Disclaimer: I do not own Pretty Little Liars

Toby (P.O.V)

I am ecstatic that Spencer is finally giving me a chance! For a second, I thought she never would.

Usually, I would never make much of an effort on a date. I would normally just take a girl to a movie that only I wanted to see. Or I would take her to a fast food restaurant, not wanting to spencd a lot of money. But this time will be different.

We will go where she wants to go, see a movie that she wants to see, and then go to a decent place for dinner.

I almost forgot! I need to tell people!

I dial Caleb's number.

"Hello?" He asks.

"Spence is giving me a chance!" I answer. I hear a loud What from the background, Caleb yell, and then the call ends.

Two minutes later, Hanna and the other two girls arrive.

Hanna (P.O.V)

I text the girls to meet me at Spencer's house. I can't believe she didn't tell me! I am so excited for them! They are going to get married, and that is my final decision!

I walk right into Spencer's house and barge into her room.

"Excuse me!" She yells.

"You didn't tell me?!"

"Tell you what?!"

Just as Emily and Aria walk in, I say, "That you and Toby are going out on a date!"

They gasp.

"What?!" They yell. Toby walks in and says, "I am taking Spence out, Hanna said."

"Get out Toby." Aria orders.

"Get out Toby. I have to get ready." Spencer says. "I'll wait here." He smirks. Spencer walks over to him and gives him a kiss. Without another word, he leaves.

I smiled at her. "You guys are so cute together!" I squeal.

"Shut up." She tells me. I reach into my purse and take out my make up. Aria takes a brush from the bathroom while Emily starts searching through the closet.

Makeover!

Spencer (P.O.V)

They order me to take a shower, even though I already did this morning. When I'm done, Emily hands me clothes to change into. I am wearing a casual loose magenta tank top and dark skinny jeans. Also, I am wearing a pair of brown boots.

"Emily, what if I get cold? We are going out at night." I ask as Aria does my hair.

"One second." She says.

I hear her go to his room and tell him to wear a sweater on the date. When she comes back, she tells me that it is all taken care of and I don't need a sweater or jacket.

When Aria's finished with my hair, I see what she has done. (A/N: It's the same hairstyle as when she reunited with Toby in 3x12, when she saw him in the reflection in the glass.)

Hanna's done with my make up, and I am just wearing some black eyeliner that is smudged in purposefully and stylishly, to make my eyes pop. Also, she put on a bit of mint lip gloss.

I thank the girls and they leave. Toby knocks on my door and HE is wearing a button up shirt and dark jeans. (A/N: He looks exactly how he did when he came back in season two with the new haircut and attitude.)

"Wow, you are beautiful tonight." He said.

"So you are saying I was ugly earlier?" I tease, knowing how nervous he is.

"No! You're always beautiful, I just-"

"Toby, I was joking. Thank you for the compliment, and you are very handsome." I say, interrupting him.

When we get to the movies, he asks what I want to see.

"I don't care what we watch." He picks a movie and I agree to it.

"Are you sure?" He asks, as if this is one of the biggest moments of my life.

"Yes, Toby, I am more sure than I ever have been." I tease him again. He loosens up finally and we enter the movie theater. We sit in the back row, which is empty. All of the other people are in the front rows.

I am fine with the movie until I realize something.

"You picked a horror movie?" I ask. He nods with a sly smirk and I gulp.

Some girl dies already, but that's what she gets for tripping over air.

I snicker. But then some more people start dying and the killer gets creepier. I jump when the masked psychopath gets a sudden closeup on the screen. Toby holds my hand, and I squeeze it.

I am fine when the humans die, because they were disobeying the rules of horror movies. That man never should have said he'll be right back. He won't be back. Then people are drinking, another fail. Then, some girl decides that while a bunch of people are getting killed, she wants to go and have her first time.

But then a dog dies, and I lose it. Toby yawns and put an arm around my shoulder, and I try so hard not to laugh at that cliché.

When the movie is over, I tell him that I'm fine and I am not scared.

"But that dog died for no freaking reason!" I yell. He chuckles and kisses me on the cheek.

"Do you want to get something to eat?" He asks me.

"As much as seeing a movie filled with blood and guts makes me hungry, I think I would like to pass." That is what I was about to say. But that look in his eyes that he really does want me to have a good time causes me to say, "Yeah, I would love to."

To be honest, this date is fun. It is a lot better than the dates Wren used to take me on. He would take me to the fanciest place he could afford, but I never really felt comfortable that way. I just want to have fun, and I can with Toby.

We decide to skip food and go straight to ice cream.

"I am having a really good time, Toby, you know that, right?" I ask.

"Are you sure? I know you didn't really want to go out int the first place." I stop him right there.

"Toby, listen. I really like you. The only reason I refused to go out with you is because I wanted to make sure you weren't looking for one date. I want a relationship with you." I say.

"About that, I think we are better off as friends. It's not you, it's me. I just think it would be really awkward if we broke up." I was about to get pissed, but then he smiles at me in a way that I know... he's joking.

I laugh and look at his nose.

"What?" He asks.

"You have something there." I say.

"Where?" He asks.

"Right...there." I say as I use his own hand to shove his ice cream cone onto his nose.

We spend the next ten minutes battling with our ice cream, getting attention from neighbors.

We finally make it home, where my brothers are waiting for us.

"You are home past curfew." Jason tells us.

I sit on the couch with Toby and say, "Sue me." with a smile.

"Where were you guys?" He asks us. I secretly shake my head at Toby, meaning that he shall not tell them.

"We went to the movies." He says. I go upstairs and can't sleep.

By now, it is 11:59, and everybody is sleeping except me. I fell asleep for a little while but then I had a bad dream. I am in Toby's shirt and a pair of shorts. I walk across the hallway to Toby's room, and I shake him awake.

"Yeah, Spence?" He asks.

"I can't sleep." I tell him. He lifts up the covers and I crawl into his bed, snuggling up close to him.

"Why can't you sleep?" He asks, wrapping his arms around me.

"I guess the horror movie really got to me." I lie.

The truth is, it wasn't the horror movie that got to me, it was the horror I lived.

I was dreaming of Wren, and it scared the hell out of me. I dreamed that he was back, and running after me in the woods.

But that wasn't the worst part of it. The nightmare reminded me of the fact that I was keeping a secret from Toby and everybody else.

What I told Toby isn't the whole story; it is just a fraction of it.

A/N: Dun dun dun! What is Spencer hiding? Please review or PM me, it means a lot and more reviews= faster update!

P.S., last chapter, the idea came from IamALittleLiar. Thank you! Again, when he talked to Spencer, it was an idea from that person, and the note he gave her was from Imabwbt.

BTW, I found out Imabwbt is actually my best friend. I found out whoi it was right after I included the note lol.

Finally, if anybody has an idea for a one shot that you want me to write, PM me. I just don't do smut and I would prefer not to do a tragedy between spoby.