Lucas came into his bathroom where Casey was. "You're still getting ready?" He asked. She was still in her silk nighty that hugged around her curves.
"Yes." She answered and looked over at him. "Can I help you?"
"Yes. I need someone to wash the dishes as I cook." He answered and came in. He stood behind her and gently moved his hands to her waist and then her hips. "I like how this looks on you." He started to kiss bare shoulders.
Casey smirked. "You should. You picked it out." She grabbed her comb and brushed her hair. They have been dating for only three weeks but were inseparable "What are you making?"
"Chicken Alfredo with pasta." He answered and kept kissing her bare skin. He pulled her closer to his body not being able to get enough. "My god you smell good."
Casey laughed and gently pushed him off. "I'm scared you are going to tear me to pieces with how much you want me."
"I know." He nodded and extended his arm to her. "Where are you going? Don't go."
"I have to get dressed." She answered with a wink. "Go start making the food and I'll meet you there."
"Can't I come with?" He pleaded. "I won't touch. Just watch."
"No." She gave him a kiss. "I have a surprise for you. Go to the kitchen." She ordered and then went to his room to get dressed.
Lucas grinned and went to the kitchen. He started making dinner since Olivia and her date were coming over for a double date.
Casey came out a couple minutes later. She had on jeans and one of his hoodies that was way too big on her. She sat down on the stool by the counter top and watched him start the dinner.
He looked up and noticed his hoodie. "Where is my surprise?"
"Oh yeah." Casey nodded and lifted the hoodie up. She showed him her bra and then put the hoodie down. "I never flashed before so that was the surprise."
Lucas laughed a little and shook his head. "That wasn't even a flash. I didn't see a nipple."
"So? Look at your own damn nipple. Speaking of that I think it's kind of cold in here." She stated.
Lucas laughed hysterically and shook his head. "You are a sick person. Come here I'll heat you up."
"No. You come over here."
Lucas let his food cook and he went over to her. He sat down on the space she had in between her legs on the stool. "Babe give me a massage."
She placed her hands over his ribs and kissed his shoulder. "Why should I?"
"Because I said so." He teased and touched her hand on the side of his body. "I'll give you oral for as long as you want."
She gave him a mean look since he knew she couldn't refuse that. "Mean." She started to massage his shoulders. "You're stiff as a board."
"I thought you liked it that way." He teased with a smile. Casey pinched his neck. "Hey!"
She smirked and kept massaging him. "You'll live."
"Yeah, yeah." He nodded and rubbed her knees that were on the side of his body. "I like it when you wear jeans. You have a nice butt."
"Thank you. These are low waist also. I'm in the hoodie so I don't get my shirt wet when I'm washing the dishes. Apparently I'm your maid when you cook."
He closed his eyes enjoying her massage. "Not a maid. Helper. Luke's little helper."
"In prison they call that person their bitch." Casey stopped rubbing his back. "Go check the food."
He got up and stretched. "Thank you. Very nicely done." He gave her a kiss and went to check the food.
Casey got up and went over by him. She slapped his butt randomly. He instantly jumped and looked weirdly at her. "It was in my way." She smirked and went to wash the dishes that were in the sink.
Lucas chuckled and shook his head. "Man you are something."
"What? Crazy? Extremely sexy? Coolest person in the world?"
"All of the above but mostly Crazy." He teased with a smirk and grabbed a towel. He twisted it and snapped it at her butt. Casey jumped this time. "It was in my way." He mocked.
Casey grinned and went back to washing the dishes.
Half an hour later they heard a knock on the door. Casey pretended to be shocked. "I have to change. I look like a college boy."
Lucas laughed and went to answer the door as Casey went to change out of the hoodie. He opened the door and smiled at Olivia and her date. "Hey guys."
"Luke this is Marcus. Marcus this is Luke." Olivia introduced with a smirk. "Where is Casey?"
"I don't know. She went to find a new boyfriend or something." Lucas teased and moved out of the doorway. "Come in."
Casey came out of the bedroom this time in a nice shirt. "Hey."
"Hey" Olivia waved. "Casey this is Marcus. Marcus this Casey, she's the ADA."
Casey shook hands with him. "Nice to meet you."
"You too." Marcus nodded. He was about Olivia's height and had brown eyes with dirty blonde hair.
Lucas went to the kitchen to finish up the food and Olivia followed him. "Hey." She sat down by him.
"Hey." He smiled back. "Your date is hot," he teased.
Olivia smirked and looked over at Marcus. "Yeah he is pretty good looking."
"What's wrong? You don't seem all that excited."
"No I am. It's just work stuff." She answered with a shrug. "I'm glad to be here trust me. Get my mind off things for at least a night."
Lucas nodded. "If you need to talk"
"I know." She nodded. "Thanks." Lucas just nodded.
Casey came into the kitchen. "Liv he is cute." She stated with a whisper.
"I'm right here Casey." Lucas shook his head.
"Shut up." She told him and started to get the plates out. "Be happy Olivia has a hottie."
"I'm jumping for joy can't you see?" He smiled. "I feel gay saying another guy is hot though."
Olivia laughed and got up. "You guys need help?"
"Nope." Lucas answered with a smirk.
"Ok. I'm going to the living room so he doesn't think were talking about him." She waved at her best friends and went back to her date.
Lucas turned to look at his girlfriend. "Isn't he too short for her?"
"They are the same height." She whispered.
"I know. That's short for a guy. Guys should be taller. I'm taller then both of you."
"Well some girls like them smaller." Casey stated.
Lucas shrugged and turned to the food again. "Olivia doesn't," He mumbled.
Casey glanced over at him since she sensed half the time he was still in love with Olivia. She said nothing and gave him a deep kiss out of nowhere. She smiled and went to set the table.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Olivia sat on the couch with Marcus. They were dating for about a week and things were going good.
"So Casey is the lawyer and that's her boyfriend?" Marcus asked in a low voice. He placed his arm around her shoulders and let her lean on his chest.
"Yeah." Olivia answered. She didn't mention she used to date Lucas. Especially not that he proposed to her.
Marcus moved his hand on her knee. "Want to go see a movie after this?"
"I'd love to but I have work early in the morning." She answered with a small pout. "Sorry." She could see Lucas looking from the side. She sat up so she wasn't in Marcus's arms anymore. She didn't want to make him jealous and would hate for him to think that's what she was trying to do.
"Dinner is ready." Casey announced. Marcus and Olivia got off the couch and went to the dining room.
Casey went over to Lucas who was getting a wine bottle out of the fridge. "Need help?"
"No." He answered with a shake of the head. "Thanks."
"You ok? You don't seem as hyper as before." She questioned.
He nodded. "I'm fine. I'm just getting hungry that's all." He smiled a little. "Let's eat" He placed his hand on her lower back. "Love the low waist thing by the way." He whispered as he led her to the table. Casey grinned and sat in her seat. Lucas glanced at Olivia talking to Marcus before he sat down by Casey.
They ate the dinner and talked only for a couple times. Basically Olivia and Casey talked. Marcus was somewhat shy and Lucas just kept looking at Olivia.
They finished the dinner and Olivia helped Lucas clear the table. He was somewhat quiet. "You ok?" She questioned him.
Lucas nodded a little. "Yeah. How you and Marcus doing so far?"
"Oh it's great. He is a real nice guy." Olivia grinned and got the plates all together. "You and Casey seem very cute together. I set you guys up so I'm first that's invited to the wedding."
Lucas laughed a little. "Yea right." He shook his head.
Olivia looked weirdly at him and moved closer. "What? You don't see Casey as marriage material?" She whispered.
Lucas stopped cleaning the table. "No. She would make a good wife. I'm just not going to get married. Ever." He whispered. "It's not about her."
Olivia nodded a little. "When did you decide on not getting married?"
He shrugged and grabbed all plates. "Some time ago." He walked away to the kitchen.
Olivia took a deep breath and followed him. "Luke if this is about-"
"It's not" He cut her off knowing she was meaning her. "Why does it matter? I don't want to get married. There are plenty guys out there that don't want to either."
"Because I don't care about those guys. I know you Lucas. You like being committed to one person. You like being loyal and honest. You do want to get married."
He shook his head and glanced at Marcus and Casey watching TV quietly. He turned to Olivia. "You of all people shouldn't care if I get married in the future or not." He whispered quietly. "You made up your mind."
Olivia took a deep breath and shook her head. "That doesn't mean I don't care anymore." She walked away from him and got her jacket. "Marcus you ready to go?"
He nodded and got off the couch. "Thanks for dinner."
"No problem" Casey got up also. "Thanks for coming."
Lucas crossed his arms on his chest and kept quiet. Casey closed the door behind them and turned to look at Lucas. "I'll wash the dishes." He spoke up.
She went over to him. "What happened?"
"Nothing." He answered and turned the water on.
Casey gently turned the faucet off. "Leave them for tomorrow." She whispered.
He nodded a little. "Ok. You sleeping here tonight?"
"If you want me to." She whispered and took him in a hug. "Do you want to talk about it?"
"No." He answered against her shoulder. "I'm sorry I ruined the night."
"You didn't ruin anything." She whispered and rubbed his back. "The dinner was good. Do you want me to give you a massage?"
"No." He answered and gave her a kiss. "I owe you an IOU don't I?"
She smiled a little. "Yeah you do but it doesn't have to be tonight if you're not in the mood."
He took her hand and pulled her down the hall to his room. "C'mon. I'm in the mood."
Casey smiled and gladly followed him. They went in and she closed the door behind them.
Lucas threw her down on the bed and took his shirt off. He kneeled down on the ground to be in between her legs.
Casey instantly got aroused not being able to wait for what was coming next. She felt his hands start to rub her legs and move up her thighs.
Lucas moved up and pulled her shirt up a little and placed small kisses on her abs. He undid her button and zipper and gently pulled them down. For some reason giving oral made him calmer because it reminded him when he was a virgin. Before he became intimate with Olivia.
Casey bit her lip not to moan as she felt his fingers roam over her panties in the middle. He softly rubbed her over the fabric and then with ease slipped his fingers in from her moistness.
Lucas gently pushed in and out and watched her reactions with pleasure. She went from moans to gripping the bed sheet with a smile on her face.
He smirked and pulled his fingers out. He gently pulled her panties off and tossed them to the side. He pulled her body more onto the bed. He kneeled on the bed and started to gently explore her body with his hands.
He pushed her shirt up and massaged her breast. Casey sat up a little and took her shirt off completely. She started undoing his belt noticing his lengthy bulge on the jeans. She kissed his abs and then his chest.
"I thought I was supposed to pleasure you tonight." He whispered with a smirk.
"I couldn't resist." She answered smiling and pushed his jeans down to his knees. She softly rubbed his bulge to tease him. She laid back down. "Your turn."
He grinned and took her bra off. He slowly began to kiss her from the neck all the way down. He stopped at her breasts and gently took one in his mouth. He teased her with his tongue and then continued going down her.
He got to her middle and took his jeans off and his boxers before he began pleasuring her with his mouth.
Casey panted a little feeling his tongue doing all the right things. "Oh god Lucas." She slowly started wrapping her legs around his shoulders as she began squirming.
He laughed a little and purposefully untangled her legs and pushed them open.
Casey laughed and sat up. She grabbed the back of his neck and pulled him up to face her. "You're an amazing man."
"You are an amazing woman." He whispered back.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Lucas lay on his couch and watched TV. Casey was cuddling next to him with her head resting on his chest. There was a knock on the door.
"Want to get that?" Luke questioned.
"No." She answered. "You're apartment."
Luke groaned and tossed the blanket off of them. He got off the couch and went to his door. He opened it and Olivia was standing there. Her eyes had tears in them and she sniffled a little.
"Olivia." He whispered and gently took her in a hug. "Are you ok?"
She shook her head in his chest. "I just need a friend right now." She whispered.
Casey looked over at the door and spotted her best friend hugging her boyfriend. She got up slowly. "Liv you ok?" She gently touched her shoulder.
Olivia looked up seeing Casey was there. She hated being an intrusion. "Sorry. I'm gonna go."
"Liv" Luke shook his head. "C'mon you're obviously not alright. Don't leave."
Casey rubbed Olivia's shoulder. "Actually I'm going to go. I haven't been home in a while. Have to feed the dog."
"Casey you don't have a dog." Olivia smirked a little and wiped her eyes.
Casey nodded and grabbed her jacket. "Exactly. I have to go to the pet store." She gave Olivia a hug and kissed Lucas. "Bye guys." She left the apartment seeing Olivia needed Lucas to talk to about whatever was bothering her.
Olivia shook her head. "I'm sorry about this."
"Don't be." He placed his hand on her lower back and led her to the couch. "I told you when you needed to talk about something you had me to count on." Both sat down on the couch. He turned the TV off. "What's wrong?"
She pulled the blanket over her lap. "I don't know. Everything sucks."
"Meaning? Work?"
She nodded a little. We had a victim get killed after she reported the rape."
He looked confused knowing it wasn't like Olivia to just walk away. "Then…why-"
"Why am I not at work trying to catch the bastard?" She vocalized what was on his mind. He nodded. "I got a little physical with a suspect in the interrogation room."
"You hit him?"
"Yeah. Kicked. Punched. Slammed against the wall. You name it." She shook her head. "Cragen sent me home."
He gently took her in a hug. "It's ok. Everyone gets out of control."
She rested her head on his chest. "I broke up with Marcus also."
"What? I thought you guys were doing good."
"Well I didn't break up with him…he broke up with me."
"Why?"
"He said we never saw each other. It wasn't going to work out." She wiped her eyes. "I guess I'm just overwhelmed by everything. I don't know why."
"Everyone has a limit." He whispered gently. He pulled her closer against him. Something about her being so sad wanted him to save her. Before he could stop himself he placed his lips against hers.
To his surprise Olivia deepened it and placed her hand on the back of his neck. They kissed for a couple seconds before Olivia broke it. "No." She whispered and shook her head. "I can't."
He looked at her teary chocolate eyes. "It's ok."
"No." She pulled away from his embrace. "I'm not a cheater. I'm not doing this again."
He nodded a little knowing she meant when she cheated on him with Robert. "Olivia you did nothing wrong."
She got off the couch. "That's the worst part. I want this to happen and yet I want to kill myself for wanting it to happen."
He got up also and went over to her. "This could happen. It's not too late."
She shook her head. "No. It can't happen. You're with my best friend. I will not be the woman that screws her friend over for a man."
He shook his head a little. "I'm not asking you to be that woman Olivia. I don't want you to be that woman." He took her hands in his. "I want to give us a try again. That's all. You said it yourself you liked me being your boyfriend."
Olivia nodded. "I did. I just don't want you to hurt Casey."
He nodded. "I know. I don't want to either but Olivia I'm in love with you. That's not fair to her either."
Olivia pulled away from him. "I…I don't want to talk about this. I don't want to know you are going to break up with my best friend for me. I just don't want that on my mind."
He nodded again. "You're right. I'm sorry."
Olivia shook her head. "I'm going to go. Thank you for talking to me though." She left the apartment before he could say anything.
Lucas just put his head down and sat in his couch. He looked at a picture with him, Olivia and Casey. He didn't know which to choose.
A/N: Casey or Olivia?