" What?" Said Dean and Sam together. They kept staring at Lucy.
" I'm your sister , surprise!" Said Lucy with a fake cheerful voice.
" How is that possible?" Said Dean surprisingly calm.
Sam could not talk. His brain had trouble processing the information. He did not expect such a revelation.
" Well… My mother told me really recently about that. It was a shock for me too you know. I don't know what to say." Said Lucy.
" I mean why are you laying? It won't change the fact that you go back home!" Said Dean still calm.
" I'm not a fucking liar Dean!" Said Lucy shouting and crying at the same time. " Why would I invent something like that?" She could not believe him. She had no reasons to lie.
Dean sighed. " I don't know Lucy, you tell me! Come in the car. We'll talk in our way back to Connecticut." He was already walking back to the car. Sam was walking behind him like a robot.
Lucy walked to Sam and stood in front of him. " Please Sammy say something!" She said crying.
" What do you want me to say Lu?" Said Sam in a whisper. " You had many occasions to tell us that! I don't know what to believe. Yesterday I told you I wished to have a sister like you. You should have told me then, don't you think?"
" I don't know what to say." Replied Lucy. " I wanted you to like me for me. I was stupid."
" Yes you were" said Sam shaking his head. " Get in the Car Lu."
They were driving for more than 3 hours but nobody was talking. Lucy knew that it was her last chance to repair her mistake. She should have talked straight away.
" My mother is not a liar!" She said pretty loud to cover the music. " If she says that John Winchester is my dad than he is!"
" That's not the point kiddo" Said Dean. Lucy regretted the « midget » call straight away. He was not expressing anything toward her anymore. It was hacking deep in her soul.
" Maybe you really believe that and well… you believe what you want to believe but do you think it's fair on us? I mean your mum can be a liar and for all I..."
" She is…" Started to shout Lucy but Dean cut her off by shouting a lot more. She never heard someone shout that loud and it scared her.
" Let me finish! Gosh! Just shut your mouth!". Dean turned off the radio and talked calmly again. " So, I was saying that maybe your mum is a liar because our dad would have talked to us about you. When he knew he was going to die he would have shared this information! And you are a liar too anyway". He looked at her through the mirror. "You told us that your dad was dead even when you believed that your dad was OUR dad!"
Lucy looked down. " What do you want to hear Dean? When I told you the first time that my dad was dead I really believed it! My mother told me only the night I met you that your were my brothers. I was really upset about that too you know. I could have met my dad and..."
" Don't call him like that!" Said Dean angry
Lucy sighed " Okay Dean. As you want! So… I could have met John Winchester but she took this chance from me!" She stopped for a couple of minutes and started again. " I'm sorry to go against what you're saying Dean but your dad couldn't reveal this secret to you because well… he didn't know about it!"
" That's practical!" said Dean with a sarcastic laugh.
" Gosh! I won't change your mind but just face it Dean! We are alike! You would be just like me if you were a girl! You know that! Just look at me and you'll see that it's true." She shot her last bullet.
" Yeah right!" Said Dean laughing " We couldn't be more different!"
Sam looked at Dean and turned around to look at Lucy. " I beg to differ Dean." Said Sam softly. " I can't be blind any longer. Dean look at her! She has an ability just like me and..."
Dean looked at Sam surprised.
" Well…" said Sam embarrassed " We'll talk about that later okay? And for the rest well she is just like you! Same eyes, same smile, same humour. She is you Dean! Totally you!"
Dean looked at Lucy again in the mirror. " We'll find out soon enough Sammy. I'm going to have a little chat with Kate!"