Broadway had been amazing so far. I had just finished my semester at NYADA as a freshman and now it's me and Broadway. Although, these past couple of weeks, it's just been Broadway. I haven't seen Finn in a whole day which is a lot since he came back. I was still staying over at Finn's. We were practically living together. But he was busy with applying to NYU and doing some volunteering and I'm not complaining but I just wish we could spend more time together.

Today was a Sunday which meant; Just Finn and I.

I woke up lying beside Finn.

"Morning Babe"

"Good Morning", I said

"You know what would make this morning better?" Finn asked as he smiled like a Cheshire cat.

"What?" I asked.

"If my gorgeous and talented girlfriend accepted my invite to the finest restaurant in the city! Just me and her."

"That would be amazing. When do we leave?"

"Around 3. Be ready. Meet me here okay. Santana did call last night to see if you could come back for today around 11 and considering that it's 10, you need to get ready. ", he said.

"Aww...what would I do without you?" I said as I kissed him. Round 1 was coming up. (*wink *wink)

A few minutes later, Finn and I showered together and I got dressed to meet Santana. I threw on a pair of denim short shorts and wore my pink flowed tank with a white cardigan. I wore my flats, got my purse, kissed Finn goodbye and left the house.

I arrived at Santana's or what used to be my apartment and Kurt, Mercedes and Santana were there.

"Uh, Hi" I said. It was odd because they were giving me weird looks.

"My brother needs to keep you out of the house for a few hours so we decided to go through your clothes. And trust me Rachie, we did not find that much cute stuff. Some were ok, but some were, well", Kurt said and Santana finished his sentence.

"Some were clothes that looked like a toddler would wear and you're in New York Frikin City"

"So, Diva, Me, Kurt and Santana will take you to Times Square and we will shop until 2. After 2, you will get ready for your night out with Finn and we will take your new wardrobe back to our place."

"Really?" I asked. This was going to be an interesting day.

"Yup! Now let's go. The sooner we go, the more stuff we find" Santana said as she rushed us out of the house.

Shopping in Times Square had been really tiring. I had gotten a huge amount of clothes and it was only 1, which meant the shopping continues for an hour before they get me ready to see Finn.

"Rachel, come here and try this on" Santana said.

I went to Santana and found a short black dress in her hand. It was really short, that's for sure. But it had ruffles which made it really unique.

"Santana, that is amazing!"

"What can I say? A hot body needs to look hot."

Oh Santana.

It was finally 2 which meant, Kurtcedes and Santana needed to get me ready for Finn's date.

I wore this nice blue, elegant dress Santana gave me. I paired my gold heels with it. Mercedes fish-tail braided my hair to the side and Kurt did my makeup and I had to admit. I looked smokin' hot.

Right on time, I came to Finn's place and found him in a nice tux.

"Wow, Rachel. You look amazing." Finn smiled as he leaned to kiss me.

"So where are we going?"

"Well, first, we're going to the best vegan restaurant in the city and then, we're going to walk around."

"Sounds good." I said as we linked arms and walked out the door.

We arrived at the restaurant no later than 4. It was so amazing. Everything smelled delicious and even Finn enjoyed it. Just as we were about to leave, an unexpected visitor dropped by.

"Hey, whoa, Rachel. You're vegan"

"Didn't I mention that Caleb!" I said. It was the bloody Caleb. Why did he have to drop by tonight.

"And I'm guessing that's your boyfriend. Flint, right?"

"It's Finn and get out."

"Can't I enjoy lunch with a beautiful, talented lady?"

"Caleb, if you don't get out in..." I was talking as Finn interrupted me.

"What's going on?" Finn came and said.

"What's going on is that Caleb here won't stop flirting." I said.

"How come I've never heard of him?" Finn asked.

"He's not important." I said.

"Well, he knows you and I don't. I've never even heard of him" Finn said.

"Berry, why didn't you tell Finn about our lovely history" Caleb said winking.

"Caleb, Get. Out!" I yelled.
"Finn, he's not that important" I said to Finn. Caleb was on his way out.

"What's the history he was talking about? Huh! No lies." Finn said.

Oh My God!

"Well, the night when I saw you in New York for the first time, remember that. Me, Kurt and Santana were celebrating Santana's birthday. I got so wasted that night that I woke up at his place. He apparently knows Santana so he thought it would be perfectly fine to take me home."

"Wait, you woke up at his place?" Finn asked.

"Yes, but I was fully clothed. I assumed nothing had happened, so I came back home. And I met him again at the call-backs. We were duet partners and had to sing Endless Love. After that he...uh... tried to kiss me but I stopped him and he hasn't stopped flirting with me since then." I said.

"So he's flirting with you and he's not that important." he asked. I, Rachel Berry had messed up this time.

"I don't think he is" I said in a quiet voice.

"Would you like it if a girl was flirting with me and I didn't tell you about her?"

"No." I said quietly.

"Then why would you hide some guy from me. I thought you loved me..."

"And I do."

"Prove it!"

"I love you. I haven't stopped loving you and I will continue to love you for the rest of my life."

"Just give me some time." Finn said as he stormed out of the restaurant.

What have I done?