It was nighttime, and everyone (Except for Sherman, Edmund, Mabel, Penny, and Ford) were in their cubbies, and Gumball was seen walking towards the bathroom. An ascot wearing Dipper noticed.
"A little late for a stroll, isn't it, Mr. Watterson?" Dipper then said.
"That's Mr. Gumball Watterson, you Star sighting dork!" Gumball insulted as he's surrounded by Jimmy, Dipper, and Baby Doll.
Meanwhile, in the front office, 2 toys were watching this, Mordecai and Rigby, and by watching this, I mean lazing around while playing video games as their friends continued to keep an eye on the room.
"Mordecai! Rigby!" Benson yelled. "Get over here!"
"Ugh!" Rigby groaned. "Those toys aren't going anywhere!"
"It doesn't matter, what if an escape plan started?" Benson groans as he rolls his eyes.
"You're becomin' a trouble maker, aren't you?" Dipper then said. "You think you could just waltz outta here?"
"And I would've gotten away with it too, if it weren't for you meddling kids!" Gumball then said, tauntingly, "Ya ascot-wearin' pink-noser! Mr. Brains-Sold-Separately!"
"Take him to the sandbox." Dipper then said, nonchalantly. Tommy grabs Gumball and leaves the room.
Back in the caterpillar room, Dipper noticed Pacifica waving at him. Dipper rolled his eyes and walked over. Then, Jimmy saw someone running in the shadows. Jimmy took a close look, and it was none other than Dexter running, Jimmy ran after him.
"What do you want?" Dipper said, rolled his eyes.
"I can't take it here anymore! I want to go to the butterfly room with you, Dipper!" Pacifica said, tearfully.
"You should've thought of that earlier." Dipper then said.
"I was wrong! I wanna be with you, Dipper Pines! Take me away from this! Take me away!" Pacifica pleaded, crying. Of course, the guilt trip got Dipper, no man is a match for a girlfriend's tears.
"Darn it, Pacifica. All right, you can come, but make sure you do as I say!" Dipper then said, he then opens the cubby, and unbeknownst to Dipper, Pacifica winks to the audience, smiling.
Meanwhile, in the butterfly room, Dexter runs, but Jimmy gets a hold of him, and throws him to a Lego Building, which breaks into pieces.
Dexter slowly gets up in pain as he said, "It's time you learn what it means to be a man."
"Dexter, please." Jimmy said, annoyed and in the feeling of urgancy. "You have to listen to me! Cipher wants us..."
Dexter refused to listen as he threw a Lego brick at Jimmy, which he punches out of his way.
"You don't understand! THERE'S NO TIME!" Jimmy said, impatiently.
"I UNDERSTAND!" Dexter shouted as he thew another punch, only to be thrown to a playtime castle as the fight goes on.
Meanwhile at the playground, the moonlight shined on the playground as Stan carried Gumball into the sandbox. He tosses Gumball in and lowers the lid, causing it to close the sandbox.
As Tommy walks off, there was a wood knot moving in the side of the box. It pops out, falls to the ground. Gumball's hand emerges, clutching his eye. It looks around. One by one, Gumball's parts fly out the hole and land on the ground next to the sandbox.
Back at the caterpillar room, unnoticed, Spongebob runs to the middle of the room.
Sherman, Mabel, Edmund, Penny and Ford grab a bag of marbles and a clothesline to use it as a lever rope.
Ford lowers the clothesline thanks to the bag of marbles' weight enough for him to reach the waiting Spongebob. The toy drops the bag itself and grabs his friend just in time for the two of them to send back to the ceiling.
Muscle Man and High Five Ghost sat at their post, staring madly at the security monitors in the office. The only sound in there is a ticking clock. Brain was back at the Library.
However, what Muscle Man doesn't know is that a familiar couple drops into view behind him holding a bag with Spongebob holding them by the ankles, lowering his friends head first. Ford watches from the crawl space above them.
"Okay, start swinging." Ford said quietly to Spongebob. The slinky toy nods as he begins swinging Sherman, Edmund and Mabel closer to Muscle Man, ready to grab him and stuff the rat right in there. However, Muscle Man frowns as he notices a reflection in the monitor.
Muscle Man screams from noticing intruders behind him! Sherman, Penny and Spongebob scream as they were about to crash by accident
Sherman accidentally knocks into Muscle Man with Penny and Spongebob falling with him which knocked the mike away and onto the floor.
The Park toys and Sherman look to each other from noticing the mike a few feet from them. Skips proceeds to growl at Sherman. Then, Benson and the others ran over to the mike, only for Mabel and Edmund to catch them in a chokehold.
Muscle Man growls as he said, "You know who else loves to get Heatbutted in the face?!"
"What?" Mabel asks, annoyed.
"My...mom!" Muscle Man replies as he headbutts Mabel in the face.
"THAT DOESN'T EVEN MAKE ANY SENSE!" Mabel shouted as she covered her nose.
Benson seems to be close to the mike until Sherman pulls the mike's cord and gets him hogtied.
Sherman tackles him but Benson clapped his cymbals against Sherman's ears and swung himself backwards 'till he landed on Sherman's back!
"Don't make me kill you!"
Benson proceeded to angrily bash Sherman with his cymbals to get Sherman unconsious enough to the point where he won't be a problem anymore.
"Go... Get... The... Tape!" Sherman uttered out his words between each bash, but he manages to signal Spongebob, Edmund and Penny to get the tape on the desk which the Sponge slinky toy got in his mouth and started rushing down to his friend in need with Mabel to accompany him.
Benson then yelped as Penny and Mabel whacked Benson with Spongebob being used like a Nunchuck.
Skips then intervened as he grabs the 3 kid toys and tried to end it, but Ford intervenes as he starts a fight with Skips.
Meanwhile, Pacifica and Dipper went to Dipper's Dreamhouse back in the Butterfly room. The 2 rode the elevator to the top floor as Dipper opens the door to show a special collection to surprise Pacifica.
"And Welcome to Magic Hour." Dipper said with a smirk as he shows the living room which has racks of clothes lining the wall. Pacifica gasps in shock and amazement.
"Look at all your clothes!" Pacifica grinned. "Tennis in Wimbleton...*gasp*...Northwest Mansion Noir!"
"Yeah, yeah, no big deal.." Dipper frowns as he turns away, thinking that Pacifica's still infuriated about what happened yesterday. "Nobody appreciates clothes and modeling! Nobody!"
"I do..." Pacifica then said, happily.
Dipper blushes as he knows how this will go down.
Dipper emerges from behind a screen, sporting some of the most insane Dipper outfits ever - '90s, '80s, '70s, even 1960s - with matching accessories. Dipper strikes just the right pose for each outfit - slinging a jacket over his shoulder; doing "The Frug" in a fringe vest; polka-ing in Lederhosen; scuba moves; break dancing. Pacifica sits watching, enthralled. She laughs, claws her hand, and growls like a cat. Finally, she applauds wildly. Dipper grins to the audience - exceptionally pleased with himself.
Meanwhile back at the Butterfly room, the deluded CIA Apprentice toy was having enough of this charade. Dexter just doesn't know when to give up.
"Stay down!" Jimmy said, losing some patience. "If I wanted it, you'd be dead already!"
"You're not brave." Dexter said, angrily.
The 2 action figures go at each other and Jimmy throws a punch, only for Dexter to catch it, taking the boy genius toy by surprise.
"Men are brave." Dexter replies, blocking every punch and kick that Jimmy threw before Dexter threw counter punches of his own that managed to hit his target. After a while, Dexter proceeded to punch the boy genius toy so hard, it got him sent to a bean bag. As soon as Jimmy got up, the 2 continued to fight.
Dipper leaps from behind the screen in a Karate Gi and does a series of fighting moves, kicking and punching the air. He freezes mid-pose as soon as he notices something. Pacifica isn't there. Where did she go? Pacifica leaps out of nowhere, tackling Dipper as he lands on his chest. Pacifica grabs his head, and spins it 180 degrees.
"No more games, Dipper. What did Timmy do to Jimmy, and how do we get him back?" Pacifica angrily said.
Dipper is secretly thrilled to have Pacifica straddling his chest, talking tough. He defiantly speaks, "You can't make me talk! You can't!"
Pacifica glares at him, eyes narrowing in anger as Stinky and Sid and Gerald entered the room, smirking evilly.
Dipper- unable to contain his excitement - blurts out, "...But I'd like to see you try!"
Sherman and Ford finish taping up the struggling PInky. Penny opens a desk drawer. Ford rolls the rat in. Spongebob pushes it closed. Sherman runs to a bulletin board above the desk. Where's the key? He finds the keys, buried under push-pinned papers. Spongebob toggles a security camera joystick.
Back in the caterpillar room, Jimmy and Dexter were still fighting.
Dexter then threw something, a fake grenade, and then, Jimmy, unscathed, ran at Dexter and punched him.
Jimmy then walked towards Dexter.
"Are you kidding me? Do you want to be killed?!" Jimmy then said.
"Jimmy, you're not going to kill me." Dexter then said,
Jimmy looks up. Cindy #2, Gompers, Gerald, Arnold and Helga stand on a bookcase above him, holding an empty, clear plastic toy bin. They leap, slamming the bin over Jimmy. Gene and Toothless leap on top of it, pinning it to the floor.
Jimmy fires his laser in a circle at the side of the bin. He charges at the wall, hits it, and falls over.
Wolfgang and Gerald head to a locker, and Wolfgang pulls out a lunch box. Cindy opens it. Inside was Harold Berman, who pretty much ate everything except a tortilla. Cindy grabs it, dashes to the door, slides it under. She knocks and runs off.
The tortilla lays outside. From the shadows, one of Gumball's arms appears, crawls over, grabs the tortilla, and drags it into the darkness. One by one, the parts implant themselves in the tortilla. The Tortilla stands unsteadily, looks around, blinks, then heads off across the playground.
Meanwhile in the halls, a Security truck patrols the hall. As it passes, the office door opens. Penny peers out.
Ford is poised with a key attached to a rubber-band sling shot. Spongebob pulls it back. Sherman signals "Go!" Slinky releases the slingshot. It shoots the key under the door, across the hall and into the Caterpillar Room.
Cindy stops the key with her boot, picks it up.
Gumball hoists himself up a tricycle and onto a classroom window ledge. He peers in. Inside the Butterfly Room, Timmy is asleep. Gumball turns and uses the trike's mirror to catch a moonbeam.
Dani, on the sill by the door, sees the signal. She uses the key to unlock the door. The other toys slip outside. As a SPOTLIGHT sweeps past, they duck behind a traffic cone then creep off across the playground.
Dipper wasn't so lucky as he finds himself tied to a paddle-ball paddle back in his house. The toy was forced to watch Pacifica and the others go through his clothes. What is she gonna do?
"Ah...New England Patriots Swim Trunks." Pacifica then said, chuckling darkly.
"Too bad they ain't Denver." Stinky said as he tore them apart real fast.
"Oh, come on! Those were vintage!" Dipper cries out, but he can't give up! "They're a dime a dozen anyway!"
Pacifica then took a noir tux as Sid the Snitch rips it up with his bare hands like a lawnmower cutting the lawn.
"Who cares, right? No big deal! Sequins are so tacky nowadays anyway!"
Then, Dipper gasps in horror as soon as Pacifica took out a Boston Red Sox Jacket, the one from 2004.
"No, Pacifica! Not that! Not the jacket from Boston!" Dipper exclaimed in terror. That jacket is one of his favorite clothes to wear!
"Hmmm? This is what; from 2004?"
"Yes, yes, the World Series Collection, yeah!"
"Aw, what a pity. Looks like it won't be anymore." Pacfica said in amusement.
Dipper then sobbed uncontrollably, "All right, all right; there's an instruction manual for Jimmy! Timmy Turner and his goons use it to switch him to Demo Mode!"
"Good. Now where's that manual, and who has it now?"
The Brain yawned as he handed a certain toy dressed as an astronaut Jimmy's instruction booklet.
"I don't know why this couldn't wait til' morning, Dip, but it better be important." The Brain said, annoyed.
Dipper salutes Brain before he heads off. The Brain then notices that Dipper is wearing...white female boots?
Disgusted, Brain asks, "Pinky, are you pondering what I'm pondering?"
"Well, I think so brain, but how is Tom Brady going to win another Super Bowl without Cheating?" Pinky replied, clueless.
"No, Pinky. As much as that statement is true, I think DIpper has one weird habit." Brain then said.