(Disclaimer in First Chapter.)

*Does no one sign reviews anymore?

X. Why Didn't They Ask Evans?

Weeks passed. In that time the four settled in to something of a comfortable existence of their little island.

The gang continued to invent things and adapted technology to make their lives easier. Sam was able to create a rough shower by diverting some of the river water to create a waterfall near their camp. It worked really well, but it was never very warm so really only one person could use it comfortably a day. But lucky for them, Quinn would often invite somebody else into "help" her get clean.

They had become used to their island diets for the most part; mostly the fruit they had been eating, but also fish which Sam had developed ways to catch. They would sporadically open a percentage of the canned goods for special meals too.

Despite how lucky they had been, Sam sat alone one day and began to wonder about the other side to their story. While he absolutely reveled in his time on the island with three stunning women, it still worried him that it had been over a month since the storm had brought them here and yet there had been no signs of rescue planes, helicopters, or boats. When they initially arrived, Sam had thought about the worst-case scenarios, but he believed he was overreacting.

In the beginning, he thought about how Quinn's family was very wealthy, and most of them were on the ship for her wedding; they would certainly notice that she had disappeared and would have spared no expense looking for her. Sam's hope was starting to die because that clearly hadn't happened yet. He was always looking to the horizon for boats, listening for planes, and keeping a fire lit on the beach. But still nothing had happened.

About a week into the ordeal, Sam got worried that something had happened to the cruise ship too. All things considered, it was likely given the strength of the storm that the cruise had been putting in danger; maybe no one was looking for them because authorities were distracted by a disaster that befell their boat. If that were true, it would take weeks to get everything dealt with before they realized that four individuals were missing.

The other slightly optimistic possibility was that given the effect the storm would have on ocean currents, the search area would be so large they just hadn't found them yet. Combined with the fact that the boat was moving when they all left, and you'd have to know exactly when they left to know where to start looking, then really they could be anywhere in the Caribbean right now. Sam began to fear that rescue might not be coming, and he wondered if he should start building a raft to leave and find that rescue himself.

Sam stared out to sea wondering just how much longer the four of them could stay on the island. They were all starting to notice the passage of time, especially in each other's appearances. Everybody's hair had gotten longer and more frazzled from the constant exposure to sun and salty air. Dani, being without any sort of hair dye, was starting to show her natural light brown color in her roots. They all had gotten substantially tanned and/or burnt by the sun. There was one razor in the supplies they recovered, which the three girls shared and forbade him from using. He had vowed to learn how to use a pocketknife as a straight razor after Rachel complained about the scratchiness of his oral sex. That of course was the thing that showed time had passed the most: just how comfortable they were getting with each other, and in particular, each other's bodies. Sam felt guilty because a part of him did not want to return home, specifically the part getting showered nightly with attention from two hot women and potentially a third. He suspected it was this part of him that kept him from building a raft and searching for help.

Sam 's mind was wandering so much that he didn't notice somebody behind him until a delicate hand touched his shoulder and he looked up to see Rachel.

"Ready for dinner?" she asked before she saw the look on Sam's face. "Sam what's wrong?" she asked with concern. Sam considered denying it, but Rachel was too smart for that, "And don't say its nothing, something is genuinely wrong. I can tell." She sat down and took his hand in hers.

Sam looked at her and saw the worry in her eyes. He started covering all of the thoughts and concerns he had just been thinking about before she walked up.

After he had finished she said, "Wow."

"I would have said voiced these concerns sooner, but I didn't want you three to stress over it."

Rachel looked a bit resentful about that last statement, "What? Do you think we're just innocent girls that can't deal with the reality of the situation? Is that it?"

"No, No. That's not what I meant." Sam said in his defense, "It's simply that the vast majority of survival is mental, you're better off keeping your composure above all else. The more you yell yourself you're going to be okay, then the better you can handle the mental strain. It's not a criticism on any of you three, you are all pretty tough and I have no doubt you can handle it. Everyone seemed happy I didn't want to rain on everybody's parade with my pessimism."

"You're such a guy," she said shaking her head. "Dani and I have been talking about this stuff all along, you know." Sam looked at her amazed and she said, "I mean it's hard not to think about it. So don't think you are bearing all of the burden for us. That being said, we've decided that telling Quinn is most likely not the best idea."

"But, but … you just said…" Sam stammered out.

"I know what I said, and I was making sure you weren't losing sight of the type of women on this island with you."

"So then why not tell Quinn?"

"From what Dani has told me about her, its best to just keep her happy and distracted because an angry Quinn is something we would never want to see. She might not take the truth that well." Rachel paused and then continued, "Look, I love Quinn. She's pretty much my new best friend. But she would snap. Dani and I … we're realists, we've dealt with plenty of hardships in our lives already, so we blame ourselves if anyone. Quinn, she's been pampered all her life. She does not deal with adversity in the same way. She looks from someone else to blame. Between the three of us, we've turned this into an island vacation for her. I hope that as long as she's getting laid frequently she'll be pretty laid back and easygoing. I think she only gets irritable and pessimistic when she gets horny."

"Rachel… we haven't really ever spoken privately yet about … you know…"

"Oh, you mean about how you've been fucking Quinn and I've been fucking her AND Dani?"

"Yeah … that."

"Well what do you want to know?"

"Well I guess we should start at the beginning. Before the night of the bet, you had already expressed an interest in sleeping with the two of them without me knowing, right?"

"Sort of… we haven't told you everything about what happened on my uncle's boat after we cut you loose. Eli, Will, and the third man pointed their guns at Dani and Quinn and ordered them to have sex in front of everybody. But that wasn't all; they even forced me to join in. But then the boat crashed. They beat me up and tied me up with Dani and Quinn. I apologized to them and told them I wasn't a part of it willingly, and thankfully they understood. That's when we all started comforting each other. I think it had something to do with the need to replace the traumatizing sexual experiences with positive ones. I wouldn't have gotten through it if it hadn't been for them. When you rescued us, I wanted to try it again without all the horror surrounding it. I was just going to ask you outright if you'd let me sex with them, but then Dani came up with the whole fake bet trick. Since I thought it was unnecessarily cruel to you, I told Quinn to see to you after we were done."

"Rachel I had no idea." Sam replied, and then asked, "But since that first night it's happened a lot more; and you're still okay with it? You don't mind how I've kept sleeping with Quinn?"

"Certainly not. I'm not the only girl here who enjoys sex with men, so I can't hoard the only man available."

"That's really not how things normally work, Rachel."

"Sam, nothing about our lives now is normal." Rachel countered. "That's not my only reason though."

"What else?"

"It ends up benefitting me in the long run because I think Quinn's made you a better lover."

"Really?"

"Mmmmmm, definitely. Also, I think Quinn's has her own reasons for keeping this whole thing going that involve a certain girl with fluorescent red hair."

"So you know about that?" Sam asked surprised.

Rachel laughed and replied, "I don't just know about, darling, I am helping her come up with strategies."

This floored Sam. "So to recap: not only are you okay with me regularly fucking Quinn, but you are also a part of the conspiracy to help me fuck Dani? This has got to be a trap. It's a trap right?" Sam asked while trying to recover from the shock.

"No trap, I promise. I love watching you and Quinn fuck, and I love the way you make her cum so hard every single time. As for Dani, I've seen the looks she gives you when she thinks no one is looking. I've felt her fuck me harder when you are watching, like she's trying to impress you or something. Trust me, we think she's definitely curious, but in denial about it. I can't wait to be there when you blow her mind."

"Seriously?" Sam said, now down right astounded.

"Think about it like this: as you said, we don't know how long we will be on this island. We could be here for the next 50 years. Who's gonna defend us and find us food when you're a seventy year old man? We might need to start having babies and three healthy wombs are better than just two. Plus, who knows what could happen tomorrow? There could be storms, or pirates, or monsters. We need to be living our lives to the fullest every day. You know that, and Dani knows that. If this is gonna happen it needs to happen soon. In fact, I think the next step of the plan is going down tonight."

"What are you hinting at?" Sam asked intrigued.

"You'll find out soon enough, right now we're late for dinner." She walked away and he just stood their puzzled. "You coming darling?"

Sam just nodded and headed off to dinner. After the short meal, the four retired to the shelter. Once they were on the group bed and had begun their usual fooling around Quinn slowed things down and tapped Sam on the shoulder. "Sam, I want to try something with you and Dani," she said. Then after a beat she added, "I want to fuck both you at the same time. So, will you fuck my ass while Dani fucks my pussy?"

Sam couldn't believe what he was hearing. Rachel had warned him that something new might be happening, but he not expected this. Rachel, who was sucking his cock at that moment, gave him a wink. Then taking her mouth off his cock and she said, "Yes, Quinn he'd be glad to, wouldn't you Sam?" Sam still dazed, nodded.

"Great!" Quinn said with obvious excitement, "I was hoping you'd say yes. Dani and I will get started, Rachel could you make sure he's ready to go?" Rachel agreed and resumed sucking Sam's cock. Quinn positioned Dani on the bed on her back before straddling the plastic cock and lowering herself on to it. "I love you so much for letting me do this, Dani."

Shortly afterwards, Rachel shifted positions and lowered herself onto Sam's hard shaft. She began to bounce herself up and down at a quick pace. As a result, it did not take long before both she and Sam were very close to orgasming. Knowing he'd last longer with Quinn if he'd already cum once, he didn't hold back at all and let himself quickly cum in Rachel; she did not slow down and kept bouncing on his spurting shaft. Soon after she too cried out in release.

Rachel promptly dismounted and grabbed Sam's cock with both hands to work it back up. She leaned in, kissed him, and whispered against his lips, "I hope you saved plenty for Quinn." Sam sat back enjoying Rachel's hands on his cock as he watched Quinn and Dani slowly fucking each other. Quinn was taking full advantaged of being on top, moving her hips with great speed. Dani was using her fingers to gently probe Quinn's asshole to make sure she could take Sam when the time came. Between Rachel's hand job and the incredibly sexy sight of the two fucking, it took little time for Sam to be at full mast again.

Now that Sam was hard again, Rachel gave way for him to take position behind Quinn. Dani got Quinn's attention, and then Quinn bent down against Dani's chest with the strap-on deep within her still. With her head buried in Dani's shoulder, she had her ass ready and waiting for Sam.

Despite never having done this before, Sam remained calm. He placed the tip of his cock against her asshole and before he pushed in he asked, "You sure about this Quinn?" He saw her nod enthusiastically against Dani's shoulder. So he added, "Okay, just let me know if you want me to ever stop okay?" She nodded again and he began pushing forward.

Quinn started to furiously kiss Dani as she felt Sam slowly enter her ass. Hearing only kiss-muffled shrieks he paused for a moment, but continued again when he realize she wasn't in any pain. He repeated this process of pause then push until his whole shaft was buried in her ass.

Rachel crawled up to the three of them and rubbed Quinn's shoulders while whispering, "That's it Quinn. You're okay. You've got both of them all the way in." Thanks to Rachel's reassurances, Quinn started to lift off of Dani's strap-on. As she slowly lowered herself back down, Sam began pulling out of her just as slowly. Once she was all the way down, he reversed and pushed in again. The series of events repeated, but this time Dani started to move her hips to give Quinn less to do.

It was a nervous moment, and no one dared say anything. After a few more rounds of in and out from both Dani and Sam, soon Quinn stopped moving completely, giving total control to the other two. Stepping up, Dani and Sam worked together to find a rhythm of trading thrusts of their two cocks into Quinn's holes.

It only took a few minutes of this double fucking for Quinn to start to feel the intense pleasure of their actions. "Ohhhhhh God, OHHHHH O—" her breath caught in her throat and her words deserted her. All she could manage was a prolonged squeak. She was experiencing multiple orgasms. The sight of Quinn paralyzed by pleasure between them began to reap rewards for her two lovers as well. Sam was fighting the urge to cum in her ass until the last possible moment, and Dani's clit was on fire as the attachment rubbed against her thanks to Quinn.

In that moment, Sam's gaze met Dani's, and a thrust for him was met by one from her. Sam realized that thanks to this, Quinn's elaborate conspiracy was likely well on its way. Only Quinn now separated Sam and Dani from truly fucking each other. As Sam gazed into Dani's eyes, he saw them so full of passion and lust, and he wondered if somehow, somewhere it was for him as well as Quinn.

Sam felt a profound, new bond with Dani and this was enough to push him over the edge. He lost the ability to fight his orgasm. His vision blurred and his cock erupted into Quinn's tight ass. Throughout his orgasm, he only saw Dani's lust filled eyes as if they were branded on the inside of his head. Not long after, Dani cried out and she too came.

Sam pulled his limp cock out of Quinn's ass and fell back against the bed. Rachel came up to his right side and held him tight, "That was so hot, I came on my fingers watching it happen."

Quinn rolled over to lie on her back between Sam and Dani. She struggled to lift her body up to give a kiss to each of them, first Dani and then Sam. When she had pulled away, Sam felt her leave behind teardrops on his cheek. She had been crying.

"What's wrong Quinn? Are you hurt?" Sam asked quickly.

Quinn shook her head, wiped her tears, and said with a smile, "No, nothing's wrong. I feel great. So unbelievably great. Sure it hurt a little, I knew it would. But you were so gentle and understanding. Both of you. Pleasure for sure outweighed the pain. Thank you so much." After another quick kiss to both, Quinn took a much-needed rest alongside a suspiciously quiet Dani. Dani cuddled with her wife, but she was not able to get to sleep until much later.

The next day, Rachel relayed a secret message to Sam from Quinn that she felt the night had been such a success in her mind that she wanted a repeat performance. Quinn knew that a bond had formed between Dani and Sam and she wanted to strengthen it before time took it away.

Back in bed that night, Quinn announced her desires to the assembled group. Dani agreed and Sam, acting like this was the first he had heard of it, agreed as well. To make this time different and special, tonight the places would be swapped: Dani would get her ass and Sam her pussy.

So events developed the way they had they night before only with the roles reversed. This meant that Quinn started off fucking Sam while he got her ready. And even though her cock wasn't real and wouldn't require the same preparations as Sam had gotten, Dani still was cared for by Rachel. Quinn started Sam off with a blowjob, which Sam accepted and then returned to Quinn by eating her out. After both had cum this way, Quinn got on top of him to begin her ride. Soon after Quinn began working up and down on Sam's shaft, Rachel had an orgasm and they both knew that it meant Dani would be joining them soon.

With Quinn laid out on top of him, Sam looked over her body to see Dani push her fake cock into her wife's rear end. Confident that Quinn could take it all after last night's activities, Dani bottomed out much quicker in Quinn's ass. Quinn once again got things started herself, and then allowed the other two to find a good rhythm. It took much less time for Quinn to go over the edge this time. She was much more confident and as a result she started cumming more quickly. Sam pinched Quinn's nipples to help her along the rest of the way. Rachel joined in this time too, and she sucked on Dani's tits.

After twenty minutes, and several of Quinn's orgasms had came and went, Sam could no longer hold off his orgasm. He felt himself cum into Quinn's gushing pussy. Dani also came with Rachel still attached to her breasts. Dani removed the strap-on from Quinn's ass, and Sam held Quinn to his chest while Quinn tried to stop shaking from all the orgasms she had been given. When she had finally recovered, she lifted herself off his cock and kissed him in thanks.

She whispered in his ear while Dani was busy un-strapping herself. "You and Dani make a good team. Do you think she looks hot when she fucks me hard?"

"Of course she's hot. But she's not getting anywhere near me with that strap-on." He said seriously.

Quinn giggled and whispered back, "I'm sue she'd enjoy that, but no, you'll fuck her eventually, I promise. You're under her skin now; I can tell."

Sam wanted to discuss this further, but soon Dani had returned and pulled Quinn away. Sam wasn't alone for long, as Rachel quickly took his cock into her mouth. Sam teased, "Well it seems someone is jealous of all the attention Quinn was getting." Rachel couldn't answer, she was hard at work sucking on his shaft and making it hard again. "Too make it up to you, I'll let you pick how we do it next. Anyway you want, anything you want to do I'll do it. So what do you say?"

Rachel released him with a loud pop and said, "I want you to fuck my ass the way you fucked Quinn's last night. Just you though, I don't know if I'm ready for DP."

"Are you sure?" Sam was surprised.

"I want to try it. But please be gentle, I've never done anything like this before." She positioned herself on all fours to present her perfect ass to him. She turned her head to see if he was getting ready, but Sam noticed she was nervous.

To make sure she was in the right state of mind, he fingered her pussy and rubbed her clit until she began to moan. Rachel's tension started to dissipate and this told Sam she was ready. He began to insert his cock into her ass. "Aaaaahhhh!" She cried out, but she wasn't hurt, just surprised at the new sensations. Sam went in very slowly, but by the time he was all the way in, Rachel was feeling pure pleasure.

"Okay, okay." Sam said to reassure her and himself a little bit. He rubbed the muscles of her back as she got used to the feeling of him in her ass.

Rachel leaned forward and started the process of removal, before stopping short and jamming herself all the way back down his cock. "I can do it Sam. Fuck me hard and fast. I want it all." Spurred on by Rachel's sudden confidence, Sam pounded into Rachel's ass with reckless abandon. "Oh Sam, I love your cock. Fuck my ass. It's all yours!"

Sam found his inner animal and continued thrusting into Rachel with increasing speed. Eventually he also grabbed her tits and played with them too. Many minutes later, Sam was grunting like a wild man ready to explode.

"Give it to me! I want your cum!"

Sam emptied his load into Rachel's ass and this was enough for Rachel to cum hard as well. As they recovered, Sam and Rachel noticed that their activities hadn't gone unnoticed: Dani and Quinn were fingering each other to orgasms having thoroughly enjoyed the show. Sam and Rachel reclined on the bed kissing and cuddling waiting for the other girls to finish.

"Thank you Sam. That was wonderful; better than I could have ever imagined." Rachel said.

"You're quite welcome. I'm happy that after all the bad things that have happened to you, I could still give you a memorable and happy first of something. Now that you're with me, you never have to be scared ever again. I'll be here for you anyway you want, as often as you want, for as long as you want. You know that right?" Tears welled up in Rachel's eyes as she cuddled closer to him.

In that moment, Sam thought about what he had said and realized that he was not only talking about sex. He loved this girl: really and truly loved her. He had not said the words, but he was sure that is what he felt.

xoxo

End of Chapter Ten.