Back in the story, Chief Swiss Cheese's daughters were asleep as Samuel, Rudy, and Melvin were around a fireplace.
"Chief Swiss Cheese's daughters were sleeping, but the guys were still awake." Narrated GDN.
Samuel smiled.
"Those daughters of the chief are beautiful." Samuel said.
"I agree. I for one am glad Jim dragged us on this adventure." Melvin said.
"Yep. Plus the Indians are nice." Rudy said.
"And they know how to invent things, just like me." said Samuel.
"Yeah." The guys said.
They then look at the village.
"Plus there is something called a movie theater here that is cool." Samuel said.
Jim and Polly appeared in front of the group, shocking them.
"Jim? Polly? What are you doing here?" said Melvin.
"We've got to take back the ship." said Jim.
"Yeah I don't think so." said Rudy.
Jim became confused.
"Why not?" said Jim.
"We just met some of the hottest babes on the island." said Melvin.
Jim looked at the sleeping girls and became annoyed.
"Seriously? You come on this Island to find the treasure, encounter Indians instead, and fall in love? I'm guessing you want to stay on the Island and forget about the Inn." said Jim.
"Yeah, pretty much." said Samuel.
Jim decided to do something about it.
"You leave me no choice, but to use your weakness." said Jim.
He pulled out a box of Cheez-Itz.
"Cheez-Itz?" said Jim.
The other guy's eyes started spinning around and they followed Jim out of the tribe. They soon reached a boat and Jim put the box of Cheez-Itz away, stopping the other guy's trance.
"Great, he did it again." said Samuel.
"He does it all the time." said Melvin.
"Whatever, get in the boat." said Jim.
"OK." The three friends said sad.
In the real world Gosalyn was sad and GDN saw this.
"Hey I know the three friends met their dream girls but they will be back." He said.
"They'd better." Said Gosalyn.
Back in the story, the group was rowing the boat and Jim told the group everything.
"You mean to tell me that we went on this journey to find treasure that doesn't even exist?" said Rudy.
"Of course it exists; Billy Bones confirmed that it does exist. The Indians must have found the treasure, took it back to their place, and reburied the chests." Said Jim.
"Even if this treasure does exist, we've got to stop those pirates and put them in jail." Said Samuel.
Melvin pulled out a telescope and saw through it.
"What do you see Melvin?" said Jim.
"Lots of water." Said Melvin.
The others became annoyed.
"How about something less obvious." Said Samuel.
"I can see Mr. Arrow." Said Melvin.
The group became shocked.
"What?! Give me that." Rudy took the telescope and put his eye on it, "Holy moly, it is Mr. Arrow."
Jim is shocked.
"How is that possible?" He asked.
"No idea." Polly said, "But after seeing that the Indians are advanced, I am not surprised."
They reached Mr. Arrow and pulled him into the boat. They did CPR on him until the First Mate came back.
"What happened?" said Mr. Arrow.
"We'll tell you about it as soon as we reach the ship." Said Rudy.
The group reached the ship, snuck on it and told Mr. Arrow everything.
Mr. Arrow is shocked to say the least.
"Most of the pirates are already looking for the treasure and Long John is behind all of this?" said Mr. Arrow.
"Yeah. But we've got the advantage against them, because they think that you're dead." Said Melvin, "By the way, how are you still alive?"
"No idea. All I could say is that none of the sharks ate me." Said Mr. Arrow.
"I think it's because you need a bath." Said Samuel.
Mr Arrow smelled himself and knew Samuel was right.
"Good point." He said, "Also what is that parrot doing here?"
"I sided with these people." Said Polly.
In the ship, Reggie, Sam, Matthew, and Paul were still tied to the mast.
"How long have we been on this mast?" said Sam.
Paul looked at the sun.
"Two hours." Said Paul.
"If only we could find a way to get rid of these pirates." Said Reggie.
The pirates are laughing.
"Oh yeah soon we will have the treasure and be rich." A random pirate said.
"Yeah and I can open up a dress shop." Another pirate said.
All the pirates are shocked.
"What I like helping girls pick out a nice dress. I am not afraid to admit it." He said.
Back at the mast, Jim's group managed to untie the others and hid in the storage area. Reggie, Sam, Matthew, and Paul were surprised to see Mr. Arrow.
"Still alive?" said Sam.
"Don't ask." Said Mr. Arrow.
"Stand by for makeup Mr. Arrow." Said Samuel.
Melvin pulled out a huge pillow full of powder and slammed it on Mr. Arrow so many times until he was completely white. The group covered him in seaweed and wrapped chains around him.
"It's show time." Said Rudy.
Mr. Arrow walked on deck and started doing ghostly wails to get the pirates attention.
"I am the ghost of Mr. Arrow, here to haunt everyone on this ship." Said Mr. Arrow.
The pirates started to shiver in fear.
"Boo." Said Mr. Arrow.
The pirates screamed like little girls and jumped off the ship, much to everyone's shock.
"Huh, that was easy." Said Samuel.
"I know." Jim said.
Polly laughed.
"Those pirates were always chickens when it came to ghosts and stuff." Polly said and sees Samuel, Rudy and Melvin shocked, "What got you three shocked?"
"Those pirates didn't even put up a fight." Said Rudy.
"Who cares, the ship is ours once again." Said Reggie.