley?"
"Um, she was hanging out with this guy she met."
"She told me that and that she would be home at 8:30 and she's not here!"
"Relax, I'm sure she's scared that she broke curfew. I'll call her."
"Ok thanks Lilly."
I hung up and dialed Miley's number.
"Lilly?"
"Miley, where are you?"
"Um…I need you to pick me up."
"What?"
"Yes, Tim left me at the lighthouse."
"Ok I'll be right there."
I hung up the phone. I told my mom I was picking Miley up. I went to the lighthouse. I opened the door and yelled.
"Miley?"
"Lilly, walk upstairs!"
I went upstairs. My mouth dropped. Miley was tied to a chair with tears rolling down her face. She had a black eye and her bottom lip was bleeding. I saw Tim facing her.
"What did you do Tim?" I asked.
"I'm not Tim." He said.
"Then who are you?" I asked.
He turned towards me. I gasped.
"Mike?" I asked.
"That's right." He smiled.
"But how?" I asked.
"Well, I made up a new name. Tim Smith. Pretty smart huh?" he asked.
"Why are you here?" I asked.
"Finish unfinished business without Oken around." He smiled.
"Miley is here." I pointed out.
"Not for long." He said.
He opened the window of the lighthouse and picked Miley up.
"Say goodbye." Mike smiled.
He threw Miley out and I heard her body splash in the ocean.
"Miley!" I yelled out the window.
It was too dark to see.
"Now we're alone." Mike smiled as he closed the window.
I froze, I didn't know what was going to happen.