Omniscient POV
As music as Emma was sad at what she did to James, she was also excited to tell Will, Matthew was with his grandparents since they have a vacant day and they wanted to spend time with their grandson.
So Emma called Will. But she was sent to voice call. She left a message after the buzz.
"Will? I broke up with James! Thank you for making me realize I could only love one person truly. And you're that person Will. I'm just here at home so you can come and visit me when you want to. Ok bye." Emma says cheerfully.
Meanwhile, Will heard what Emma had said. But he didn't believe her. She was just playing with him making him trust her so She could tear his heart all over again. That's what Will thought. So he stayed in his hotel room, crying to himself iPod on one hand. his headphones on to maximum volume. He needed to escape, and music was the only way. He cried while singing the saddest songs. This was worst than James and Emma making out, because Emma promised him, promised him she'll breakup with James and they'll be a happy family. But he thought all Emma said the past night were just nothing.
An hour has past and Will hadn't called Emma yet. She was starting t worry. She tried to call Will again but no One was answering. So Emma decided to call Quinn.
"Hey Quinnie!" Emma said as the blonde picked up the phone.
"Hey Emma, do you need anything from me?"
"Umm, Will, do you know where he is. I tried calling him but he wouldn't answer."
"Well, that's funny, he told us that he'd be coming to your house and hour and about 15 minutes ago, but I can see he's not there." Emma thought about what happened in the last hour and remembered why Will wouldn't want to answer her calls.
"Quinn. Oh My God!" Emma says starting to burst into tears.
"Emmie, why are you crying I can hear your sobs form here."
"Will saw me kissing James this morning. I didn't want to kiss James I pulled away and I slapped him but maybe Will didn't see the last part. OH MY GOS QUINN WHAT AM I GOING TO DO! Will hates me right now I'm sure of it."
"Emma, calm down come here, maybe you could talk this out."
"I'm coming I'm just grabbing my things and getting in my car." Emma ran as fast as she could to her car. Putting it n speaker so she could talk to Quinn while driving.
"Emma, don't worry I'm heading to his room now."
"Thanks Quinn." Emma arrived there 5 minute later. Will still wouldn't open the door. He didn't here anything since he was listening to music. All of them were there. Finn,Rachel,Quinn,Santana and Mercedes. And soon Emma joined them.
"Will! Will!" Emma knocked. Will realized someone was knocking and took his headphones out. He heard Emma's voice. But he didn't want to see her.
"What do you want Emma!?" Will asks from behind the door.
"I know what you saw Will. I know you saw me Kissing James but its not what you think it is."
"Then what was it Emma?!"
"I-I he kissed me then I slapped him after I got to pull away."
"Your lying!"
"No I'm not Will. If you stayed you would've saw." Emma hears the door click and it was a signal for her to come in. The kids remained outside to give them privacy.
Emma walked inside carefully and saw Will lying on the bed with his headphones. she closed the door behind her.
"Will." he ignores Emma. "Will! I'm talking to you."
"What Emma?"
"I dont know what you saw but I'm sure that if you saw me kissing James it was nothing. I promise. He did it and I pulled away and I slapped him and-"
"I get it Emma."
"So you're okay with me? You're not mad?"
"Yes."
"So, is it okay if I kiss you?" Emma asks innocently.
"Yes." Emma leans in and kisses Will. Will responds to the kiss and Will brings Emma to his lap.
"I love you Will." Emma says in between kisses.
"God Emma, I've waited for so long to do this, with you." WIll says panting as he pulled away for a moment. Kissing Emma again, Emma drops off of his lap and lies down, urging Will to lie down with her. "I love you so much Will." they stay there kissing for about 5 more minutes when they hear someone knocking on the door.
Will opened the door and saw Shelby. This couldn't be good. Will had used Shelby to replace Emma for the last 20 months. They weren't in a relationship but Shelby misinterpreted it and thought Will and her were a thing.
"Hey hot stuff." Shelby says caressing Will's curls. Emma was sitting on the bed and was hearing everything Will and Shelby were talking about.
"Shelby, why are you here?"
"I missed you over at Lima and I have sources you know, I get the people I want. Why'd you run away from me Will? You didn't even kiss me goodbye."
"Shelby! Do I have to, we're not even a couple."
"What?! After we kiss and held hands in the park. Sang duets together, your kisses were so hot and full of passion Will and now you tell me we are not a couple. " at this Emma was furious. She stood up abruptly and headed towards where they were.
"Your a whore Will! So this is revenge huh!? Well I don't need you if you must know. Matthew and I could live our lives without you. Cause your a worthless piece of crap!" at that Emma walked away furious. But Will grabbed her elbow like he always did.
"Emma, she's lying. We're not a couple."
"Wow Will! Not a couple? Do friends kiss passionately and hold hands? Do friends kiss Will? Tell me?!Your just saying that so I can fall in love with you more! Then you'll break my heart and it will hurt twice as hard! Goodbye Will!" Emma ran away not looking back. This was why she never wanted to come back to Will.
Will tried to catch up to her but she was already in her car and she drove away. He was about to go to Emma's house when Shelby stopped him.
"What do you want shelby?"
"You Will. Why can't you just let go of Emma!?"
"Because I love her."
"Don't you love me? After all we've been through Will!"
"I don't." at that Will walks away and runs as fast too Emma's house. What he didn't know was Emma wasn't going home. She was going to James.
They were stuck in an Imperfect Routine. Falling for each other, misunderstanding situations, running to someone else. Everything was an Imperfect routine and they wanted to stop it.
"James." Emma says desperately knocking on James' door. He opens the door and sees Emma crying.
"Why are you here?"
"Will, he-."
"That's what I thought. Come here Emmie."
"James, how come your so kind to me even after I left you for a nobody?" Emma said hugging James tightly.
"Because I love you Emma. And I will never hurt you." he says swaying both of them. And kissing her head in the process.
"He doesn't love me James, he's just playing tricks on me."
"I'm here Emmie, don't worry I'm here, I'll take care of you."
"Thank you James. I love you, I'm sorry. I'm sorry."
"I love you too Emmie. And don't cry okay. It hurts me to see you cry." James says lifting Emma's chin and wipes Emma's tears away.
"I'm sorry, I'm sorry for leaving you. I'm sorry for slapping you, I'm sorry for rejecting your kiss, I'm sorry for leaving you for a nobody."
"Emms, the past is past, what matters is what's next. And I'll be here through everything. I'll help you raise Matt up, I'll help you."
"I love you James." Emma says kissing James passionately on the lips.
After a minute or so they both pulled away. Emma didn't know what she was doing. All she knew was she didn't want Will. She wanted to hurt him. She wanted to feel as what she felt. She couldn't believe he was chasing after Her and having an affair with Shelby. And she knows they did more than kissing and cuddling. Meanwhile, Emma did nothing. The worst she did was kiss James. She was so mad at Will. But she had no idea if what she was doing was right.
"Come on Emmie, I'll drive you home."
"Can you stay with me, for the night. I'm going to be all alone. Matt is not coming home till tomorrow. He's with Mom and dad."
"You sure babe?"
"Yes Hun." Emma says unsure of her words.
They both went inside Emma's car and James insisted he drive. After a 3 minute drive James and Emma arrived in her house.
"Babe, I love you so much."
"I love you too James." Emma says quite unsure.
James leans in and kisses Emma fully on the lips. Right then Will finally arrives and sees them kissing inside Emma's car. James went outside the car and opened the door for Emma. Emma grabbed James' hand and stands up. Snuggling closer to him. Leaning in to James and initiating a kiss. Will's jaw literally dropped.
Emma was just kissing him 30 minutes ago. And she just broke up with James. He was so confused. He wasn't mad, he just wanted all the distractions to go away. He wanted Emma, him and Matthew to become a family. He sits on the sidewalk. Thinking of anything, anything that he could possibly do to get Emma back. To get them out of this Imperfect routine.
Emma was sitting on the couch snuggling up to James.
"I hate him so much James."
"Emmie, don't. You loved him before. Didn't you?"
"I did, but he made me leave you. He made me think we would be happy like we were before. Then I find out he's been having an affair with someone." Emma says sniffling.
"Don't worry Emms. I'll be here to stay."
"And I won't leave you like I did before." Emma says snuggling even closer to James.
"Oh and Emma."
"Yes?"
"Thank you, for coming back to me."
"Why are you thanking me? I should be thanking you for staying with me."
"I just love you so much Emma."
"I love you too. And what happened was just a detour. Cause in the end we will lead to this." Emma says closing the gap between her and James. It was about 4:00 p.m. When they were happily snuggling in the couch.
But what was inside Emma's heart and mind was so different from the outer appearance. She was still as confused as ever. She wanted to hurt Will, she wanted to make him feel bad of himself. But was she going to hate him for her whole life. She was so mad that she made commitments to James, a great guy, that she'll stay with him and never bring him down like before. But could she really do that?
Just then Emma heard a knock on her front door. She opened the door leaving James on the couch. It was Will.
"What do you want Will?!"
"Emma, I'm sorry. I-I Shelby and I weren't anything."
"Wow Will! Did you really kiss her lots of times? Did you hold her hand? Did you cuddle with her?"
"Yes. And I regret it Em, you're the only woman I could accommodate in my life."
"The point is, you cheated. You made me think that we could finally be together but Shelby comes in and I find out you have a commitment to another woman? God Will!"
"Emma, I have no commitment to her."
"Yes You do. You lead her on Will! And it's your fault."
"Ok, but I'd leave her in a heartbeat for you baby. I'd do anything for you." Before Emma could move Will leans in to kiss her. But Emma doesn't respond and pulls away as fast as she can.
"How dare you Will!" Emma says slapping Will on the right cheek. His head crinkles and he hold his hand to his face as the pain sears.
"Emma, please. I Love you and I just don't want to lose you." Will says his voice cracking indicating he was crying.
"I'm sorry Will, you made me leave you."
"So you come back to James and get all lovey-Dovey?!" will says harshly.
"Yes! It's all your fault James and I had to go through break-ups! But this is fate. My life will always lead to me and James being together Will! And I just don't see you in the picture! James would be the greatest father! Better than you could ever be!" Emma lied, she knew Will was the perfect father for her young son.
"Emma, please, I don't want us to fall for this imperfect routine."
"What routine?!"
"This, falling in love, misunderstandings, running away, finding someone else, gets back together. Then again and again."
"Your right Will! Cause it ends here. I found someone else and the gets back together part isn't going to happen."
"No
Emma. I love you and I know that you love me too. Tell me the truth Emma. Look at me straight in the eyes and tell me if you love me or not."
"I love you Will but I can't be with you. I'm so broken, I can't handle this anymore."
"But wouldn't you sacrifice that for true love Em?"
"No, I've given you chances Will. So many. And you always found a way to break my heart."
"My heart is broken and fragile and damaged Emma. But it's yours. It will never be anyone's. It will only be yours."
James comes up to Emma and sees Will crying in front of Emma.
"Get out of here! You broke my princess's heart and I don't want you to get away with it." James says punching Will right on his buttchin.
He tries to stand up but was too weak, because of the punch and because he had no purpose to carry on. Emma wasn't with him.
"James! STOP!" Emma demanded.
"You said you hate him Em, I'm just doing this for you."
"NO! DON'T DO THIS. I STILL LOVE WILL OKAY!? DON'T HURT HIM!"
"What?!"
"I still love Will, don't hurt him." Emma says more quietly this time.
"I thought you promised that we will never fall apart. But why does it seem like you're coming back to him!?"
"I can't HELP WHO I FALL IN LOVE WITH JAMES AND UNFORTUNATELY I LOVE WILL. AND NO ONE BUT HIM!"
"Oh so you lied? You lied to me when you said you loved me?!"
"I was confused."
"You were confused or were you just a piece of crap!?"
"James, don't say that."
"And who are you to tell me not too!?" James says grabbing Emma by the collar.
"James it hurts!"
"Oh so you think it doesn't hurt to be used and played at?!"
"DON'T HURT MY ANGEL!" Will says getting up and running to James and punching him on the stomach causing him to drop Emma.
"I'm going to get my revenge!" James says running away.
Emma gets up and retreats to Will.
Their imperfect routine wasn't so perfect but they wanted it to stop at falling in love with each other. Cause they both knew they couldn't even try to hurt each other anymore.