Potential Good Company

Dean wasn't interested in more than a one night stand with Rory, much to her devastation. Deciding not to let it destroy her, she goes back to Yale and lets loose a little by spending a night with a random guy, Colin. Things get complicated, though, when she meets his friend Logan and they fall into an awkward threesome.

PS: Takes place in season five.

PS2: Plenty of sexual situations.

PS3: Bad language (I think Paris would have a dirty mouth for one).

PS4: I came to the conclusion I don't care for Dean, so some bashing ahead.

PS5: This does eventually feature a threesome. Don't like it, don't agree with it, don't read it.

Notes:

"Words" – regular conversation

'Words' – quotes and such, thoughts too

Chapter 0010: Down and Dazed

It had been a couple of days since Rory last saw Colin, and she was anxious.

Classes were as hard as she'd expected them, and Paris was still going on and on about her little escapade, but all Rory cared about was Colin. Thinking about his touches, the way his body felt against hers, his voice when he dryly talked about his life, and the way he'd look at her and make her weak to her knees. She wanted to go to his dorm and have her way with him and go out for dinner and hang out like she was doing with Marty, except–

She liked Marty, really, she did, but he was her friend. Colin was not her friend, he was a guy who gave her so many orgasms, who taught her a little about what she liked and didn't like, who made her feel alive like she hadn't really felt since Jess left. She wondered if the sex with Jess would've been so electrifying.

Paris had been shocked to learn Colin was Jamie's cousin, and though she acted aloof, Rory could tell she felt guilty about the way she ended things with him, so both girl spent their Monday morning side by side on the couch watching TV and commenting on the cousins' sexual prowess (Paris was pleasantly surprised by how Rory opened up to her, and in turn she talked about how sweet but intense Jamie had always been). Eventually, Paris confessed she had had an adventure with Prof. Fleming, but Jamie was– Jamie was her first love, and she still cared about him a great deal.

After Marty left for the night, clearly sensing Rory's detachment, she grabbed her phone and after staring at it for a few moments, she started writing to Colin to ask about Jamie, a safe enough topic.

'Is Jamie still at Princeton?' – some minutes later, he replied, and she pictured his smirk as she read it to herself.

'Sure is. How did Paris Geller react when you told her about Jamie & I?'

'Pretty sure her jaw hit the floor'

'Should I mention it to J?'

'Not yet. But maybe see if he's still interested?'

'He was over the Summer when we last talked, but I can ask'

'Thank you =D'

'Miss Gilmore, you use emoticons?'

'Not often, Mr. McCrae'

'Don't start with me' – she frowned at the screen.

'Start what?'

'You call me Mr. McCrae, I'm gonna wanna come over and let you say it again while wearing your schoolgirl uniform. You still got it?' – Rory flamed and bit her lip.

'I still have it. It's here in my dorm'

'Don't tempt me' – she hesitated but pushed forward.

'Or what?' – he had to be smirking, she was absolutely sure.

'I'll bend you over your desk, you'd like that?' – she gasped to herself.

'Yes'

'You want me to eat you out, Miss Gilmore?'

'Yes' – God, she did. He was so amazing at it.

'Tell me what else you want me to do' – he ordered, and she had to catch her breath before she wrote him back.

They kept writing back and forth for the rest of the night, and Rory felt frustrated when it was time to sleep, she had an early class and couldn't be late. She pulled her hand off her pants with a mournful sigh.

'I have to go now. Early class'

'Seriously?'

'Sorry'

'Tease and tease, Miss Gilmore. I'm gonna have to punish you next time I see you'

':)'

'Night'

'Bye'

She leaned back into her pillows and imagined Colin in his bed, jerking off to their conversation. She wondered if he was as hot and bothered and horny as she felt. God, she had to make sure she had her Chilton uniform at hand, she was pretty sure Colin wasn't kidding about his schoolgirl kink.

The next day, Rory's classes finished early, and she had plenty of time to lock herself in her room and text Colin. He took a while to reply, stating he'd been on his last class, but now he had all the time in the world for her.

After an hour trading increasingly explicit texts, and boy, Rory didn't think anyone would believe the things she'd written, she finally swallowed dry and took a leap.

'Come over' – she wrote, and a breath later, she got a quick text from Colin.

'Where r u?' – she giggled, thinking he was as eager as she was, and quickly let him know and waited for his arrival.

"Hey, Paris?" – she hesitantly called out to her roommate in the living room, reading a book.

"What?"

"So, hum, Colin is coming over" – the blonde snapped her head at her.

"What?"

"Colin? Jamie's cousin?" – Paris rolled her eyes.

"Yes, I know which Colin you mean. But what would you like me to do about it? Need condoms? Lube?" – Rory flushed at the smirk that spread across Paris's sly face.

"No, I just wanted to let you know so you're not surprised"

"I won't be, but please try to keep it down. Is he staying the night?"

"I'm– I'm not sure"

"Just don't let him have any of my stuff from the fridge, and make him put something on during breaks if he decides to come out of your room"

"Oh God"

"Yeah, I'm sure I'll be hearing much more of that, you seem like a screamer" – as Rory babbled, mortified by Paris's comment, someone knocked, and the blonde jumped at the chance to answer – "Hello, Colin"

"Paris Geller" – Colin greeted, making his way in. When he saw Rory, he looked her up and down slowly and smirked.

"I already told Gilmore, but do try to keep it down, okay?"

"Just like you and Jamie?" – he shot back, and Rory was shocked by the way Paris pinked.

"Shut up, frat boy"

"I heard you can be pretty vocal with the right incentive" – he winked shamelessly, and laughed all the way to Rory's room at Paris's irritated but embarrassed mumbling – "Well, Miss Gilmore, you seem to be missing an uniform" – he said quietly before pulling her to him and kissing her.

Considering they spent most of their time naked, Colin barely seemed to miss the uniform, though he did tease Rory and said he'd love to see her in it – then he described everything he was planning on doing while she was in it. He spoke the way he wrote, or he wrote he was he talked, and it got her all tingly for him. She promised she'd wear the Chilton uniform if he'd wear one of his many school uniforms, and he looked shocked for a single moment before laughing.

"Only if you call me Mr. McCrae when I make you cum" – he whispered in her ear.

"And you can only call me Miss Gilmore"

"Deal" – he slyly slipped a hand in between her legs, making her gasp – "Wanna have dinner or go again?"

Her mother wouldn't believe it if she told her she refused food, but considering the mind boggling sex she was having, she imagined Lorelai Gilmore would just giggle like a little girl and demand every filthy detail.

Colin did end up staying over that night, and the couple and Paris even shared a late dinner of takeout in which Paris made dirtier and dirtier comments on their sex life, and Colin ruthlessly returned fire with fire by telling her how everyone in his family knew how she liked it with Jamie. Rory tried not to giggle, she did, but she never got to see Paris so embarrassed (and she didn't think sex was the thing to break Paris's stonewall, especially given how the Bicentennial at Chilton had gone down), so she decided to quietly savor it, just like the way Colin let his hand rest on her leg most of the time when he wasn't eating.

They didn't have much sex after dinner, just the one time, and the rest of the time they stayed lying in bed, talking.

Rory wondered as they again slept together if it was possible to fall in love with someone so quickly.