Thanks to all those who reviewed! I'm glad you guys are enjoying it so far!

Abigail 'Abby' Davis - Ellen Page
Olivia 'Libby' Davis - Ellen Page
Riley Davis - Hayden Christensen
Andrew Davis - Jeremy Irons

Devon Jacobson - Ian Somerhalder
Caitlyn Davis/Lilith - MeganFox
Unnamed Demon - Catherine Zeta-Jones
Unnamed Wizard - Wentworth Miller

Disclaimer - I do not own Harry Potter or Supernatural.

Chapter 10

Sam groaned as he was awoken by the sound of his cell phone ringing on the nightstand. He sat up and rubbed a hand over his face, glancing over at the other bed to see Dean still asleep, his face anything but peaceful. But since he had come back from hell, his expression was rarely ever peaceful anymore. Sam felt guilt twist in his gut. The incident with the siren had only been a few days prior, the small cut that Dean had made on his neck while poisoned by the venom was just beginning to heal and no matter how many times he told Dean that he hadn't mean anything he had said while they were being controlled by the venom Dean just wouldn't believe him.

With a heavy sigh, Sam reached over and grabbed the phone, pressing the talk button before putting it to his ear. "Hello?"

"Sam."

Sam frowned slightly when he recognized the voice on the other end of the call. "Riley. What's wrong?"

"It-it's Caitlyn," Riley responded. His voice was strained and the Auror sounded exhausted. "She's missing."

"She's what?" Sam asked, glancing over at the other bed as Dean stirred and glanced over at where Sam sat on the phone.

"She went to a skating rink in Houston the day before yesterday. When she still wasn't home yesterday, I went to investigate," Riley told him, his words rushed. "The rink ….it looks like a war zone and there was no sign of her anywhere. But that wasn't the worst thing that I found there."

If he hadn't found any sign of her, what had he found? What had Riley found that made him call Sam and Dean at, he glanced over at the motel alarm clock, four in the morning? "Riley, what did you find?"

"Sulfur. There was sulfur at the rink," Riley replied, sounding like he was out of breath.

Sam's furrowed brow disappeared and he glanced over at Dean, who was looking confused as he tried to keep up with one side of the conversation. "We should be there sometime this afternoon."

He heard Riley sigh in relief. "Thanks. See you soon."

Sam then hung up the phone and set it back down on the nightstand before pushing the covers off his legs. "That was Riley," he told Dean as he stood up and went to get his duffle from where it sat at the foot of the bed. "Caitlyn's missing and he found sulfur at the rink she disappeared from. And I guess the place looked like a war zone."

Sam moved about, pulling out clothes to change into. He heard no movement from Dean's bed and glanced over at him while pulling things out of his duffle to see Dean looking thoughtful. "You sure you want me coming since I'm holding you back and all."

Sam sighed and threw the clothes that were in his hand down onto the bed before turning to face Dean fully. "How many times do I have to tell you that it was the siren talking, not me."

Dean pushed the covers off and stood. "Whatever."

The Impala stopped in front of the ranch house just as the sun was sinking below the horizon. Sam and Dean climbed out of the Impala, the doors creaking as they closed them, and walked up to the front door. Once again, the front door opened before they could knock. Though instead of Libby standing there, it was an older man with graying hair and the same hazel eyes as Abby and Libby. He was as tall as Sam and wore the khaki uniform of a naval officer.

The man looked them up and down. "You must be Sam and Dean."

"Uh, yeah," Sam responded hesitantly. Who exactly was this man?

The man stepped aside and let them into the house. "Abby and Libby are in the kitchen," he told them as Sam and Dean walked past him and into the house. "Riley's at work but should be back soon."

He closed the front door behind them just as one of the twins came out of the kitchen. "Hey guys," she greeted with a small smile. She then turned towards the man. "And dinners almost ready Dad."

"Thanks Libby," he responded as she moved back into the kitchen. He then turned towards Sam and Dean and gave them a small smile. "Forgot to introduce myself. Andrew Davis."

Andrew then extended his hand towards the brothers and Sam was the first to take the offered hand, visibly shaking himself as he processed that the man before them was the father of Riley, Caitlyn, Abby, and Libby. "Nice to meet you sir."

Andrew chuckled as he extended his hand towards Dean. "Call me Andrew."

Dean gave a small grin and took the offered hand. "So you're not a wizard like Riley?"

Andrew shook his head as his arm dropped back down to his side. "Nah, I'm just an ordinary Muggle," he responded. "My wife Margret was a witch, though I didn't know that until after we were engaged."

The two brothers nodded as they took in what the man was telling them before Sam frowned slightly as he noticed something in Andrew's wording. "'Was?'"

The small smile the man had been wearing faded slowly. "She died about fourteen years ago. She was an Auror like Riley and Caitlyn are and that was always how she expected to go out," he told them, smiling sadly. "Wanted to go out with a bang. Sadly cancer got her before that could happen."

"Cancer? I thought magic would be able to take care of something like that," Dean commented. Or at least, it seemed like something the witches that they had previously come across could do. Though those witches were getting their powers from demons and not from something in their blood.

"There are some things that magic can fix," Abby said, causing three heads to turn towards where she stood in the doorway to the kitchen. "And some things that it can't unless you want to delve into the dark stuff and that always has a price tag on it," she told them before shaking her head and giving the three men a small smile. "Anyway, dinner is ready."

Seconds after she said this, the fireplace roared to life with bright emerald flames. From out of the flames stepped Riley who looked just as haggard as he had sounded when Sam had talked to him on the phone. Dark circles were under his eyes and he looked to be in desperate need of a shave.

"Just in time, Ri. Dinner's ready," Abby told him as he dusted soot off of his clothes.

"Great," he responded, his voice monotone.

Abby sighed and exchanged a glance with her father and leaned against the doorframe. "No luck?"

Riley heaved a heavy sigh and ran a hand through his hair. "None whatsoever," he replied. "And I've been put on leave. I'm apparently too emotional and seeing things that aren't real."

"Robertson?" Andrew asked. Sam and Dean glanced towards him as he spoke. Andrew noticed this and mouthed to them 'His boss.'

Riley nodded. "Yeah. Anyway," he began, turning his attention towards Sam and Dean. "Thanks for coming. I was thinking of maybe heading over to the rink after dinner so you guys can take a look around."

Sam nodded. "Alright."

Dean glanced over at Sam for a moment before nodding as well. "Yeah."

"Couldn't you get, oh I don't know, fired for that?" Libby asked as she came to stand in the doorway beside her twin.

Riley shrugged. "So?"

Libby pursed her lips and exchanged a glance with her twin. "Well alright then. We're in."

"Guys-"

"Nope! Not up for discussion," Abby told him as she pushed herself away from the doorway and moved around her twin, heading into the kitchen.

"Yeah. Now come feed your face before the food gets cold," Libby added before turning and following her sister into the kitchen.

The Aerodrome Ice Skating Complex had been closed for reasons unknown to the public while Aurors worked to figure out what happened at the rink. Though by eight in the evening all Aurors on duty had gone home and all that was left were a few charms on the building that would alert Auror headquarters if anyone was to cast a spell within the building. The only light in the building was provided by the emergency flood lights that provided just enough to see by.

POP!

"What the hell was that?" Dean yelled, pulling his arm from Riley's grasp and gaping at the man. His skin was pale and he looked about ready to vomit. Sam didn't look like he was ready to vomit, he was vomiting. As soon as they had appeared in front of the concession stand at the rink, he had quickly pulled free of Libby's grip on his arm and proceeded to empty the contents of his stomach into the nearest trash can.

Riley cringed as he heard Sam vomit. "That would be Apparition. It's kind of like teleporting basically."

"Well, we are not Appriting or whatever back," Dean told him, glancing over at Sam as he pulled his head out of the trashcan and wiped his mouth.

"Holy shit," Abby muttered as she and Libby approached the wall around the ice or rather what was left of the wall and the glass.

Dean's eyes moved away from Sam and to the ice and his eyebrows shot up on his forehead. The place looked like a disaster area. There wasn't much of the wall that went around the ice left and the same went for the glass. Chucks of ice littered the rink around the holes that had been blasted in the ice.

"Riley, where did you find the sulfur?" Sam asked as he approached the ice, taking in the destruction.

"On the ice," Riley replied as he stepped over the remains of part of the wall, Sam, Dean, Abby, and Libby following him as he moved across the ice, avoiding the holes and chunks that littered the once smooth surface.

"Here," he said as he stopped just before the doors where the Zamboni got onto the ice to smooth it. It was here that one of the few panes of glass still intact was and just against the wall was a yellow powder that Sam and Dean immediately recognized even in the dim lighting.

"It looks like she put up one hell of a fight against whoever took her," Dean commented as he looked at the sulfur that was against the base of the wall.

"That she did," said a voice from behind them.

The group turned towards the voice to spot none other than Devon Jacobson standing in the center of the rink, grinning at them.

"Devon," Riley growled as he twisted his wrist and his wand appeared in his hand. Abby and Libby pulled out their wands as Sam and Dean pulled their guns out from the back waistband of their pants and switched off the safeties.

"So you're the Devon we've heard so much about," Dean commented as he assessed the young wizard standing at center ice. "Have to say, you're more of a douche then I expected."

"Oh, I'd know that voice anywhere," said a familiar feminine voice. Out from behind Devon stepped Caitlyn, who wore a sadistic grin.

"Caitlyn?" Riley gasped.

Her eyes flickered towards him for a moment before focusing once more on Sam and Dean as behind her a young man with a buzz cut and a wand in his hand stepped up behind Devon alongside a woman with dark wavy hair and a low cut top. "Hello Dean."

"Riley, that's not Caitlyn," Sam told the Auror, glancing over at him just as Caitlyn's eyes went completely white. "It's Lilith."

"Get out of my sister you bitch," Libby growled as she aimed her wand towards the demon and a beam of red light shot from its tip. Lilith waved her hand and the light disappeared. In her hand was Caitlyn's wand.

She held up the wand before her and studied it. "I never knew possessing a witch could be so fun."

"GET OUT OF HER!" Libby screamed before sending another spell towards Lilith, who easily countered it with a spell that sent Libby flying back into the wall.,

"LIBBY!" Abby and Riley yelled in unison before both sending spells towards Lilith, only to be intercepted by Devon and the wizard they had yet to know the name of. Sam and Dean fired off shots towards Lilith only for them to be stopped by the dark haired woman, who eyes flashed back as she approached the brothers.

The next few minutes were chaos. The air was filled with shouts, spells, and bullets as the two groups fought on the ice. Riley fought Devon, Libby fought Lilith, Abby fought the wizard that she knew not the name of while Sam and Dean fought to the black eyed demon and tried to get past her to help the Davis siblings but just as they got the upper hand against her, loud cracks rang through the rink as Auror's appeared around them as well as Lilith in Caitlyn's body screeching a single spell above all the noise.

"AVADA KEDAVRA!"