They arrived in Connecticut in the morning. They decided not to stop and Sam took the wheels when Dean was tired. As soon as Sam parked the car Dean stormed out and went to the reception desk.
" Kate?" He was talking loudly " Kate I need to talk to you right now it's important!" Said Dean even louder.
He saw her, she was coming his way. " She told you the truth didn't she?" Asked Kate nicely.
" Well I don't know about that!" Said Dean furious " But she told me she's my sister!"
Lucy and Sam entered the Motel.
" Well she is your sister Dean! Why are you so mad?" Asked Kate curious.
" Not a good question Ma!" Added Lucy.
Dean turned around and gave her a dark look. " I'm not talking to you am I? I want to hear it from Kate!" Said Dean to Lucy. He turned back to Kate. "I can't believe you! I don't have a sister.!"
" Well, you can deny it as much as you want Dean." Said Kate with a smile " But the truth is that Lucy is your half sister and the fact that you don't like it won't change it!" She turned her wheelchair " Please follow me to the flat. People don't need to hear us."
They went in the kitchen. " Please sit down" said Kate. " Do you want a coffee?"
Dean could feel his anger grow I don't want a dam coffee!! I want an explanation!"
" What do you want me to tell you Dean?" Said Kate coming at the table and looking into his eyes. " What do you want to hear?"
I" want to know why you decided to tell Lucy about her father without telling him first?! I want to know if this all thing is true! I want to know why my father didn't know about her! I want to know it all!!" Said Dean maintaining her glance.
" That's a lot to say!" Said Kate laughing to hide her guilt. " Well Lucy is your sister because your dad was the first man I slept with."
Dean made a weird face.
" That's maybe too much information ." Said Sam embarrassed.
" Your brother want to know it all and he will!" Said Kate harshly. " So, We did it only once, we were trying to comfort each other. It was a mistake and we decided to forget about that night and to stay friend. We did it pretty well. When I discovered I was pregnant I was really happy and I wanted to tell John but he kept telling me how bad he felt about raising you in the hunt and how a terrible father he was. I didn't want to put more weight on his shoulder by telling him that I was expecting his child and that I will be a mother before my 19th birthday!" Kate sighed " I could have told him later on but I just couldn't! He came here last year and talked about his regrets. I could have told him then because Lucy was already 16 and you guys were all grown. I wanted to keep my daughter for myself and I was sure that if your dad knew the all story he would have been really upset and what about Lu?" She looked at her daughter. " I lied to her for so many years! I couldn't see myself telling her! I thought she wouldn't talk to me again! I'm sorry guys. As to know if it's real, we can take a DNA test if you want but she doesn't need you in her life! I told her the truth because she wanted a family and it was maybe my last chance to give her that! But she will realize one day, after your gone, that she is well better without you! She needed to see and get to know her brothers."
Dean shook his head and looked at Kate. She was sincere. He was denying the facts but he knew deep down that Lucy was his sister, he knew it was true since Lucy told them in the wood, he was just not ready to accept it yet. " Do you really think that I'm going to walk away? I won't forget about Lucy Gosh! She is my sister! My « evil teenager little sister ». I can't do that! I won't do that!" Said Dean with a smile for Lucy but she was not looking at him, she was staring at the floor.
He could see that he hurt her and he felt sorry about that and wanted to repair his mistake. He looked at Kate and back to Lucy even if she was not looking at him he talked keeping his eyes on her. " I want to know her better. I want her to come with us and hunt as the family! What do you say? Do you want to come with us Lu?" He was smiling.
She raised her head to look at him. Her eyes were empty, she was not expressing anything which surprised Dean. " Don't call me Lu" she said very calmly. " I don't want to hunt with you anymore. I met you and I know you a bit that's all I wanted. You can go now, I'll be find. There is no need for you to try to repair a « bound » that never really existed. Take care of you guys. Bye." She added. She walked to her room and closed the door behind her. They did not want her and clearly stated that. She refused to be their charity work. She laid on the bed.
Sam stood up in the kitchen. " I'm going to talk to her, I know what she needs."
He will try his best to convince her because even if he knew her for just about a week he already felt love for her and he did not want to loose his sister because she already was important to him and owned a piece of his heart.