A/N: Thanks for all of the reviews, follows and favourites. This is a new chapter. The full chapter focuses on junior prom when Brittany and Santana hooked up.
Chapter 10: Flashback, summer 2014
Brittany's POV
I'm dancing on my own because my friends are either at the rest room or dancing with their date, when I hear someone say "Hey, what's up?" I turn around towards the voice and I realise that that someone is Santana Lopez, the hottest girl in school and the one I have been crushing on for a while now. She's the head cheerleader and most popular girl in school so for her to speak to me does make me a little surprised.
"Nothing" I say nervously, immediately I stop dancing.
"Can I get you a drink?" she asks with the brightest smile I've ever seen, how have I never noticed her smile before? I always thought she was beautiful but I have definitely never seen that smile before. Santana Lopez isn't exactly known for her cheery nature, she's famous for giving out death glares and making bitchy remarks.
"No thanks, I'm fine" I reply and she smiles again. Ok, now I just want to take a picture of that smile so I can look at it all day.
"Ok, cool" she says. "Want to dance instead?" I can never let an opportunity to dance pass so I decide to accept her offer.
"Yeah, sure" I say and Santana puts down her drink before leading me to the dance floor. We dance for a while together and I have to say, I feel very comfortable around her considering how she acts around me at school. Santana's the popular cheerleader and I'm a nerd and at McKinley high, those two do not match.
"You have really blue eyes" Santana observes before pulling me closer to her so we can dance closer for the slow song that just came on. "They're so pretty and sparkle in the light."
"Thanks" I say, blushing slightly. "Why are you not dancing with your date?" I ask out of curiosity because come on, if I was Santana Lopez I wouldn't dance with me over some attractive popular kid.
"They aren't as hot as you are" Santana says and I laugh, good one. "What?" she says.
"Good joke, but I'm serious" I say.
"As am I" Santana responds with a smile. "You're beautiful."
"I'm not going to…..like, get beat up by your date or something…am I?" I ask nervously and Santana laughs.
"Why would you think that?" Santana asks grinning.
"Because I am dancing with you and I don't want them to get angry that I am dancing with their date" I answer.
"Don't worry honey" she says smiling. "I will keep you perfectly safe." I'm not entirely sure what she means by that but I nod my head anyway, having a crush on this girl definitely makes me a bit of a pushover.
"Do you work out?" I ask. I know it was pretty random but believe it or not, I'm not overly keen on silence for too long plus I'm dancing with the girl so I may as well get to know her a little.
Santana laughs "The question was a little out of the blue but yes I do" she answers.
"From your appearance you look so thin but by the way you are holding me, I can tell you are quite strong" I say. If I were ever lucky enough to get married then I would definitely want to be married to someone like Santana, someone I know will be able to make me feel safe and secure.
"Was that a complement or an insult?" Santana asks with a smirk.
"Obviously it was an insult" I say and Santana smiles before frowning.
"Wait, what?"
I laugh "I'm joking, of course it was a complement" I answer and Santana smiles.
"So where's your date?" Santana asks. "Not that I care, I'm going to keep dancing with you anyway."
"I didn't actually come with a date" I reply.
"Someone stood you up?" Santana says shaking her head with a frown. "Tell me the fucker's name, I will teach him/her a lesson."
"I didn't get stood up" I reply. "I just never had a date in the first place, there was no one I wanted to ask so I just didn't bother."
"You can be my date" Santana says smiling and I laugh.
"You've already got a date."
"I had one but not anymore, I've found myself a new date" Santana says. "A hotter one."
I instantly blush, I hate that Santana has this effect on me because it clouds my view of reality. Instead of blushing I should be asking Santana why she's took such a sudden interest in me after she has teased me for so many years.
"You're cute when you blush" Santana says which results in me doing my utmost to ensure I don't blush again, I really got to try and change the subject here before I look like a tomato. A beet red face wouldn't exactly complement my purple dress now would it.
"Tell me something people don't know about you" I say and suddenly Santana pulls me super close.
"Dancing with really attractive, hot girls like you turns me on" she whispers sexily in my ear before pulling away with a smirk. "I also find intelligence really sexy and we all know you're pretty clever."
"Oh..." I say blushing, I couldn't muster up a reply because I was too shocked at what she said. I totally did not expect her to say that, I was waiting for something like I'm secretly obsessed with comics or I like video games or I hate cheerleading but only do it for the popularity. I honestly did not expect her to try and flirt with me.
"I'm surprised someone as attractive as you doesn't have a boyfriend or girlfriend" Santana says. "On the bright side though, that's a bonus for me because now I can spend the rest of the night with you."
When the song finishes Santana leads me over to the side of the room and we take a seat.
"So any plans for the rest of the night?" Santana asks me and I shake my head.
"Just going home, too late to do anything else" I reply. "I told my parents I would be back home after the conclusion of the party anyway."
"How would you like to come with me to an after party" she says. "It's our only junior prom, why let it end too early?"
"I don't know, I'm not really the party type" I say and Santana smiles.
"How about we just hang out then?" she asks and I think about it. "We can go to the party and if we don't like it then we can just bail, you can give your parents a call and say you will be later than first thought"
"Ok" I say. "Yeah, why not?" I say aloud. My mom has always wanted me to be a little more sociable because apparently I spend too much time with my head in a book and that isn't healthy.
"Cool" Santana says. "I thought we could head to the party straight after everything wraps up here but first I need to go up on stage, being a nominee for prom queen and all" Santana kisses my cheek before standing up "Wait here for me, ok." I nod at Santana to which she smiles at me then makes her way on stage. I remain where I am as the principal reads out each of the names of the nominees for king and queen.
"Hey"
I turn round and see Tina "Hey" I reply with a smile. "Are you having fun with your date?"
"I was until he left for the bathroom and then came back and made out with some blonde bimbo" Tina says.
"I'm sorry T" I say rubbing her back. "You were too good for him anyway."
"So how's your prom?" Tina asks.
"Ok" I respond.
"I spend like half an hour looking for you" she says before smirking at me. "Did you hook up with someone?"
"I didn't hook up with anyone" I answer. "I was with someone though" I say trying to conceal the smile that wants to emerge across my face.
"Tell me the details" Tina says grinning.
"There isn't much to tell" I say. "We danced and chatted for a bit" I say shrugging, trying to act nonchalant.
"There's something you're not telling me Brittany" Tina sing-songs.
"If you must know" I say turning to Tina. "She asked me to accompany her to an after party."
"You're going right?"
"I think so" I reply.
"You have to go" Tina says. "I haven't seen you look this happy in a while so maybe this girl is the one for you."
"Steady on" I say a little panicked. "We're just going to hang out and dance and stuff, it isn't like a date or anything."
"Fair enough but you never know, maybe after tonight you might find you want to ask her out on a date" Tina says shrugging her shoulders. "I'm heading home after this so I want all the details on Monday, you understand?"
"Yeah" I say and Tina hugs me before standing up. "If you want to come to the party, I'm sure it would be ok."
Tina smiles "No it's cool, but thanks" she says hugging me again. "See you on Monday when we go to the cinema." I wave at Tina and then she disappears. Maybe after tonight I could ask Santana to hang out again, I mean we do have the full summer holidays ahead of us.
"Ready?" Santana says and I nod.
"So how does it feel to be prom queen?"
"No different to how it felt when I wasn't queen" Santana answers. "I couldn't care less if I won or not, I just like annoying my fellow cheerio's by making them think I care."
"So I won't find you ditching me for the prom king at this after party then?"
"As if" Santana says. "There's no way I would ditch someone as gorgeous as you for some horny teenage boy." Santana looks at me "I'm all yours tonight, don't worry about that." I smile at Santana but yet it feels so surreal, I've had a crush on her for a while but she never paid any attention to me but now all of a sudden she's paying nothing but attention to me.
"Some people are playing spin the bottle, want to join in?" Santana asks but I shake my head.
"Not really" I reply. "It's not really my thing but you go play if you want."
"Nah, its fine" she says waving it off. "I didn't want to either, I just thought I would ask you."
"So…" I say, not really sure what else to say.
"I can tell this isn't really your thing" Santana says. "How about we grab some liquor from here and head back to my house to hang out" Santana says looking at me. "Just the two of us, we can chat or watch a movie."
"Ok" I reply.
"Just say if you would prefer me to walk you home instead because I would be cool with that too" Santana says. "I respect that you maybe don't like the things I do, I mean I never even asked if you drink alcohol."
"I want to hang out with you" I reply quickly, almost too quickly. Jeez, I don't want to act like I'm desperate.
"Ok then" Santana says smiling before leading me to the kitchen. "We will take some beers and a bottle of vodka, is that ok?" Santana asks and I nod. I've never drank much before so I don't really have much preference when it comes to alcohol. "I only live one street over so we should manage to walk, unless you want me to call a cab."
"Walking's fine" I reply with a smile.
We reach Santana's front door but before we go in, Santana stops me. "We need to be really quiet so as we don't wake anyone up" Santana says and I nod. "Cool" she says before leading me quietly inside before we head up to her bedroom. "Make yourself comfortable, I am just going down to the kitchen to get us some snacks." I nod at Santana before she leaves the room. I quickly check the time on my watch and realise it is quarter to one so I decide to text my mom to tell her I am staying at Tina's, Santana said I can stay over tonight since it will probably be too late to go home after we hangout. I decide not to tell my mom I am staying at Santana because A- she probably hasn't ever heard of a Santana or B- if she has heard of Santana, it probably wouldn't be for good reasons.
Just as I place my phone on Santana's desk she walks in with hundreds of food. "Wow, you're certainly hungry" I say with a smile.
"Ha-ha" Santana replies. "But when I was in the kitchen an idea popped into my head; we should totally play that game where one person is blind folded and the other gives them a mystery piece of food and the blind person has to guess what it was."
"Ok, we can play" I say. "One thing though, can we rule out mustard because it makes me feel really sick?"
"Sure" Santana replies setting the food down. "I don't like mustard either."
After drinking a few beers and some vodka we decide to give the alcohol a break for a bit. "Ok, your turn" I say to Santana before placing the scarf round her eyes. "Can you see me?" I ask to make sure she can't see through the scarf.
"No Brittany, I can't" she answers. "Just like I couldn't see you when you fed me a teaspoon of ketchup, rubbed a potato chip on my lips and made me taste beer and vodka mixed together."
"Ok" I say before taking a teaspoon of jam and placing a tiny bit of salt on it and then holding it in front of Santana's lips. "Ok, open your mouth" I say, to which Santana obliges. As soon as she tastes what's on the spoon she spits it out and whips the scarf off.
"What the fuck is that?" Santana says, sticking her tongue out and wiping it with a tissue.
"What do you think it was?" I ask with a mischievous grin on my face.
"I don't know but it was as sure as hell disgusting" Santana says screwing her face up.
I decide to put her out of her misery and tell her what it was "It was strawberry jam with a pinch of salt."
"Aw man, it was terrible" Santana says.
"Sorry" I apologise.
"Your turn now" Santana says smirking. Now I know this is going to be disgusting, there's no way I would get away with giving her something extremely bad that easily. Santana wraps the scarf around my eyes. "Are you ready?" she asks and I put my thump up and nod. "Ok, here we go." What I taste in my mouth was actually really good, it was fruity.
"That was good" I say. "What was that?"
"Orange and ginger conserve" Santana replies. "My brother is like obsessed with it."
"It was tasty" I say, licking my lips which causes Santana to laugh at me.
"Ok, let's make this game more interesting" Santana says smiling.
"How so?" I ask.
"Well, every time one of us fails to correctly identify the foodstuff we have to take a shot" Santana answers.
"We don't have shots though" I say.
"We will just use vodka and mix it with beer" Santana says. "We will only make them small glasses so we don't get too drunk."
"Ok then, why not?" I reply. I don't usually drink much alcohol at all but I am having so much fun with Santana then I'm sure one night won't hurt, I mean I don't suppose anything bad will happen tonight.
"Cool" Santana says, preparing some glasses of beer and vodka mix using some plastic cups she had in her room. I don't bother to ask why she has a stack of plastic cups stored in her closet.
After I drank four cups of the alcohol mix and Santana drunk two, I suddenly gain the courage to become more daring. "How about we make this game even more interesting?" I say smirking.
"How much more interesting can it get?" Santana asks raising an eyebrow.
"How about we continue this game but instead of tasting the foodstuff via the spoon we use our lips?" I ask confidently. Either alcohol makes me more courageous or my crush on Santana has took over my mind.
"Brittany Pierce" Santana says smirking. "I think someone secretly just wants me to kiss them."
"Maybe I do" I say boldly.
"What happened to the normally shy girl?" Santana asks gently punching my shoulder and I just shrug. I have no idea where my sudden confidence has come from but I won't deny that I would love to kiss Santana. "Come and sit down next to me then" Santana says, patting the bed next to her so I do as I am told. As soon as I sit down Santana leans in towards me, which causes my heart to beat faster. I lean in towards Santana slowly, closing my eyes, prepared for our lips to connect…but it doesn't happen.
I open my eyes and see Santana smiling at me "What….?"
"I want to kiss you too babe but before we can do that we need to find a winner for this game" Santana says. "I'm afraid we are tied at the moment" Santana tells me shrugging.
I don't know how it happened but suddenly I am lying on Santana's bed staring at the ceiling as she lies next to me, placing kisses all over my neck and across my jawline. One minute I am identifying the taste of toothpaste on Santana's lips during our game and now suddenly we are in this position. I feel a sense of fear going through my body but it's not because I am scared of Santana, it's because I am nervous of what Santana will think of me. Santana slowly moves her hand down to reach for my waist, occasionally squeezing my hip. This action makes me aware of my surrounding and I get freaked out so I try to pull away from Santana.
"I n-need to tell you…..something" I manage to get out as Santana places sporadic kisses all over my neck.
"Uh-huh" the husky but sexy voice replies.
"I haven't….d-done….it before" I say, taking a big gulp of air.
"Done what?" she asks, momentarily halting her kisses to my neck.
"You know…..it" I reply quietly, almost whispering.
"Oh" Santana says after a few seconds. "Well that's ok, we don't need to do anything."
"No-no, I want to. I want you to be my first" I say, almost pathetically. See the thing is, I've had a crush on Santana from the moment I laid my eyes on her and if there's anyone in this world I would want to be my first then it's her.
"You don't need to say that Brittany" she says.
"I know but I genuinely do want this" I say. "Santana, I know we have never really talked until tonight but what I do know is that I trust you" I tell her sincerely. "And I want you to be my first because I trust you" I say and Santana looks shocked.
"You trust me?" she asks and I nod. "We barely know one another" she says.
"I know enough to know that I trust you" I reply because I do.
She swings her leg over my hips so she is straddling my waist. This is the closest I have ever came to anyone, never mind a girl. She wraps her arms round my neck and leans in and kisses me gently. As she kisses me again she intertwines her hands behind my neck so there is really no way of moving my head anymore, not that I want to randomly twist my head from side to side anyway.
It quickly becomes not so innocent when she moves her hands to take mine and places my hands on her butt. "Oh" I say, a little too loud if I'm honest, when she places my hands firmly on her butt. I didn't think I'd feel anything when I touched it, but boy did something shoot through me.
Santana's hands are locked around my neck again and she is kissing me passionately on the lips. Each time she takes my lip between hers, she sucks on it that bit longer. She seems particularly fond of my bottom lip for some reason and I don't really know why, it's just a lip. I try to keep up with her but she just seems to be getting faster and kissing me more passionately each time that sometimes I feel her teeth knock against mine.
It's not long before I feel Santana's tongue enter my mouth and boy, when her tongue enters do I feel something I have never felt before. I literally feel like I have just gone to heaven, Santana is slowly caressing the underside of my tongue with her own.
I feel Santana move her hands to the back of my dress and start to pull the zip down slowly as she kisses me. Once the zip is successfully down she slowly removes the dress from my shoulders, exposing my bra. Crap, I've just realised I'm not even wearing my fancy bra, I'm just wearing some normal everyday comfortable one.
She pulls me to my knees where she then bunches the dress up and pulls it off of me over my head. I am now kneeling on the bed in nothing but a bra and a pair of panties that don't even match. Just as I'm about to speak, Santana loosens her dress off and takes it off over her head and tosses it to the floor before pushing me back on the bed, signalling for me to lie down. She doesn't move for a few seconds, she just stays there kneeling on the bed while staring at me. Ok if I wasn't self-conscious before, I am now. She is looking me up and down and it's starting to make me feel embarrassed now, she's probably realised how unattractive I am.
"You have an amazing body do you know that?" she says to me while continuing to stare. I didn't expect her to say that whatsoever.
"Um…." I'm not sure how to respond. "I don't really like the way I look" I state.
"Are you kidding me, you have an amazing body?" she says with a smile. I appreciate the compliment but I really don't think I do look that good.
After a few moments she gently lies on top of me with one of my legs trapped between hers. Wait a second, did I just feel something damp on my leg? It takes me a second before I realise what I felt.
"Shit" I mutter aloud. I didn't mean to say it out loud but it came anyway.
"What's wrong?" Santana asks as she raises her head from where she was assaulting my neck with kisses.
"Uh….nothing" I say. Santana just shrugged and went back to kissing my neck. I can't believe I actually made Santana Lopez wet. I mean she did say I turned her on but I thought that was all talk, I didn't realise she would actually be wet because of me.
"Can I take this off?" I hear Santana ask as she starts to slide her hands under my bra. I nod my head quickly and stay still as Santana removes the item, I feel extremely self-conscious but it subsides when Santana kisses me gently on the lips. "You're beautiful, there's no need to feel shy" Santana tells me, kissing my cheek this time.
Before I know it, the heat of the moment takes over us and I am short of breath as I kiss Santana languidly, breathing deeply. Words cannot describe how good Santana just made me feel, I've never experienced anything like that before. I have to admit, I think losing my virginity to Santana was the best decision I ever made. The crush I have on this gorgeous Latina has just increased tenfold.
"Oh my god" Santana moans loudly, rolling off of me. "Are you sure that was your first time?"
"Yes, why would I lie?" I ask defensively, a little too defensively I think because suddenly Santana is looking straight at me.
"I didn't mean you were lying" she says with a bright smile. "I just meant you were so good."
"Oh" I say, feeling a little embarrassed. "Did you really think I was ok?"
"Yeah!" Santana says as if it's obvious. "Couldn't you tell?" Santana asks, pecking me on the lips. "I think we should get some sleep, you look tired" Santana observes while stroking my cheek. "You are incredibly beautiful Brittany, don't ever let anyone tell you otherwise" Santana tells me honestly with a kiss to my cheek before sleep takes over us.
A/N: Hope the chapter was ok. The next chapter will be back in the present time.