"I'm going to somewhat keep up the nice streak and let Kol talk again," Katherine said, since Kol had been dared to not speak until his next turn. "Kol, truth or dare?"
"Dare," Kol said happily.
"I dare you to hold hands with Klaus until your next turn," Katherine said with a giant smirk.
"Seriously?" Kol asked in a whining tone as he very unhappily grabbed the hand of the brother sitting next to him. "At least I can talk now, though."
Caroline took a shot as Klaus rolled his eyes even though he clearly was just as unimpressed with the idea as his brother was.
"Doppelgangers, truth or dare?" Kol asked.
"Dare," Elena responded, knowing that Katherine's choice would be the same.
"I dare you two to leave the room together and when you come back you have to find a way to confuse the rest of us all until we all unanimously vote that you're each other. And if we all vote right then you have to leave and then come back and try again until you fool us," Kol told them.
Elena and Katherine got up and walked into Rebekah's bedroom together before closing the door behind them so that no one would be able to listen in. As they left, Caroline took another shot.
"Most of them already know how to tell when I'm acting like you," Katherine said as soon as the door was closed. "So we should both to pretend to be me."
After a few minutes, the two doppelgangers entered the room side by side wearing matching facial expressions. Each had straight hair and matching Katherine style makeup. They had half switched clothes so that each was wearing a little bit of the other's clothing as well as their own. Both girls had a significant amount of cleavage showing and their breasts pushed up.
"How do we know which one we're talking to?" Damon asked. "Do we just number them off?"
"Well we all know which one would be number one," Elena said in her best egotistical Katherine voice as a Kat-like smirk formed on her lips.
"I could always be the hot one and she could be the less hot one," Katherine suggested helpfully with a shrug.
"In your dreams maybe," Elena responded in her best impersonation. "But don't you think that would just confuse them when I'm clearly the more attractive one?"
"This is really weird," Matt commented as he looked between the two doppelgangers.
The pair had come up with a dare while they were alone, so Katherine decided to speak for them.
"Stefan, truth or dare?" She asked.
"Truth," Stefan chose, surprising them all.
Although they hadn't come up with a dare together, Elena managed to quickly think of one and there was no pause after Stefan answering Katherine before Elena asked, "If you were going to sleep with one of the guys here, who would you choose?"
Elena did a slight Katherine like head tilt as she smirked over at him curiously.
"Klaus," Stefan responded a little too quickly before shooting his friend a drunken smile.
Stefan hadn't even looked around to try and decide or hesitated in the slightest, he had just answered automatically.
The speed of Stefan's answer was met with two matching Katherine smirks.
"How are we going to figure it out when they're both acting exactly the same way?" Klaus asked.
"I have an idea," Stefan said excitedly, before pointing at the nearest doppelganger. "You, truth or dare?"
"Dare," Elena responded with a grin.
"I dare you to go as far as you have to with Elijah until he tells you to stop," Stefan slurred.
"With pleasure," Elena said with a suggestive eyebrow raise and smirk as she got up and began to head over to Elijah.
"Risky move when it might be your girlfriend," Kol commented on Stefan's choice of dares.
Elena wasted no time as she sat down on Elijah's lap and grabbed hold of his hair to push his head forward until their lips met. Elena kissed him hard, pressing her tongue into his mouth within seconds.
As they kissed, she let her hands slide their way down the back of Elijah's shirt before she pulled them back out and grabbed onto the front of his shirt and began to unbutton it. She got one button undone before she decided to just rip the rest of the shirt open, sending buttons flying every which way.
She smirked against his lips before pulling away from his mouth.
Elena began to kiss at his chest and after a few seconds she slid her body up against his until her chest was against his face. She grabbed onto the back of his head to hold him against her and much to everyone's surprise he began to kiss at her chest.
After several long seconds Elena slid back down and pressed her lips against his again. As she kissed him, she ground her body against his a little.
After another minute, she removed her mouth from his and brought it back to his chest.
She trailed kisses downwards as her hands trailed down his chest on either side. Once Elena ran out of exposed flesh, she decided to take a gamble and reached for Elijah's belt and began to unbuckle it as she looked up at him with a suggestive grin.
"Stop," Elijah told her, deciding not to go that far with everyone else watching.
Elena ever so slowly let go of his belt and sat back up, still on top of his lap.
"Okay, that is definitely Katherine," Kol commented.
"It's way too slutty to be Elena and if Katherine was the one watching she would have looked angry and annoyed," Bonnie added.
"That wasn't my sister," Jeremy agreed.
"It's Katherine," Elijah said definitively as he looked at the girl sitting in his lap.
"Then I guess we're voting," Rebekah commented. "I vote Katherine's the one on Elijah."
They all went around voting until they had all said basically the same thing; they had unanimously decided that Katherine was the one who had performed the dare with Elijah.
Elena continued the act for a moment longer as she swung a leg off of Elijah and stood up with the triumphant smirk of Katherine Pierce.
"Wrong," She told them.
"That was impressive," Katherine commented from where she still sat. "I wasn't sure that you'd be able to pull it off."
"Really?" Elena asked, her face returning to a smile of her own as her tone went back to normal. "It all felt a little over the top, even for you."
The entire room stared at the pair in a shocked confusion. There were more than a few dropped jaws.
"No, it was dead on," Katherine told her with a smile.
"You're really good at being a slutty bitch," Stefan told his girlfriend in a flirtatious tone.
Caroline took a shot and then began to laugh hysterically as she turned to Katherine and said, "The guy that you like can't even tell the difference between kissing you and kissing Elena!"
"I take it back, I don't like drunk people," Katherine said as she glared over at Caroline.
"Hey, I thought that you like me because I was good at being a slutty bitch," Caroline complained in a slurred tone as she remembered Katherine's reaction to her teasing Klaus. "But I see how it is, you find someone better and you just drop me. You know what, fine. I didn't want to be your friend anyways."
It was becoming more and more apparent just how drunk Caroline was with every word.
"I'll just find someone else to talk about the guys' dicks to afterwards," Caroline said, shocking everyone there.
Caroline turned and spotted Rebekah and said, "Well I can't talk to you because almost half of them are your brothers." She turned to Elena, "And I can't talk to you about Jeremy's penis."
"I'd volunteer if it wasn't for Damon," Stefan slurred.
"Sorry that my existence is holding you back from gossiping about dicks," Damon said sarcastically. "You two are seriously drunk."
An idea seemed to hit Caroline as she turned to Bonnie excitedly, "Hey, Bon. You like Jeremy's penis! Plus you aren't related to anybody here. You and me are going to have some girl talk tomorrow." As she said the last part Caroline winked and pointed back and forth between herself and Bonnie.
A/N: Please read and review! I hope that you enjoyed another quick update and thanks for reading! If anyone has any suggestions or characters that they would like to get more attention then please tell me and I'll try my best to make you happy. I know that an anonymous guest asked for more Damon and although there hasn't been too much of him in this chapter I promise that he will get more soon.
Another super giant extra thanks goes out to all of the incredible reviewers of the last chapter that motivated me to get this chapter up so quick: chibichibi98, .rain, astrita15, xxvampiresgreatestweaknessxx, Replica Velocity a.k.a. X5 714, Green-eyes-blonde-hair, sara, Ktclaire99, Lisa, Nataliesmiley6, KlarolinexDelenaxx, Kay McNell, Jamie, glevez25, jessnicole, justine, Carroline, vampirelovver, Bonnie, SingLikeThere'sNobodyListening, hannaaa150, MoomeyMoomster, Buffy-Angel9, DrawingMyHeartOut, Pagan-Angel13, Bell5853, BiancaR, and the two anonymous guest reviewers :D