SPOILERS: Season 8
I don't own Supernatural or any of its characters, unfortunately
This is just a little semi-AU I put together about Sam and Amelia. More chapters to come. I hope you like it!
"I've heard a lot about you boys," the demon inside Amelia said with a sadistic smile.
Sam's blood ran cold. His heart stopped. He couldn't see. He backed away from "Amelia" as the demon smirked mockingly.
"What?" she asked, "no kiss for the Mrs?"
It was Dean who acted first, recovering from his shock when the demon spoke. He grabbed his gun from his pocket and a flask of holy water from under the table.
"Get out of her, you son of a bitch," he growled.
"Why? This really is the perfect arrangement," the demon toyed
"You let her go now!" Sam shouted as rage filled him. He wouldn't lose his girlfriend and child to a demon. He couldn't. He pointed Ruby's knife at the demon. "Or else"
"This is too good!" The demon laughed. "Don't you get it? You can't hurt me. Not unless you want to hurt sweet little Amelia and her darling baby"
"Exorcizamus te, omnis immundus spiritus," Sam began to recite. He knew he wouldn't exorcise the demon if she wasn't restrained, but he had to try. He couldn't hurt Amelia.
"Ah, ah ah," the demon laughed, coughing slightly. "I can still destroy Amelia and baby Amelia from the inside out."
"What do you want?" Dean asked coldly
"What does any girl want?" The demon mused, her eyes flashing black again. "Sam and Dean Winchester's heads."
"Yeah, we're not so keen on that," Sam replied with fake bravado. "You let her go or we will make you think hell is a paradise." However, Sam was panicking. He couldn't hurt the demon without hurting Amelia and the baby. He couldn't exorcise the demon without her destroying her host and his child. There was no way out and Sam knew it.
Ultimately, it was Dean who made the decision. Dean knew Amelia's best chance in the long run was for him to capture and exorcise the demon. Dean also knew Sam couldn't do it. As the demon continued to taunt Sam, Dean lunged forward and sprayed her with holy water.
"Dean!" Sam yelled. "What the hell are you doing?"
"It's our only choice, Sammy." He shouted back as he wrestled the demon inside Amelia. "We have to get the demon out. The knife, now! Get her and knock her out!"
Sam was horrified but deep down he knew he had to do it. As tears ran down his cheeks, Sam slashed Amelia's arm with Ruby's knife, causing her to scream in agony. Hating himself more than ever, Sam hit Amelia with the butt of his gun, somehow knocking out the demon inside of her, if only for a moment.
"Get her to the panic room, now!" He yelled at Dean. Together the brothers dragged Amelia's limp, bleeding body down into the Men of Letter's dungeon. Sam wept silently. Chaining Amelia in place, Sam began the exorcism just as the demon began to wake up.
"No!" She screamed. "No! I will destroy her from the inside out. Your baby will die, she will die!"
Despite the threats, Sam continued the exorcism, watching Amelia's body contort as the demon struggled to remain inside of her. With horror, Sam watched as Amelia's bones began to break and her eyes began to bleed. Moments later, Sam saw the most horrific sight he'd ever seen: blood soaked through Amelia's pants.
"NO!" He screamed as he ran to her. Dean, seeing his brother's pain, continued the exorcism as Sam cradled Amelia's hand. Finally, Dean finished the exorcism and the demon rushed from Amelia's mouth. As soon as it was out, Amelia's body slumped to the side. She moaned.
"Dean," Sam sobbed, "help her. We have to help them!" Sam unchained Amelia and laid her gently on the floor as she continued to moan in agony.
"Baby," Amelia whimpered. "Now." Her body convulsed and Sam realized that even as she was dying, Amelia forced her body to push their baby out.
"I'm here, Amelia," Sam whispered as he held her. "You're almost there. You're okay, love. The baby's almost here. It's all okay. Everything is okay."
"I love you, Sam" Amelia whispered hoarsely
Dean felt helpless watching Sam. He was trying to stop the bleeding coming from her limbs, but Dean knew nothing could be done for the baby. Amelia continued to clutch at Sam as she pushed, using the last of her strength.
"A head," Sam told her, his voice breaking. "I can see her head." Fortified only for a moment by Sam's words, Amelia gave one final push and their baby entered the world. For a single moment, Sam was happy. But then he saw it: his daughter was blue and unmoving.
"No!" He cried, cradling his tiny daughter to his chest. "No, no, no, no, no, no." Turning to Amelia, Sam realized she was unconscious. "God no. Please don't. Please, please don't be-" Sam pleaded with her, unable to finish his sentence. "You can't be. I love you. I love you both."
Dean watched helplessly as his brother cried. Sam held his daughter tightly to his chest in one arm while his other clutched Amelia too him. He rocked back and forth as he cried for his family. Dean put his hand of Sam's shoulder, desperate to relieve his burden just a little.
"Sam, I-" Dean murmured, his voice cracking with emotion. "Castiel, if you are out there, you get your angel ass over here and make this better. Do you hear me, Cas? You fix this."
Sam and Dean waited for a moment but nothing happened. Cas didn't come. Sam buried his face in Amelia's hair as he raged against the world.
"Fix them! Dammit Cas, fix them. We have always been there. Don't let them die! Fix them. Please fix them. I can't do this without them. Castiel, please. Please. You owe us this" Sam called over and over again. Finally, Sam placed his daughter in Amelia's cold arms and looked up at Dean, feeling more broken than he thought was possible. "It's all my fault."