Meanwhile upstairs, Rachel and Finn argued. "Rachel I want you. Why is that so hard to believe? Why can't you just trust me when I say I love you?" Finn shouted.
"Finn, why should I believe you? You're a liar. Besides I don't care if you want me or love me! I'm with Noah and I wouldn't want it any other way!" Rachel yelled back in anger. She had never been this angry before and she visibly trembled as Finn approached her, almost stalking her.
"Rach I need you. My life has been miserable without you. I want you." Finn muttered as he grabbed onto her arms and pulled her close.
Rachel was terrified and yelled, "No Finn, stop it. I don't want this! Stop please."
As he placed his lips gently against hers Noah burst through the door shouting, "Get your hands off my wife asshole!"
Finn backed away from Rachel and prepared for a fight. Noah squared his shoulders and dropped into a fighting stance ready to defend the woman he loves. Seeing the two men acting like children caused something to break inside of Rachel and she finally snapped. She was tired of Noah and Finn fighting with each other, and she was tired of being fought over. Rachel was not a prize to be won; she was a married woman for crying out loud! Tonight she would find a way to make the guys realize that or she would walk out on both of them.