Dear Gray-sama,
Juvia doesn't want to tell you this, but she must. Your memory is awful.
Juvia remembers the umbrella you made me. It was broken later that day. Juvia supposes you don't remember that too.
But there is something Juvia forgot: that she used the alias Lucy. When you met Lucy, did you remember her name? Or did that slip down the black hole known as your memory too? Maybe that's why Juvia feels her main love rival is Lucy, but Juvia won't bring that up.
Juvia didn't know Lyon-sama was in the crowd that day. How ironic. Have you told him? Juvia would've liked to see his reaction. But everybody hated me back then when I was little. Even those who care for me today.
Don't try to contradict, you know it's true. How could you make it rain wherever you went and still be loved?
Though, for that one day in Magnolia, you did.