It was a Sunday night and Spencer and Toby were at the grocery store. Amelia was fast asleep in her car seat. Toby was being extra lovey dovey on account of Spencer telling him she would have sex with him tonight. As much as she hated to admit it that trip to the clinic had freaked her out. She had been ready to tell Toby that they wouldn't be having sex until marriage. Not that marriage guaranteed he wouldn't leave her and she wouldn't end up raising their children alone. Toby circled his arms around Spencer kissing her. They got lost in the kiss and soon a voice broke them apart.

"You two ought to be ashamed of yourselves!" a woman in her forties yelled. "You already have one child out of wedlock and here you are practically making another in the frozen food aisle!"

Toby had thought it was funny he was still laughing when they got in the car to go home.

"You wouldn't be laughing if this kind of thing happened to you on a daily basis like it does me." she cried. "I'm always getting scornful looks and judgements." Toby was still laughing. "Guys hitting on me"

Toby stopped laughing. "What?!" he asked.

"Yeah, men see a baby and no man or ring and they automatically think I'm easy."

"I'm sorry I guess I didn't realize" he apologized.

"That's okay" she mumbled.

Toby sighed. He wished he could tell Spencer that she would have a ring in just a few short weeks. He had it all planned out. From the wine and the home cooked meal, to the scented bath and chocolate covered strawberries, to the proposal, to the red rose petals covering the bed they would inevitably be having celebratory sex on. Amelia was already asleep when they pulled up to the house. Toby was bringing in the last of the groceries when he noticed Spencer crying at the counter.

"Baby what's wrong?" he asked.

"You bastard" she whimpered handing him a card.

Thanks for all the GREAT late nights -Yvonne

"Baby it was just work, alright, her ex was stalking her and making threats and since she is a high profile person they gave her a cop detail" he explained.

"And you coincidentally just happened to be the one that got picked?"

"She asked for me" he admitted. Spencer turned and went upstairs into the bedroom. She slammed the door and locked it. Toby put Amelia to bed and put the groceries away. When he got to the bedroom door he could hear Spencer sobbing in the bedroom.

"Baby, please I promise nothing happened, it was just work" he said through the door.

She continued to cry and not answer him. He pulled out his phone and called his boss.

"Chief, its Cavanaugh, I need to remove myself from the Philips detail." he said. "Yes, I am aware that that means I will be out of the running for the detective promotion. Yvonne and I have somewhat of a history and it makes my girlfriend uncomfortable. Ok thank you"

Toby ended up sleeping on the floor outside of the room. When Spencer finally came out he got up onto his knees.

"Baby please forgive me" he pleaded "I took myself off of Yvonne's detail, no more Yvonne, I promise"

She crossed her arms. Spencer walked around him towards the baby's nursery.

"Spencer" he said going after her. "Please, let's just talk about this"

She picked up Amelia and laid her down on the changing table.

"I love you baby" he said.

"It's fine" she said flatly.

"Your mouth says it's fine but I'm getting a different vibe off your face." he countered.

"Toby" she sighed "don't push it"

He stood there waiting for her to say something else but she didn't.

"Are you just going to ignore me?" he asked incensed.

"I am getting Amelia and myself ready for our day" she said.

Toby sighed and stalked off to make coffee.

Spencer left an hour later with Amelia without saying a word to Toby. He hated this fighting. He knew in his heart that he should have turned down the Philips detail but he had wanted the promotion. It would have been set hours. A desk job. It would have been better for him and Spencer and Amelia. He hadn't been thinking that Yvonne would do something like that. He knew how Spencer felt about Yvonne and he should have told his boss no from the beginning. Toby decided to make it up to her by making her dinner, he had the day off since he'd quit the detail and they needed to assign him another shift. When Spencer came home Amelia was in her high chair at the table but it was clean. She had been fed and bathed by the looks of it. There were candles and all the fixings for the tacos she had been craving. Her heart melted a little and she decided to not be mad at Toby anymore. It was something he had to do for his job. She didn't like that he had lied to her but she understood why he did.

"Is it too soon to ask if I get lucky tonight?" Toby joked.

"I'll tell you what, I have a test Friday that I need to study for plus all my other class work. I will ask my mom to watch Amelia this weekend and you will get very very lucky." she said kissing him.

"Ok" he sighed. It had been over a month since they had made love and he was seriously horny.

"Come on just give me a quickie, I'm dying here" he teased.

"No, I told you this weekend" she teased.

"Fine" he pouted as he went upstairs.

Thursday night

It was 5 o'clock, Toby was just getting home from working a pick up shift and he had to turn around and do it again tomorrow. As he opened the door he saw Spencer on the couch studying. He looked around and Amelia was nowhere to be found. He thought maybe she was at the Hastings until he saw her diaper bag on the counter.

"Where's Amelia?" he asked knowing what she was going to say but hoping he was wrong.

"She's taking a nap" she said nonchalantly

"She's still sleeping?!" he yelled "Damn it Spencer now she's going to be up all night and I have to work tomorrow morning!" Amelia began crying now that Toby had woken her up.

"You can't work tomorrow!" she yelled back. "I told my mom you could watch her tomorrow since she's taking her for the weekend so you can get laid"

"Well why don't you have your sister do it then, she doesn't do anything all day except sit on her ass and hide from her husband"

"Maybe I'll just take Amelia and go over to my mother's tonight since she's going to be up all night" she snapped.

"Fine!" he yelled which only made Amelia cry louder.

Spencer took Amelia upstairs and Toby went into the kitchen looking for something to eat.

When he went upstairs his heart fell to the floor. A big suitcase was on the bed and she was emptying her side of the closet.

"Spencer?" He whispered.

"I can't do this anymore Toby, were at each other's throats, yelling at each other…"

"Who's yelling" he half whispered.

"We aren't meant to be together and the sooner we accept that the better"

"You don't mean that, you can't, I love you and Amelia so much, more than anything"

She closed the suitcase and Toby picked up Amelia.

"You're not taking her, I won't let you" Toby said. Spencer sighed rolling her eyes.

"I'm taking her and you can't stop me" she said trying to pull her out of Toby's arms. Amelia began crying again.

"Let go, you're scaring her" he said.

"Let go, you're hurting her" she countered, finally Toby let go of Amelia and she walked out the front door.

Spencer was trying to compose herself after getting Amelia and the suitcase in the car.

"Atta" Amelia said in her baby babble "Dada"

When Spencer got to her parents' house Melissa and her mother were waiting for her. The next morning Spencer felt like crap, Toby had been right Amelia was up all night and despite her mom and sister running interference she still barely slept. Her test went horribly. She was only able to finish less than half of it.

"Ms. Hastings, this kind of work isn't like you" the teacher asked when she handed it into him.

"My, uhm, my daughter kept me up all night. She is 7 months old so she can't really help it"

"I see" he said "why don't you take it and turn it in Monday" he said flashing her a smile.

"Really?" she asked excitedly.

"Really" he said.

"Thank you so much" she said as she left. She just had one more class and then she could go home to her beautiful baby girl.

Toby got done with his shift around two. He picked up some information on the daycare the police station provided. They would need a current physical and shot records. When he got home he called Amelia's doctor.

"Hello, I need my daughter's medical records so I can sign her up for daycare." he said politely.

"Name please?"

"Amelia Cavanaugh" he said.

"I'm sorry sir, I don't have an Amelia Cavanaugh"

"Oh, Amelia Hastings then" he said. Of course Spencer had given her her last name.

"Found it, and you are?"

"Her father, Toby Cavanaugh" he said. After a long pause the nurse came back on the phone.

"I'm sorry sir, I can't give you her medical records"

"Oh do you need something in writing from her mother?"

"No, but we have Caleb Rivers listed as her father."

"Well that's a mistake, she's my daughter"

"I'm sorry without a signed change from her mother I can't release anything to a non-parent"

"I'm not a non-parent, I'm her father!"

"I'm sorry sir, have a nice day"

Spencer was in the middle of class when she heard a phone vibrating. She was inwardly annoyed until she realized it was hers. She hoped it would stop when her teacher announced.

"Ms. Hastings will you do us all a favor and answer your blessed phone?!" he croaked.

"I'm sorry" she said pulling it out of her purse. She looked to see 20 texts and 10 calls from Toby.

"I have to go it is an emergency" she said ducking out of class. She read the texts first. They started out nice enough. Things like will you call me, I need to talk to you, it's important please call. She scrolled down to the last one that made her heart pound in her chest, in all caps it read

WHY THE FUCK DOES AMELIA'S DOCTOR'S OFFICE HAVE AMELIA'S FATHER LISTED AS CALEB?!

DUN DUN DUN! What do you guys think will happen next?

Review and let me know what you think!