"Wait wait!" Brittany said.
"Brit no, I want to hear them now!" Santana said.
"Don't you think we should do our surprise goodbye group number to Sam first?" Brittany asked and Sam and Dean heard her.
"Well there's no surprise anymore." Rachel said.
"Thanks Brittany." Puck said sarcastically.
"You're welcome!" Brittany said.
"Aww, you guys had a goodbye song for me?" Sam said.
"Yup, it's called…" Brittany started.
"Brit let's keep some of the surprise ok?" Santana asked.
"Oh sorry, ok."
"So do you guys want Dean and me to sing our duet first or do you want to sing your goodbye song to me?"
"I guess since Brit let it slip we might as well sing our goodbye number." Rachel said. "But it's more than a goodbye number. We do this thing sometimes where we change the meaning of the song to benefit us. So we have given this song a different meaning, like we gave Because You Loved Me a brotherly meaning, and we will tell you that meaning after the song."
"Now you guys probably don't like this band, if you even know them, trust me I don't like them that much either, but the song has a good meaning." Finn said.
"It's One Thing by One Direction." Tina said.
"The only direction I've heard of is the New Directions." Sam said.
"Me too Sam! I get confused with right and left!" Brittany said. "But if you don't know the directions than how do you know how to stake a vampire if you don't know what side his heart is on?"
"Brit, I didn't mean it like that! Well if you guys want to sing first that's great!" Sam said.
"Fine with me! Not that I don't want to hear two sing because believe me I do!" Kurt said.
"We all do! Anyway just listen to the words and picture it from not just one person to one person…"
"Or five hot guys to one hot guy." Kurt said.
"Yes exactly, just picture it from all of the New Directions to you." Rachel said. "And Dean, this is more to Sam but it applies to you too I guess. Hit it."
"So we are doing One Thing right?" The piano man asked.
"Yes, duh, don't you and the band always just know what we are going to sing anyway? And since when can you talk to us?" Rachel asked. "Now like I said, hit it."
Rachel sings. "I've tried playing it cool, but when I'm looking at you, I can't ever be brave, cause you make my heart race." Rachel pointed at Sam and Dean who were sitting in the seats now.
Santana sings. "Shot me out of the sky, you're my kryptonite, you keep making me weak, yeah, frozen and can't breathe." Santana pointed at Sam and Dean.
Kurt and Blaine sing. "Something's gotta give now, cause I'm dying just to make you see, that I need you here with me now, cause you've got that one thing!" Kurt, Blaine, and all of the New Directions pointed at Sam and Dean.
All of the Glee club sings. "So get out, get out, get out of my head, and fall into my arms instead, I don't, I don't, don't know what it is, but I need that one thing, and you've got that one thing." They all pointed at Sam again.
Tina and Mercedes sing. "Now I'm climbing the walls, but you don't notice at all, that I'm going out of my mind, all day and all night."
Finn sings. "Somethings' gotta give now, cause I'm dying just to know your name, and I need you here with me now, cause you've got that one thing." Finn and the whole Glee club pointed at Sam.
All of the Glee club sings. "So get out, get out, get out of my head, and fall into my arms instead, I don't, I don't, don't know what it is, but I need that one thing, get out, get out, get out of my mind, and come on, come into my life, I don't, I don't, don't know what it is, but I need that one thing, and you've got that one thing."
The New Direction boys sing while clapping. "Woah."
Girls sing while clapping. "Woah."
They all sing while clapping. "Woah."
During that Dean puts his fist out for Sam to fist bump. "Since when do we fist bump?" Sam asked.
"Since we tried something totally different and it actually made us both happy. So I want to try this, to tell you this is actually awesome and that I support you no matter what." Dean whispered back. Sam smiled and fist bumped Dean.
"You've got that one thing." Santana sung as she grabbed Sam and dragged him up on the stage.
The music stopped and the whole Glee club sings this part as a cappella. "Get out, get out, get out of my head, and fall into my arms instead."
The music started again as the whole club sings. "So get out, get out, get out of my head, and fall into my arms instead, I don't, I don't, don't know what it is, but I need that one thing, get out, get out, get out of my mind, and come on, come into my life, I don't, I don't, don't know what it is, but I need that one thing, and you've got that one thing." The whole club pointed at Sam and gave him a group hug. Dean stood up and clapped.
"Dean, you are welcome to come up here and join in on the group hug." Santana said.
"Don't mind if I do!" Dean said and went to the middle and held his arms out to Sam.
"Since when do we hug when neither of us are dying or haven't seen each other in a while?" Sam asked.
"Do I have to go through the spiel again because it's pretty much the same reason for the fist bump." Dean said. "And plus, you're a cool brother, best brother ever." Dean said and cleared his throat because he was kind of embarrassed he said something that lame.
"You've got that one thing Dean. And that thing is being an amazing brother, and the best damn brother in the world." Sam said and hugged him and Dean hugged back and the whole club hugged them.
"Now Sam, I bet you want to know what your one thing that we all were singing about was." Rachel said.
"I have some ideas, but sure what is my one thing?" Sam said as they all let out of the hug.
"Well it's actually a lot of things but it can all be narrowed down to awesome! You accepted us from the very beginning, you love us, we love you, and you are an excellent teacher." Santana said.
"If you were listening to the words, get out of my head and come into my arms instead. That was us as a group always thinking about you and letting you know you can come back whenever." Kurt said.
"Or stay!" Rachel said. Dean and Sam both looked at the club.
"Guys, I am so sorry, but I can't stay."
"You and Dean seem like you hate that life." Santana said.
"But it's still our life. First of all what would Mr. Schue think about you guys trying to replace him. He wouldn't feel loved. I do love you guys but let's keep the message of that song as me being welcome back whenever and that I accept you guys as you are. Let's keep it like that because I'm sorry but staying is not an option." Sam said.
"Why? Because of me?" Dean asked.
Sam looked at him with the biggest WTF face ever. "Dean, hunting is what we were born into, I'm not leaving you again like I did for Stanford. I was excited but it still hurt leaving you and dad and plus it hurt you."
"I'm not saying forever. I'll pick you up in a couple weeks, it will just give you more time with what makes you happy." Dean said.
"You make me happy too Dean. These few days were great and I'm so thankful to you for giving them to me but I'm not staying."
"We didn't mean forever either. Most of us are graduating this year, we just meant stay a little longer." Rachel said.
"No, I told you it's out of the question. I'm really sorry, and I am going to miss you all so much but it wouldn't be right to stay. Especially when we are hunting Lilith and trying to stop the freaking apocalypse from being jump started even more."
"Oh damn. You know what it was selfish of us to ask you to stay." Mercedes said.
"Yeah it actually was you guys." Sam said.
"Sam, no need to take your problem with me being ok with you staying out on them. I just thought since you were like oh I hate hunting, I want to stay in Buffalo, NY in a high school Glee club and move onto college and make something of my life…" Dean mocked Sam. "that you would appreciate me letting you live a normal life for a couple weeks."
"Dean no it's ok. I wish and I wish for a normal life sometimes but this was meant to be and we are never going to get that normal life. And you gave me everything I ever wanted when you let us take a break and spend a few days at a high school in Ohio just so I can lead a group of amazing kids into singing and dancing. I love you for that and just being the amazing big brother you are to me daily. So, I couldn't pick a better person to hunt with then you even though you and hunting is a huge pain in my ass sometimes."
"Thanks man, and sorry, I just thought if you wanted to be normal so bad that I would give it to you for a little bit longer."
"Wanky." Santana said as Dean and Sam both laughed.
"I got everything I wanted in three days and tonight I get to hunt this bitch more with my big brother. That's all I could ask for." Sam said and smiled while he hugged Dean.
"Now that brotherly love is in the air I think it's a perfect time for you two to sing Because You Loved Me." Rachel said.
"Wait! First I want to tell you that I'm sorry for snapping back at you guys. It wasn't all that selfish. I enjoyed every minute I have spent with you, but there is always going to be a time when someone important to you has to leave. And in my case I have to leave some very important people to me. And you all are going to experience this at the end of the year."
"Aww Sam, we can't say this enough but we are going to miss you so much and we will always remember you!" Santana said as the whole club shook their heads yes.
"Me too! Now I guess this is the final number." Sam said.
"But 100 is the final number!" Brittany said.
"No Brit." Santana said.
"Ok guys this isn't only from Dean and me to each other but think of it as from me to you and you guys to me and to each other." Sam said.
"Yeah of course." Santana said as she grabbed Brittany's hand. And the other Glee clubbers grabbed their significant other's hands as Mercedes grabbed Artie's. Puck was again left alone until Santana noticed and grabbed his hand too. They both smiled at each other. Castiel appeared out of nowhere.
"Oh God, you're like the piano man, just appearing out of nowhere!" Brittany said.
"Have you seen God?" Castiel asked.
"I've seen Unisius, the head unicorn, he's kind of like God except a unicorn." Brittany said.
"Cass what you doing here?" Dean asked.
"I wanted to see you two sing together." Cass said and sat on the stage.
"No!" Dean said.
"Listen Dean, I can either watch with you seeing me or watch without you seeing me, but either way I am going to see you sing." Cass said.
"Crap. Whatever, but this is never getting mentioned again." Dean said and Castiel just smiled at him and laughed a little with his mouth closed not shaking his head at all. "Dude I said, you are never mentioning this again."
"And I did." Castiel said and then smiled at Dean while laughing through his smile.
"Damn angels! Ok I'm ready Sam how about you?"
"Yeah let's go!" Sam said and pointed at the piano man and the band.
Sam sings. "For all those times you stood by me, for all the truth that you made me see, for all the joy you brought to my life, for all the wrong that you made right, for every dream you made come true, for all the love I found in you, I'll be forever thankful, baby, you're the one who held me up, never let me fall, you're the one who saw me through, through it all."
Sam sings. "You were my strength when I was weak."
Dean sings. "You were my voice when I couldn't speak."
"You were my eyes when I couldn't see." Sam sang as he pointed to his eyes and then to Dean.
"You saw the best there was in me."
"Lifted me up when I couldn't reach." Sam sung as he pointed up.
"You gave me faith 'cause you believed." Dean sung.
Both of them sing. "I'm everything I am, because you loved me."
Dean sings. "You gave me wings and made me fly." Dean pointed at Castiel and Cass
laughed. "You touched my hand, I could touch the sky, I lost my faith, you gave it back to me, you said no star was out of reach, you stood by me and I stood tall, I had your love, I had it all, I'm grateful for each day you gave me, maybe I don't know that much
but I know this much is true, I was blessed because I was loved by you." Dean sung and pointed at Sam as they both smiled at each other.
Dean sings. "You were my strength when I was weak."
Sam sings. "You were my voice when I couldn't speak."
"You were my eyes when I couldn't see."
"You saw the best there was in me."
"Lifted me up when I couldn't reach."
"You gave me faith 'cause you believed."
They both sing. "I'm everything I am, because you loved me."
Sam sings. "You were always there for me, the tender wind that carried me."
Dean sings. "A light in the dark shining your love into my life."
Sam sings. "You've been my inspiration, through the lies you were the truth."
They both sing. "My world is a better place because of you. You were my strength when
I was weak, you were my voice when I couldn't speak, you were my eyes when I couldn't see, you saw the best there was in me, lifted me up when I couldn't reach, you gave me faith 'cause you believed, I'm everything I am, because you loved me." Sam and Dean sung and then they both pointed to the Glee club.
Sam, Dean, and the Glee club sing in unison. "You were my strength when I was weak,"
Kurt and Blaine touched hands while singing it to each other with the group. "You were my voice when I couldn't speak," Santana and Brittany put their pinkies together and smiled at each other while singing. "You were my eyes when I couldn't see," Artie and Mercedes smiled at each other as Puck took Artie's glasses off and put them back on and the three of them laughed. "You saw the best there was in me," Rachel and Finn hugged as they sung with the group. "Lifted me up when I couldn't reach," Tina and Mike held hands as they sung with the group. "You gave me faith 'cause you believed," Dean and Sam smiled at each other, and then at Cass who smiled back. "I'm everything I am, because you loved me." Sam pointed at the Glee club and they pointed back at him while they smiled.
Castiel started singing and he was alone. "I'm everything I am…" Cass looked around embarrassed. Dean chuckled and so did the Glee club.
Everybody sings. "Because you loved me." As the song ended everybody cheered loudly and clapped for each other. The Glee club, Sam, and Dean all went around and gave each other hugs.
"That was actually pretty cool!" Dean said.
"Yeah it was! It was pretty damn awesome!" Sam said.
"That was pretty good!" Castiel said.
"Yeah Cass, did you enjoy singing?" Dean asked.
"Well Dean, now we both have something to never mention again." Cass said. Dean just smiled and laughed through his teeth without shaking his head at all. "You think it's so funny, well I can erase your memory."
"Don't do that."
"I wouldn't, unless you agreed to it." Cass said.
"No thank you." Dean said and Cass rolled his eyes and disappeared.
"Wow that was a hot performance you guys!" Santana said.
"Thank you!" Dean said.
"Santana, stick with Brittany." Sam said.
"You told them that we were stuck together that time?" Brittany asked as everyone gave her a weird look.
"No Brit. And I know Sam, I'll always stay with Brittany as long as she will let me but you two are hot so yeah." Santana said.
"Well our time is running out." Sam said.
"No it's not. Glee club wouldn't have started until about now, remember we left class 20 minutes early?" Mercedes asked.
"Yeah, but guys, the earlier Dean and I get on the road the better. But we have a few minutes left so we can all say goodbye." Sam said.
Santana started crying and then Rachel did, followed by Kurt, Mercedes, and Tina. "I am going to miss you more than you will ever know." Santana sobbed and hugged Sam. Sam was trying to hold in the tears. He knew that he would cry but he just wanted to appear strong.
"It's ok to cry Sam, regardless of what I've told you before." Dean said and Sam immediately cried a little.
"I'm going to miss you too." Sam sobbed. "I'm going to miss all of you. Never in my years of hunting have I met someone that I'm going to miss more, or hell even liked. As corny as it sounds, well Glee is corny sometimes anyway, so here it goes, as corny as it sounds you guys are all in my heart and will forever remain in my heart. I know it's crazy because it's only been three days, but I love you guys! I loved teaching you, learning about you, learning from you, hearing you sing, and singing with you, it was all amazing. I loved all the songs we sang or that I've seen you sing, even our song Santana, Promiscuous. Whenever I hear that song I will think about you, as weird as that is. And I'll just think about all you guys in general and how fast you accepted me as a substitute teacher. And I will always be amazed that after three days you already wanted me to stay with you guys. I was flattered, but I can never leave my brother, not again. And thank you for that goodbye song; I'm glad I have that one thing that you guys look for in a teacher." Sam said.
"Not only in a teacher but in a friend." Rachel said and smiled as she cried.
"Damn right!" Santana said. "And I think we all are amazed that after three days we already feel so loved and love you back as well. And every time I hear Promiscuous I will think of you too, and more times than just that." Santana said.
"And you will remain in our hearts forever too!" Mercedes said. "Like the song said, my world is a better place because of you. And we are everything we are because you and people like you loved us."
"Yeah, and all our worlds are a better place because of you, not just Mercedes'. I'm pretty sure we all feel that way, even the straight boys who won't admit it." Brittany said. "I mean Sam you accepted me even though I'm really dumb and have a high cat and a pet unicorn who like to have sex. And I love you for that because Santana also accepts me even though I'm dumb so I love everyone that is able to do that." Brittany said and smiled at Sam and then Santana.
"Wow Brittany, that was really sweet actually!" Sam said.
"Yeah, I'm so sweet that I also told Uni to tell the unicorns to not kill you two anymore, or force you two to have sex with me because I realized that Santana loves me too much for that and I need to start loving her back so she is the only one that I want to have sex with." Brit said and kissed Santana.
"Thanks for those kind words Brittany." Sam said as he wiped off his tears. Dean actually shed a tear when thinking how much Sam really meant to him and how that song, although cheesy, was true for him and his brother. But Dean didn't let anybody see his tear.
Mr. Schue walked in with Emma.
"I told Mr. Schue he should take over for today." Sam said.
"Only at this school would someone come in after they have been absent for a day just for a club." Puck said.
"It's because I love you guys like Sam loves you. Only more because I've known you for longer than three freaking days." Will said. "I've known you for almost three years. And I will be sad at the end of this year. I want to definitely win Nationals this year."
"I want you guys to win it too." Emma said and winked at Will.
"But we can't do that if someone in this club doesn't commit. Santana, I heard you helped Sue light a piano on fire while Blaine was performing. Get out and come back when you are as committed to this club as everyone else in it is." Will said.
"No, Santana ended up not helping Sue." Sam said.
"It's fine Sam. I can see now how I and the rest of this club wanted you to stay and take over." Santana said right into Mr. Schue's face.
"Is that true?" Will asked.
"It was a misunderstanding Will, they wanted me to stay a little bit longer but not takeover. But I couldn't do that and I wouldn't."
"It's fine Sam, I'm sure Santana is just pissed. Emma and I will leave you alone and you can say your final goodbyes to the club." Will said as he and Emma left. Santana stayed in.
"It's ok Sam; I could use a break especially if there is no you." Santana said and hugged Sam again.
"Don't worry; you are crazy talented so you will be back in the club. You definitely deserve it." Sam said. "Well as I said I hope to see all of you become successful in the ways you want and I wish all of you the best of luck. We all can't say this enough it seems, I will miss you and hopefully we will see each other again, but if we don't, farewell!"
"One more group hug?" Tina asked.
"I thought you'd never ask."
"Woah, that's another substitute's saying." Puck said.
"Oh sorry. What should mine be?" Sam asked.
"Umm, my pleasure, of course." Santana said.
"My freaking pleasure." Sam said and they all smiled and went in for a group hug. Kurt, the girls, and Sam started to cry again. They loved this moment and wanted to stay in it for life. But they had to let each other go, and at the end of this year, the juniors would have to let the seniors go. It was a sad moment for all of them, even the straight guys who would never admit it. They did learn a lot from Sam just as he learned from them. They loved each other and as they said, they would stay in each other's hearts forever.
After the group hug Sam hugged each member of the Glee club individually and even fist bumped Finn, Puck, Mike, and Artie. "I love you guys. Good luck with your futures!" Sam said and then he hugged Santana. As he hugged her he slipped a sheet of paper into her hand. She read it quickly to herself. The note said: Don't tell anybody this information; it's mine and Dean's numbers, for an emergency only. And remember sometimes talking about life is an emergency, if we are busy we won't always be able to talk though. Then the note listed Sam and Dean's numbers for all their phones and what that phone was for. As Sam left the auditorium he turned around and winked at Santana. She tried to smile behind her tears and she cried even more because they cared enough to give her their numbers. Dean also waved at her as he left. She waved back as the whole Glee club waved to Sam and Dean.
"Sammy that was really freaking sad even for me!" Dean said. "But do you know what's going to be sadder, what I have to do now; say bye to Quinn."
"Yeah that was very sad; I can't believe how sad it was. And that song was actually pretty good for us, even though it was cheesy."
"That's exactly what I thought!"
"Do you want me to go with you to say bye to Quinn?" Sam asked.
"Sure." Dean said.
Quinn was already walking towards them.
"Quinn? I was just coming to say goodbye to you." Dean said and hugged her.
"I don't know you that well yet you are one of the last people I want to say goodbye too. I'm going to miss you!" Quinn said.
"I'm actually going to miss you too." Dean said as they let out of the hug.
"You changed my life Dean Winchester. I can't thank you enough. I'll be going back to Glee club because of you; I'm keeping my grades up and moving onto college because of you. It's all because you loved me, well maybe not love but you care for me!"
"Yeah maybe not love but I like you a lot! And I care about you." Dean said. "So much so that I'm going to give you my numbers and my brother's numbers for your safety." Dean gave her the same note Sam gave to Santana.
"Thank you!" Quinn said and hugged him again. "Good bye Dean." Quinn said as a tear flowed down her cheek. Dean used his finger and caught her tear and she smiled. He even watered up a little too. The Glee club was Sam's happiness here while Quinn was Dean's happiness here.
"Goodbye Quinn." Dean said. Quinn gave him a quick kiss on the lips and let him leave. Sam waved to Quinn as Quinn turned around to walk into school.
"After saying goodbye to her, there is nothing more here. Let's go Sammy!" Suddenly they heard a scream and then turned around quickly. They saw someone struggling against a window upstairs. Then the window broke and a cheerleader fell out.
"Help me!" She screamed as she fell out and splat as she hit the ground. Dean and Sam looked at the window and noticed a shadow running away from the window.
"OH SHIT!" Sam and Dean said in unison as they ran for the school.
The End!
There is a sequel coming eventually! It will be much much shorter than this one and won't be as comedic. This one was more Supernatural in the Glee world so the next one will be Glee in the Supernatural world. Please write a review! Just thought I would keep advertising my other stories: Let Me Walk You Through It, part of its sequel Walking On My Own With You, and my first fanfic I Remember the Way We Touched are on the site! I hope you read and enjoy those and enjoyed this one! Thank you so much, you reading, reviewing, favoriting (I know that's not a word), and enjoying my stories means the world to me!