(AN:) I think this chapter seems rushed, but I guess that's up to you guys to tell me.

Disclaimer: I do not own iCarly, or Madisen Hill.

"Hey, Melanie, where did you put my...?"

Sam walked into her sisters room about to ask her where she placed all of her shoes when something surprised her.

"W-What are you doing?" Sam asked.

"Getting ready," Melanie answered as she applied red eye shadow to match her summer corset dress. "I'm heading out for a little while."

"But I thought you wanted to go grocery shopping together?" Sam questioned as her sister walked around her and headed downstairs to the front door.

"How about we go later?" Melanie suggested before opening the front door.

"Where are you going then?" Sam asked when her sister opened the door and walked out.

"I'm going to meet an old friend," Melanie answered over her right shoulder. "I'll be back soon!"

"But Mel!" Sam yelled, but she didn't come back. She just waved her hand in the air and crossed the street.

Sam knew something was going on. Why would Melanie go to meet an old friend? What old friend did she have here besides Carly? All Sam knew was that she was going to get to the bottom of this.

First she had to find her other shoe.

"Are you sure you're doing the right thing?" Madisen just had to ask when she and Freddie were walking together to the park. They still had about twenty minutes before they were going to meet up with Melanie, so the two decided to just take a stroll.

"Think about it, Madisen, who knows Sam more than me?" Freddie asked.

"Carly," Madisen answered.

"Okay, true, but who's last name is also Puckett?" Freddie cleared.

"Her...sister?"

"Her twin sister," Freddie corrected. "Melanie probably knows more about Sam than I do."

"But you said they barley talk to each other," Melanie reminded. "I mean, you said Sam hated her."

"I even said she hated her mother, but that's not true," Freddie said.

Madisen sighed. "I still just don't understand why you can't go up to Sam and express your feelings the old fashion way."

"Because I want to make this something she'll remember the rest of her life," Freddie honestly answered, shrugging his shoulders.

"I need to make you stop watching so many romantic movies," Madisen thought out loud and Freddie laughed.

"Freddie, over here!"

Freddie and Madisen both turned around and saw someone waving at them.

"Oh, no, it's Sam," Madisen panicked. "Do you think she heard us talking?"

"She's over there; how do you think she heard us?" Freddie asked as he was waving back at the blonde who started walking towards the two.

"What do we do? We can't let her see us when Melanie comes," Madisen said behind her forced smile.

When the blonde got closer, Freddie saw the outfit she was wearing and took a sigh of relief.

"Oh, good, there's nothing to worry about," Freddie said, taking a seat on the bench.

"What do you mean 'there's nothing to worry about'?" Madisen repeated. "Don't you see the girl walking towards us?"

"Hey guys."

Madisen screamed. "Don't do that!" Madisen said, placing a hand on her chest to calm her heartbeats.

"Oh, sorry."

"Nice going, Mel," Freddie commented and Melanie did a small bow.

"Melanie?" Madisen questioned, looking at the girl standing next to her. "But this is Sam."

"Correction," Melanie said, sticking out her hand to shake with Madisen's. "I'm Sam's twin sister."

"Oh," Madisen laughed, shaking her hand. "Wow, you guys look exactly the same!"

"That's what being twins is all about," Melanie said.

"Anyways, I'm glad you could make it," Freddie started a new conversation, getting up from the bench and shoving his hands in his pocket.

"I wouldn't miss a second date with Fredward Benson in the world," Melanie joked, throwing her hands up in mid-air with a smile.

"I'm afraid I'm playing the girlfriend part here," Madisen said, linking her arm around Freddie's.

"Aw, Freddie!" Melanie whined.

"I'm sorry, I'm sorry," Freddie apologized. "But that's not the important thing right now. The important thing is that I need your help."

"Oh, I already knew that. You want to woo Sam with your," she air quoted, "'cuteness' so she could fall in love with you."

"That's one way of putting it," Freddie observed.

"Making her jealous is not a great idea," Melanie shared.

"Told you!" Madisen yelled, hitting Freddie's arm and he yelped in pain. "Girls don't like it!"

"There's only one thing that makes her weak," Melanie continued, grinning.

Freddie and Madisen both looked at each other before looking at her. Freddie's eyes grew wide, "What is it?" He walked up to the blonde and placed both hands on each side of her shoulders. "What? I'll pretty much do anything."

"Even..." Melanie paused, looking from Freddie, to Madisen and then back to Freddie. "...Sing?"

Freddie's arms dropped. He then brought one hand up to his chin and asked, "Did I ever mention how much I hate Sam?"

"Don't tell me you've never done it before," Madisen giggled. "The Fredward Benson has never sung before?"

"I have too sang!" Freddie said, crossing his arms over his chest. "Just never to anyone for whatever reason. Maybe I sang to my parents when I was little, but that's it."

"Well, if you really want Sam's heart to melt you're going to have to sing," Melanie spoke. "And that's really all I can help you with. Now, if you'll excuse me I have to get back home before Sam gets suspicious since we need to go shopping."

"Wait, Melanie," Freddie called after her when she turned around and took a few steps away.

The twin turned around, her hair flipping to her back. Freddie ran up to her in case anyone they knew heard them.

"Can you do me another favor and be a spy?" Freddie asked. "I want to know what happens at home."

Melanie shrugged. "I don't see why not."

"Great," Freddie smiled, giving Melanie a hug. "Thanks so much for this! Oh, and welcome back."

Melanie laughed, patting Freddie's back. "You're welcome." She broke away from the hug. "If one Puckett can't have you, then the other one can."

Freddie shook his head and lightly pushed her away, still laughing.

"Keep in touch," Melanie said before turning around and walking back home.

"Do you think singing will work?" Madisen joked, hoping up next to Freddie and smacking her hip against his.

"I'm not going to sing, let's get one thing straight," Freddie shook a finger at her.

"But that's the only way for you to-." Madisen tried explaining, but Freddie brought a hand up to make her stop as he walked away. "Freddie, you have to!" The brunette screamed as she ran after him. "It's the only way!"

When the two were long gone, Sam finally stepped out from behind a tree far from where the three were standing. She was crushed when seeing that her sister was just here with the two and hugging Freddie. After everything Sam told Melanie - she double crossed her?

Sam needed to drown her feelings in food.

At least she didn't hear what the three were talking about. Her guts told her that she wasn't going to like it.

Sam thought she could have trusted Melanie. Oh, that girl was going to talk. Sam didn't care if she had to beat up her sister for it, but she was going to talk and explain what she was doing with Freddie and Madisen.