Way back
"Get the fuck off her." Finn fumed at the man on top of Rachel.
"Why don't you get out? This is my apartment." The man said.
"Finn, can you please not do this?" Rachel said.
"Can I please just talk to you outside?" He asked her.
"Fine Finn." Rachel said pushing Caleb off her and walking out the door.
"You can't be with him." He said once the door finally closed.
"Do what? Finn I love him." She said.
"No you love me and I love you, so come home."
"Two months ago you told me to get out because you didn't love me anymore."
"Well I was stupid and I was lying."
"I love Caleb, Finn we can't be together anymore we're done."
"We're never done Rach you know that, we're tethered."
"I'm staying here."
"Ill wait then. Ill always wait for you."
"Whatever you want Finn." She said turning around and walking back into the apartment, he'll get her back. They're tethered she always comes back, whether that Caleb douche exists or not.
They'll find their way back to each other.