"What would you want to catch up on?" Spencer asks with a curious expression.

"Did I ever tell you I saw what happened that day?" Alison's eyes turned evil.

"What do you mean?" Spencer asks panicking. She places her hands in her lap and played with her ring on her middle finger.

"Never mind. Have you talked to Caris lately?" Alison asks with a smile. Spencer gave her an irritated look.

"No. You?" Spencer asks trying to stay calm.

"No, where she is has no visiting hours." Alison moved a piece of blond hair behind her ear.

"Where is she? A mental hospital? Jail?" Spencer asks concerned. She could've easily given her a fake identity or something. It was Alison Dallas, she could do almost anything.

"No. It's a long story." Alison says shrugging.

"I want to hear it." Spencer snaps. "She was my best friend too."

"Fine." Alison snaps. "Jenna was after her and she needed away out. I gave her a new identity, like you predicted probably. I changed her name to Bailey Hastings." Alison stopped and took a breath.

"Why my last name?" Spencer asks.

"So if Jenna ever saw the name she would think it was a relative of you and she never wanted anything to do with you that we knew of. Anyways, I gave her that identity and she left. I guess it got too much for her or something because when I came to visit her it looked like she committed suicide." Alison smiles. "I don't know why im trusting you, I mean, I shouldn't be".

"I know I gave you no reason to, but again, I deserve to know." Spencer says sternly them urges her to continue.

"So…I thought maybe Jenna found her. No one could find the body because they would know it was Caris. So I took care of it and it was found a little bit ago." Alison finished explaining.

"So Jenna is alive?" Spencer questions. Alison looks at her and smiles.

"I have my ways. I can make her come back whenever I want her to." Alison looks Spencer in the eyes. "But Jenna didn't her my voice so I wouldn't be in trouble."

"What are you talking about?" Spencer asks confused.

"I took some recordings. Jenna heard your voice only. No one else's."

XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX

"Do we just set here and wait?" Aria asks Hanna. "I guess." Hanna shrugs.

"Where's Em?" Aria asks Hanna.

"She said she had to take care of something." Hanna shrugs again. Hanna glanced at the clock and the time read 9:55.

"We should go. No one's here." Aria whispers still looking toward Spencer's house.

"5 more minutes." After Hanna said that, there light above the stairs turns on. They watch Spencer walk down dressed in what she was wearing this morning.

"When did she get home? Her cars not even here." Aria whispers to Hanna. "I don't- look! There it is". They both look and saw Caleb. Her wasn't hidden or anything and looked normal.

"So we can cross them off being A". Hanna says.

"When did we think they were A?" Aria asks shocked. Aria can swear she thought they were dating, that's it.

"I never told you that?" Hanna asks her thinking.

"No." Aria says seriously and watches Spencer let him in.

"You would think they were blind." Hanna says looking at Caleb hand Spencer an envelope labeled something they couldn't read, in front of a big open window.

"Who's the blond?" Hanna asks as she sees the blond appear. The blond takes the envelope from Spencer and looks inspects it. She opens it and says something to Spencer.

"I don't want to watch anymore." Hanna says getting out of her car and walking toward Spencer's. "Wait Hanna." Aria says and tries to run faster to stop her. By the time she caught up Hanna already knocked on the door. Spencer opens the door part way so only her face was sticking out.

"Oh hey, it's Aria and HANNA." Spencer yelled Hanna louder. Hanna assumed it was meant for Caleb to run and hide somewhere. Spencer goes to talk but the door gets yanked open the rest of the way throwing Spencer off balance.

"This must be the famous Aria and Hanna." The blond smiles. Hanna gives her a dirty look and Aria fake smiles.

"I'm Alison but you can call me Ali". Alison smiles. "Why don't we let them in Spence?" Alison asks innocently but the two girls could see fear in Spencer's eyes.

"Come on in". Spencer says moving out of the way.

"So Alison." Aria starts to start conversation. Alison looks her way. "How did you and Spencer Meet?"

"I was best friends with her, Alison, and Caris when we were younger." Alison smiles.

"Who's Caris?" Hanna asks her.

"Spencer never told you about her? Whoops." She says evilly.

"You can tell us… If you want to of course." Aria says trying to sound like she knew what was going on. This Alison girl looked a lot like there Alison but not exactly, her nose was a little smaller and her eyes were brown. Aria knew she had seen her somewhere before.

"She was the 'good twin'." Alison laughs. Spencer sets there uncomfortably.

"Good twin? Who was her twin?" Hanna asks getting really into this.

"You wouldn't believe me. Most people don't". Alison says looking down.

"We'll believe you. I promise." Aria says fast.

"Okay, she was the good twin of Alison." Alison says and smiles again. Spencer's eyes open wide in shock; Spencer did expect her to say Jenna. Aria and Hanna both looked confused.

"You don't believe me, do you?" Alison asks quietly.

"I do… Where is she?" Hanna asks. Alison did an 'uh-oh' smile. "Well Caris ended up being crazy. Tried to strangle Spencer." Spencer tried to smile and go along with what Alison was saying.

"I thought it was Spencer who went crazy." Aria blurts.

"No, it was Caris. She had a bit of a mental problem." Alison says to them. "Spencer just blamed herself for the cause." Aria and Hanna nod their head. 'Why is she helping me?' Spencer thought. 'She's going to want something big.'

"Umm, we should get going." Aria says pulling Hanna.

"Ya we should…Umm bye Ali and Spencer." Hanna smiles and walks away with Aria. "Never thought I would say those to name together like that again." Hanna whispers to Aria.

"My car!" Hanna yells and runs to it. The window had been smashed in and a note was left inside. Hanna opened the envelope. It had several Pictures of Spencer from when she was 7 with both Alison's and a girl who looked like Jenna.

"I'm so confused." Aria says.

The note said:

People lie for Friends or in this case, there enemies.

~A

A/n: Sorry, I wrote this kind of fast. I'm going to be gone from Tuesday to Saturday without internet so I will try to update before but if I don't, you know why