This chapter is mostly Fuinn centric with a splash of Puckleberry lol enjoy
They met at Rachel's house that afternoon, Puck and Finn sat down on the couch while Rachel baked cookies for everyone. "OK bro let's look at the situation here, So Quinn is with Sam and according to Jewfro's blog Sam gave her a promise ring before the Hummel's wedding." Puck said a little disgusted he had to resort to looking at that creepers blog just to get some info. "And she accepted it? Aw man this is hopeless, he's like...I dunno the perfect Ken doll boyfriend or something." Finn frowned and slumped back on the couch. "Dude nothing is hopeless, you can win her back." Puck reassured him as Rachel walked into the living room with a plate of cookies.
"I suggest just talking to her Finn, I could invite her over now if you'd like?" Rachel said before sitting down beside Puck. "Don't try to get her to break up with Sam, just explain to her how you feel." She continued and Puck nodded in agreement. "Yeah dude I know from experience, nothing sucks worse than being in love with someone while they're in a relationship with somebody else. Maybe if I would've told her a long time ago at least how I felt about her, I wouldn't have been as miserable as I was." Finn thought about it for a bit and then he let out a nervous sigh. "OK Rach, call her."
Rachel invited Quinn over under the ruse that it would just be the two of them. When Quinn arrived Rachel met her at the door and told her to go up the her room and she'd meet her in a minute. When Quinn walked into the room Finn was there waiting for her. "Finn? What on earth are you doing here, Rachel didn't say..." Finn cut her off. "That's because I told her not to, I needed to talk to you...alone." He fidgeted nervously. "Oh, um...OK. What did you want to talk about?" She questioned before taking a seat on Rachel's bed.
Finn gained a little confidence and started to speak. "Last year when we were dating I thought it was only because it was the popular thing to do. I really cared about stuff like that back then, I had to be liked by everybody. The quarterback, the most popular guy in school with the hot head cheerio as his girlfriend. After I joined glee club though all that changed, and I started to care about other things. Being popular didn't matter much to me anymore and after I started dating Rachel things started to become clearer and clearer." Quinn listened to him, she was slightly confused but she assumed there was a point. "You see I thought I was in love with Rachel, but when she broke up with me I realized that there was someone else I've been in love with for a long time. Seeing the way Puck feels about Rachel made me realize I feel the exact same way about you Quinn."
Quinn's eyes widened in surprise and she started to speak. "Finn I..." He held up his hand to stop her. "Wait..let me just..get this off of my chest.." He took another deep breath. "I thought I just wanted you because you were hot and popular, but I realized that you are the love of my life. When I see you my heart starts beating all fast and stuff and my ears get really hot. I feel weak, and I used to just think I was sick when it would happen but Rach and Puck explained that's what love feels like to some people. I'm not trying to steal you away from Sam, please don't think that..I...I just wanted to tell you how I feel. I do't care about what happened last year, I'm glad it did. I wish I was your first time..I wish the baby really was mine." Quinn had started crying by this point and Finn was trying not to freak out. "Oh crap Quinn, don't cry...uh, um..just forget I said anything I was stupid I.." She cut him off with a kiss.
Finn was caught off guard, was she really kissing him? It felt so amazing, he remembered everything about her lips. How soft they were, the taste, he could do this forever, but he knew he had to stop it. Gently he pushed her away but kept his hands on her shoulders. "I love you Quinn, but...you're with Sam and I can't do the same thing to him that Puck did to me. I don't want you to choose me just because of what I said, I just want you to be happy." He smiled sadly and kissed her forehead before walking past her and out of the room. She immediately broke down into heavy sobs and Rachel rushed in to comfort her.
Puck got Finn out of there and back to his house. "Damn dude, what the hell did you say to here? She was crying a river back there." Finn frowned and went over his conversation with Quinn. "Well she wouldn't have kissed you if she didn't feel the same, but I'm proud of you for stopping it. God knows I wouldn't have." He sighed still feeling a little guilty until Finn smacked him on the back. "Quit it with that dude, I told you I'm not mad about that stuff anymore. The first one was a drunken accident and I'm glad you got Rachel, she's perfect for you and it just made me realize the feelings I have for Quinn. It sucks that I made her cry though, I didn't want that to happen, I just thought she'd blow me off. I didn't expect her to kiss me or anything.."
Back at Rachel's house Quinn sobbed and told Rachel what happened. "I don't know what to do, I...I love him too so much but I love Sam too. I can't hurt him, but I don't want to hurt Finn either. I've hurt him so much already, it's so unfair." She cried and Rachel rubbed her back soothingly. "You just have to ask yourself who do love the most, who would you be the happiest with. He just wants you to be happy Quinn." Rachel said softly while trying to calm Quinn. "I know, he told me. Rachel there's only one way to decide this and I need your help to do it."
A few things, Sorry it took me so long to update I've been incredibly busy. Sorry it's so short, the next one will be much longer and hopefully I caught all the typos and whatnot this time. :) Please Review I really need your feedback.