Sorry for the insanely long wait for this chapter. I've been so busy, I'm actually amazed I got this out. Anyway, enjoy.

Ana Lucia grabbed Shannon by the arm and led her into the kitchen. "Okay, I don't think Kate saw us", she said.

"So, what's this plan? Why do you need me?" Shannon asked.

"I need you because you're the only one who would help me", said Ana. "Okay, here's the plan...",she started.

Five minutes later they came back into the living room. "Where'd you go?" asked Sawyer.

"Bathroom", Ana replied. "I had to show Shannon where it was." Hurley started to say something, but she shot him a look, and he quickly stopped talking.

"Okay then, let's start", said Claire.

Ana smiled. "Kate, truth or dare?"

Kate hesitated. She didn't like questions, so she never chose truth. "Dare", she said slowly. Who knew what Ana Lucia would come up with?

Ana's smile widened. This was where her plan came into play. There were two possible outcomes, and both were good.

"Okay, but first we need to think of something that you have to do if you back out." Ana shot a glance at Shannon.

"I have an idea. If you back out of a truth or dare, you have to tell everyone who your first kiss was", Shannon said, grinning widely. Everyone started laughing.

"Are you kidding me?" exclaimed Kate.

Sawyer shook his head. "Rules are rules, Freckles."

Ever since they were fifteen, the girls had been trying to get Kate to tell them who first kiss was. They all assumed it was her ex-boyfriend Tom, but when she refused to tell them, they got curious. They had been trying to get it out of her for the past two and a half years, and they had even gotten the boys involved.

"Fine, I'm not going to back out of anything", said Kate confidently.

"She says that now," Ana wispered to Shannon, who laughed quietly.

"Okay Kate, your dare is to kiss Sawyer", said Ana. Kate's eyes widened. Why would Ana Lucia want her to kiss Sawyer? Everyone knew Ana liked him. Apparently, Sawyer was thinking the same thing.

"What, you don't like me anymore, Lulu?" asked Sawyer. He tried to pass it off as a joke, but deep down he really did wonder if she still liked him.

"Sawyer, just shut up and kiss her", said Ana Lucia with a laugh.

The only person who noticed Jack glaring at Sawyer as Kate leaned into kiss him was Charlie.

"It's just a dare, mate" he said under his breath.

Meanwhile, Kate was an inch from Sawyer's lips. Right before they touched, he gave her a smirk and she laughed against his mouth. The kiss lasted longer than she expected, but she suddenly pulled back.

"Sawyer! The dare didn't involve your tongue!" Kate exclaimed. Everyone laughed.

"Ok, my turn", said Kate. "Boone, truth or dare?"

Boone looked a bit shocked for a moment, then said, "Dare."

Kate thought for a minute. Ana's next door neighbor was the secretary at their school. She thought of something.

"Okay, listen. Go next door to Mrs. Smith's house, and ask her if you can use her phone to call for a ride. Just call Ana's and pretend to ask. Then talk to Mrs. Smith while you 'wait' for your ride. Then, in the middle of the conversation, say 'stop trying to seduce me, Mrs Smith,' then run out and come back here."

Kate grinned and asked, "Did you get all that?" Everyone laughed at the look on Boone's face.

"I really have to do that?" he asked. Kate nodded, and Boone let out a deep sigh.

"Have fun", said Shannon. Boone scowled and slowly walked out of the house.

"Do you think he'll really do it?" asked Claire.

"No," replied Shannon, "He'll be back in a minute."

They all laughed, and didn't notice that Ana's dog came into the room. Well, Charlie noticed. His eyes lit up and he turned to Sawyer.

"Truth or dare, mate?" he asked.

"Dare" Sawyer replied lazily.

Charlie grinned. "Put one of Ana's bras on the dog and walk it around the block" He said with a laugh that was echoed by everyone else's.

Sawyer smirked. "I'll do anything involving Ana Lulu's bras", he said, getting up and walking up the stairs to Ana's room.

"Hey! Don't go near my room!" exclaimed Ana Lucia, quickly following him up the stairs.

Suddenly, a phone rang in the kitchen. Shannon quickly stood up. "No way", she said.

Five minutes later she returned. "It was Boone", she said looking shocked. "He's actually doing it."

Just then, a slightly dishevled Ana and Sawyer came back downstairs. "I got the bra", said Sawyer with a grin. However, the dog was gone, so they decided to wait for it to come back.

Shannon turned to Kate. "Truth or dare?" she asked.

"Me again?" replied Kate. "Fine, dare." She didn't see the smile Shannon gave Ana. One step closer to solving the mystery of Kate's first kiss.

"Is anyone going to do a truth?" asked Hurley. Shannon ignored him and said,

"Well, you got a taste of Sawyer, now kiss Jack."

"Why's Kate gettin' all the action tonight?" asked Sawyer. "That ain't fair."

"Sawyer, stop trying to keep Kate from kissing Jack," said Ana.

"Yeah, and we all know what you and Ana were doing up-" Charlie started, but was cut off by Ana Lucia throwing a pillow at his face.

Shannon turned to Jack and Kate who were staring at each other intently. "Will you two kiss already?" she asked impatiently.

Kate shrugged and leaned into Jack while the others watched, and Ana and Shannon contemplated their next move in hushed voices.

Just when it seemed as if they would never break apart, the front door flew open, startling everyone and breaking Jack and Kate apart. Boone ran in and said "I'm so dead!"

"I can't believe you actually went through with that!" exclaimed Shannon.

"Yeah, and I'll be lucky if I don't get suspended! Thanks again", he said, turning to Kate.

She smiled. "Any time."

They played for a while longer, in which time they learned Hurley had only kissed one girl, Shannon had seen all the Star Wars movies, Libby wasn't a natural blonde, Charlie was afraid of bees and cats, and Ana really did think Sawyer was hot. They all knew that, but it was funny to hear her admit it. Also, there had been a few prank calls and Claire was wrapped in a towel, drying herself off. When it was Ana Lucia's turn to pick someone, she chose Kate.

"Why do you keep picking me?" exclaimed Kate.

"Truth or dare?" was all Ana said.

"Well, I'm afraid if I say dare again, I'll end up kissing Charlie" she teased.

"Not that you would mind!" said Charlie.

"So," Kate continued, "Truth."

Ana and Shannon couldn't help but laugh. She had fallen right into their trap. Kate gave them a confused look.

"What?" she asked.

"Nothing", replied Ana. "Okay, you're question is, who's a better kisser, Jack or Sawyer?" Everyone besides Kate, Jack, and Sawyer broke into a fit of laughter. Jack and Sawyer looked at Kate curiously, and Kate blushed a deep red.

"I'm not answering that!" she exclaimed.

"Come on Freckles, you know the answer", said Sawyer with a smirk.

"You wish, Sawyer" said Jack.

"I'm not answering it!" Kate repeated.

"Well, then you have to tell us who your first kiss was", said Ana Lucia with a smirk to match Sawyer's.

"You planned this, didn't you?" asked Kate.

"Maybe."

Kate sighed. She had to tell them now. They would never let her forget it. Before she answered, she looked at the person who's name was about to come out of her mouth. He gave her a small smile and she smiled back before she answered.

Ooh, cliffhanger. If you think you know who it is, or there's someone you want it to be, tell me in your review. I might even change it if I get alot for one person, or someone has an idea I like. So there's a really good reason for you to review, if the fact that they really make me happy isn't enough. I'll try my hardest to update much quicker next time.