February 14th

Dani had been trapped in the Winchesters room all night. Around 3 a.m. she'd given in and gotten in bed with Sam. It was awkward since she was still feeling too sensitive, but it was better than getting in bed with Dean. Sam had put his arm around her in his sleep and she'd moved close opportunistically. It wasn't honorable, but it was necessary. She was desperate to feel his skin against hers. Stupid Lust.

"Good morning!" Jenny said brightly as she opened the door. "Are you all still sleeping?" She clicked her tongue in dismay, but then she noticed that Dani and Sam were entangled on the bed closest to her. "It's about time!" She plopped herself down on the foot of their bed and smiled happily.

"What?" Sam mumbled. "Oh." He started to move back, but Dani tightened her grip.

Jenny sighed dreamily. "Oh, to be in the throes of love and the heat of the moment."

"Um. No, no throes. No heat," Sam said, untangling Dani's arms and then pressing her wrists down against the bed to keep her from grabbing him again. She groaned low in her throat and he shook her awake before she could do anything embarrassing.

"Sam?" she asked, confused. "Oh crap."

It was the real Sam, not the highly inventive dream Sam of a few seconds ago. What had she said? She glanced over and saw her sister smiling at Dean, who was asleep in the next bed.

Dani sat up quickly. "You!"

"Me?" Jenny asked innocently. "What did I do?"

"What did you do?" Dani shouted. "What didn't you do? Tell her, Sam!" She smacked him in the chest with the back of her hand.

"Um," Sam said, unsure of what to say. "You seemed to have a, uh, a really good day yesterday."

"I did have a nice day!" Jenny grinned broadly. "And a really nice morning."

"I am scarred for life!" Dani informed her.

"Why? You weren't there."

"I saw everything!" Dani knew that she was exaggerating now, but she'd seen more than enough and she figured that gave her license for hyperbole.

"We didn't see everything," Sam amended.

"I hope not," Jenny agreed. "That would just be awkward."

"It was awkward," Dani said. "Awkward and horrible. Sam! Tell her!"

"Tell her what?" Sam asked. "I think she gets that it freaked you out."

"It should freak all of us out! Walking in on that was the worst thing ever!"

"There are worse things," Sam said with a shiver of disgust.

"Did something bad happen to you, Sam?" Jenny asked.

"Bad things didn't stop happening for a while," Sam informed her. "It was just one bad thing after another all the way back from the library."

"Wait… are those hickies?" Jenny asked, climbing over him to get a better look at his neck. "Oh my God, Sam! What did you do yesterday and why wasn't I invited?"

"You were busy!" Dani informed her. "Besides, all he did was walk down the street."

Sam nodded forlornly.

"He came home half naked," Dani said, remembering it. "It was..." Perfection. "These people are savages."

"These people?" Jenny asked. "I've only met really nice people since we've been here."

"The tupperorgy lady was nice," Dean said from the other bed.

"Forget the tupperorgy!" Dani snarled.

Dean started to tell her that it had been pretty damn unforgettable, and then he remembered yesterday and dropped the subject. Dani looked down at the blanket, unable to look at Dean.

"Are you hiding something?" Jenny asked. "It looks like you're blushing."

"Me?" Dani asked with a forced laugh. "What would I be hiding?"

"Nothing," Dean said. "She was with me. All day. So if she was hiding something I'd be hiding it too. And I'm not. We should get breakfast."

"Oh my God! You're blushing too!" Jenny giggled. "That is too cute!" She moved over to the other bed and took a very close look at Dean's face. "You're adorable when you blush!"

"You know what?" Dani said, standing up and planting her hands on her hips. "You know what we're hiding?"

Dean pulled away from Jenny's gaze with some reluctance. "Nothing! We're hiding nothing."

"We walked in on you and a million other girls!" Dani finished, rolling her eyes at Dean. She'd take what they'd done in the Impala to her grave, and he'd better do the same.

"I'd hardly call five girls 'a million'."

"Do you even remember hearing me open the door?"

"Nope, "Jenny said distractedly. She couldn't listen to Dani while her full attention was drawn back to Dean. "We should get out of here. I can introduce you to some of my friends!"

"No," Sam said firmly. "We're getting rid of the demon. Then, if you still feel the same way about your friends, you can do whatever you want with them."

"I'd feel a lot better about working if I could get a quickie in first." Jenny grinned at Dean. A smile curved his mouth and she remembered why she'd been so attracted to him in the first place.

"There will be no more sex!" Dani said emphatically. "We are going! Right now!" No one moved. So much for her rallying abilities.

"Then you should go," Jenny mumbled moments before her lips pressed against Dean's.

"Winchester! You have to at least wait a full twenty four hours to bone my sister!" Dani snapped as she pulled her jeans on.

Sam smacked Dean in the back of the head. "Come on, man. I'm pretty sure Dani's about to cry."

There was still no reaction. At least, not to what Sam was saying.

"Sam!" Dani wailed. She wasn't about to cry. But she was pretty close to throwing up.

Sam sighed. "All right, fine. But I feel like a jerk about it."

He wrapped his arms around Jenny and lifted her out of Dean's embrace.

"Wah?" Jenny cried out. "Put me down!"

"If you put her down I'll put a hurt on you," Dani promised when Sam gave her a look. She put on her big sister voice. "Now, listen, Jenny." She hadn't used the voice in a long time, but she was pleased to find that it still worked. "We have a demon to kill and we need your help because otherwise we're all just going to be horny until we die. Or we'll bone until we die..." Dani trailed off for a second, thinking about her dream. "And we'd be happy, but we'd be dead. So, let's kill Lust and then you can have all the sex you want. Okay?"

"I kind of planned on fucking until I died anyway," Jenny countered. "And look how sad you're making Dean!"

Dean was sitting on the edge of the bed with a mixture of longing and determination on his face.

Dani smacked him across the back of the head. "Man up!"

"Son of a bitch!"

"Now," she said, turning back to Jenny. "You know that I can't let you die. If Sam puts you down can you get your head in the game for a few hours?"

Jenny sighed. "I… I can try… maybe."

Dani grabbed her sister's face with both hands. "I am counting on you. Do not make me buy you a chastity belt. And you don't want to know what I'll do to you," she said, turning to Dean. "All right, Sam. Put her down."

Jenny fell to the floor in a crumpled heap.

Dani dragged her upright. "Look at me! I know what it's like to want something so much you want to die when you don't get it. But we've got a job to do and we're going to do it! And if I die, you'll feel bad about it when you're not horny anymore and you know it."

"I'm trying… you have no idea how hard this is for me, do you?" Jenny whined.

"You have no idea about the ideas I have ideas about!" Dani snapped. "Now are we doing this, or not?"

Jenny looked up at her, tears wavering in her eyes. "I… I'm going to do my best." She reached for her sister's hand.

"Would it help if I put a bag over Winchester's head?" Dani asked.

"No, I want to look at him."

"And what about you?" Sam asked Dean dryly. "Think you'll make it?"

"I don't even know if I can stand up right now," Dean answered gruffly.

Sam rolled his eyes and pushed the girls out of the room. "Three minutes," he called over his shoulder.

"Okay," Dani said once they were outside in the fresh air. "So, Lust is a person. Well...wearing a person. So maybe..."

She lost her train of thought when Sam caught her eye. He had such nice, expressive eyes and they looked green in the morning light, even though they tended to shift depending on what he was wearing and his mood. Hazel eyes were incredibly attractive and she hadn't even noticed it before.

"Uh, maybe it's a person that Jenny saw," Sam suggested when Dani didn't speak again.

"Right! That. And someone who was at the tupperorgy." Dani clinked her tongue ring against her teeth. "I hate to say this, but Jenny, tell me about your super fun happy orgy walk."

"Well, I was at the library and this woman asked me a question about one of the books on my table and then one thing led to another…" Jenny's eyes started to glaze over.

Dani snapped her fingers. "Stay with me."

"What did she look like?" Sam asked. "Because there was a redhead behind the desk that was pretty aggressive."

"No." Jenny shook her head vehemently. "She had dusky golden skin and luscious, full lips that you could suck on for hours. Her hair was dark and wavy… it makes you want to pull it…" Jenny's eyes wavered into the distance again. "You just want to lick everything on her."

"I think I saw her leaving the library," Sam said suddenly.

"And I saw her at the Tupperware party!" Dani said. "She asked us to join in. She touched the back of my neck." She ran her fingers over the place again. It seemed warmer than the rest of her skin. "And Dean on the cheek! That explains the...uh..." She let the sentence die, remembering what had happened in the Impala. She might be stable enough to know that she didn't want Dean, but that didn't mean that she didn't remember parts of him fondly. Like his hands. And his lips. And his…she blushed.

"Explains what?" Sam asked.

"Nothing! The party. Dean wanted to stay. It must have been because she touched him." She turned to her sister. "But she made out with you or whatever, no details for the love of God, and you're way worse off than we-Dean. Dean is."

"It was soooo much more than making out," Jenny agreed.

"Okay!" Dean called as he walked across the parking lot, looking a bit more relaxed. "Let's get this thing done! Let's talk!"

"Actually, let's go," Sam corrected. "Apparently it's the hot dark haired woman that invited you to the tupperorgy."

"Oh. Okay then. So where is she now?" Dean asked.

"I don't know," Sam answered, speaking slowly. "We have to find her."

"Right, okay." Dean slid behind the wheel. Dani shoved Jenny into the backseat and got in beside her to ensure that she didn't try anything funny.

"Anybody else think it's creepy that there are no lights on?" Sam asked as they drove through town.

"What?" Dani asked. She'd been distracted by his hair again. She wanted to bury her fingers in it, maybe brush the back of his neck...how was she getting turned on by the back of his neck? She let out her breath out, disgusted with herself. "You're right. Maybe we'd be better off if we parked and walked."

Dean pulled the Impala into a parking spot and they got out. After a few steps, Jenny said, "Do you hear that?"

Everyone stopped and listened.

"Ew," Dani muttered as the moans grew clearer.

"I think it's coming from over there," Dean said, pointing down the street.

"The church?" Sam asked as they walked closer.

"The church," Dani confirmed with a slight grimace as the sounds amplified. "Are we actually going in there, or do you think maybe we can just lure her out?"

"I can go get her and get her," Jenny offered.

"No!" Dani said emphatically. "You stay with me."

Jenny whimpered as Sam opened the church door.

"Oh. My. God." Dean said and Sam knew it was the most reverent his older brother had ever been inside the walls of a church.

Dani pressed her hand to her mouth as she looked in. It was the most primal scene she'd ever imagined. Lust stood naked in the pulpit, and two of her followers stood with her. A man stood behind her, his hand light on her throat, as a woman knelt in front of her, running her tongue down the demon's inner thigh. Heavy smoke from a thousand incense burners wafted lazily through the air, twining around the demon and her worshipers and clouding Dani's senses with cloves and honey.

The rest of the room was in complete disarray; writhing bodies covered the carpet, clothes were strewn over pews and draped over lamps. There were hands and feet sticking out from odd places here and there and the occasional head thrown back over pews, dozens of faces distorted in ecstasy.

Jenny inched closer without thinking. "It's so beautiful!"

Dani grabbed her by the back of the shirt. "Calm down."

"All right," Dean said suddenly, sounding positively brisk. "This is it. Too much." He turned to face Sam and clapped his brother on the shoulder. "I'm sorry, Sammy."

"What?" Sam asked, as Dean turned and headed into the room. "Oh no, you don't!"

He grabbed the back of Dean's jacket and then shoved him into the closet off the entrance.

Jenny took the moment of distraction to break free of Dani's grip.

Dani yanked her back, clapping a hand over her mouth to stifle her protests. "Hold the door, Sam!"

Once Dani had shoved her into the closet, Sam slammed the door and pulled a chair in front of it.

"Sam!" Dean yelled. "Damn it, Sammy, you open this-" his voice was suddenly cut off. Jenny had covered his mouth with hers.

"We don't have to leave just yet do we?" she asked when their lips finally parted.

"God no." he growled.

Dani listened to the sudden quiet. "Maybe we should have picked different closets."

"You really want to be the one to open that door?" Sam asked, glancing around and hoping for a brilliant idea.

"No. You've got a plan, right?"

"Um...yeah. Yeah, I think so, actually. Crap."

"Crap?" Dani asked. "What crap?"

"She's headed this way."

"What should we do?" she asked, feeling a bit nervous, but mostly just turned on. It was an odd combination.

"No idea. But we better do it quick, because I am not getting it on with everybody in this church," Sam said firmly.

"Okay, okay! I'll go and distract her."

Sam raised an eyebrow. "Are you sure?"

"She can't Lust me to death."

Dani stepped out of the hall and between the pews.

"I remember you," the demon said with a smile.

"Yeah, the tupperorgy," Dani said, walking closer, careful to avoid the people at her feet.

"Did you enjoy yourself that night?"

Dani felt her face flush. "That's not really...important."

"Not important?" The demon stepped closer to Dani, tipping her chin up with her slender, beautiful fingers. "It's everything, sweet thing."

"Everything?" Dani whispered as the fingers trailed down her neck and around to tug her hair.

"Everything," she confirmed before pulling Dani close.

It was everything. It was perfection. How could one kiss spread through her whole body and make her want so much more? Even kissing Dean hadn't felt like this.

She buried her fingers in the demon's hair and groaned against her lips. There was only one thing that would make this better.

"Sam," she said, breaking free of the kiss. "We should get Sam."

The demon's full lips curved and she kissed Dani once more. "That is an excellent idea."

Dani pulled her closer desperately and they stumbled back out into the hallway, half tripping over Lust's followers as the demon tugged off Dani's jacket and her overshirt, leaving her in only her tank top as Lust began to unbuckle her belt.

Suddenly, Sam reached out and yanked Dani out of her embrace.

The demon took a step forward, her eyes going black with anger when she was stopped by the trap Sam had just finished.

"Gotcha," he said, pulling his father's notebook out of his back pocket and beginning to read.

"You little bitch!" Lust screamed at Dani.

Dani wanted nothing more than to knock the book out of Sam's hands and drag him into the circle to join the beautiful demon, but she knew somewhere in the part of her that wasn't desperately needy that there was a reason not to.

She settled for stepping close to him and wrapping her arms around his waist. She pressed her face against his chest, half under his jacket so that she didn't have to see the demon or smell the incense. She could feel his voice vibrating through her as he spoke over the demon's curses and shrieks. An exorcism had never felt so sexy.

When it was finally over, Dani pulled away and leaned against the wall, exhaling with relief as most of her desperation drained away. She hadn't noticed how messed up her clothes were. She began tugging down her tank top and buckling her belt with shaking fingers.

"Thanks," Sam said, giving Dani a smile as he scooped up the woman who'd been host to Lust and laid her carefully down on one of the back pews.

"Yeah," Dani said with a weak smile as she wiped lipstick off of her mouth. "All part of the plan."

"Should we open the door?" Sam asked, pointing at the closet.

"The way I see it, if either of them wanted out, they'd manage it on their own," Dani said, shoving the chair out of the way but leaving the door firmly closed. "And...what are we going to say to all of them?" She inclined her head at the huge group of people getting gradually to their feet in the sanctuary.

Sam ducked out of sight, pressing his back to the wall and pulling Dani to the side with him, giving her a sidelong grin. "Do you really want to try to explain it?"

"No. But my shirt is out there. And my jacket."

Sam pulled his jacket off and draped it around Dani's shoulders. "Better?"

"Better," Dani said as she waved her hands, making the sleeves flap around.

They joined the confused crowd filing out of the church, but they took seats on the side of the steps, waiting for Jenny and Dean. Dani lit a cigarette, daring Sam to say something about it. He didn't.

It was almost an hour later when Jenny and Dean came stumbling out of the church doors, Jenny halfheartedly tucking her shirt in and Dean shrugging into his jacket.

"Hi!" Jenny chirped.

"You look cheerful," Sam said, opening the passenger side door and ushering Jenny into the front seat while Dani ducked into the back, keeping her face averted from the glance Dean threw her in the rearview mirror.

"I'm relieved," Jenny corrected.

"Must be nice," Dani said bitterly.

"What's your problem?" Jenny asked, noticing the lipstick still smeared on Dani's face. "Did you happen to make out with Lust? Are you upset because you kissed a girl I fucked?"

"No," Dani said. "This has been a weird 24 hours for me. Sexually."

Jenny turned and peered into her sister's face. "Huh? Pull over!" She waited only moments after the car had stopped before dragging her sister out. The moment they were out of earshot, Jenny turned to face Dani and looked seriously at her. "What else happened?"

"Nothing!" Dani said, wrapping Sam's jacket more tightly around her, as if it would shield her from Jenny's stare. "What...I mean, what else would there be?"

"You said twenty four hours... that means that Lust had taken effect on you before we went to the church."

"No, it doesn't. Don't be silly."

"Answer me quickly. I want this to be as painless for you as possible."

Dani buried her face in her hands. "Painless? This is the worst thing ever!"

Jenny patted her on the back. "Just let it out."

"Are you kidding?" Dani blurted out. "It's already screwed things up with Dean! He won't even look at me now!"

Jenny gasped. "You and Dean? What did you do? Spill the details! Why would you keep secrets from your sister?"

"Because it's awkward! And it wasn't...I mean...we didn't..." Dani sighed and made a graphic jerking motion. "Just that. And now everything is wrong and weird and...wrong."

"You gave him a hand job?" Jenny asked, tilting her head to the side. "You're so cute!"

"Bite me. It was reciprocated, just so you know. But you and Dean now..." She sighed, thinking of how awkward things were going to be now that she couldn't just go back to her regular life when this was done.

Jenny was going to want to hang out with Dean, which meant that she was going to have to hang out with Dean and he was going to keep being quiet around her and not looking at her and it was going to suck.

"So do you need me to back off? I can blame everything on Lust so that nothing is awkward." Jenny patted her older sister on the head.

"What?" Dani asked, flabbergasted. "You don't...you're not in love with him?"

"He's hot and he saved me from a wendigo... but love? That's just silly. If you want him then I'll support you. How long have you had feelings for him?"

"Whoa. No, no, I don't have...the feelings I have for Dean aren't the kind of feelings that mean that I have feelings about who he has sex with." Dani waved her hands, making the jacket sleeves flap again. "I just didn't want things to be weird between me and you. If you're cool with me jerking off the dude you just boned, then I'm marginally okay with it too."

"Wait. Are you saying that you want me to continue fucking him?" Jenny asked, nearly betraying her hope with her voice.

"Knock yourself out, little sister," Dani said with a grin.