Okay, so I guess I wasn't too informative about the second option for a longer fic, so I'll give you a bit of a spoiler about what's going to happen.
So, something bad was going to happen to Jude, which in turn makes Lucy act irrationally and do something stupid which would make someone else hurt her and would make her fall back into a state of depression like she was when her mother died.
Essentially, this option would be a more angst way of writing the story instead of the lighthearted version option one would be. So now you can re-vote, I guess, and I'll determine which way this will head.
Keep in mind, I have other sort-of-angst stories such as A Loner's Light and The Trial (which I only have the first chapter of so far before I went on my brief hiatus) so I'm leaning more toward option one, but be sure to tell me what you think by leaving a review :)
See you later, My Poptarts~