The episode picks up with the lacrosse team celebrating another victory. As Scott searches for Stiles, he bumps into Allison. She tells him how well he did and how hard she cheered for him.
"Guess we are getting closer again" Scott mumbled to Allison who squeezed his hand with a smile on her face.
In the locker room, Danny tells Scott he accepts his apology from elbowing him before. Scott says he didn't apologize, but he did pass to Danny for the entire game.
"Ah team mate love. How I miss it" Peter said with a sigh. "You were in a team?" Stiles asked the not yet insane wolf. Peter rolled his eyes, "I might be a raging lunatic there but I was not always like that. Plus I was in the basketball team" he said.
When the team leaves, the lights go out and Scott finds Derek, joined by his uncle Peter. They try to convince him to join their Wolf Pack.
"Come join the dark side" Stiles said in a Vadar like voice which made those who watched the film chuckle.
Peter says he wants Scott to see his side of things and digs his claws into Scott's neck, enabling Scott to see Peter's memories.
"That..was…I don't know how to say it" Peter said in a whisper as everyone looked on in silence.
After having dreams of Scott, Allison wakes up and notices her necklace is missing.
"Naughty girl" Lydia said from her seat with a smirk making Allison blush. "Shut up" Allison whispered trying to hide into herself.
She decides to look in her car, when the garage opens. It's her dad and Kate, who is trying to convince him to teach her the family trade. He tells her it's not time yet and storms off, but Kate leaves a strange arrowhead for Allison to discover.
Chris curls his hands into fists. He had planned on not putting Allison down this line of work and now his idiotic and if he was right murdering psychopath of a sister was messing it all up.
Jackson, driving his car through an abandoned parking lot, is shocked when the car has some sort of trouble. As he goes to look at the problem, Allison's father drives up and offers help with the car. As Jackson leans in to look at the problem, he gets a closer look at the scars on Jackson's neck.
"Who drives around in an abandoned parking lot like that" Stiles said flailing his arms around. "Apparently Jackson. And would you stop doing that before you hit me" Lydia said pointing a glare at Stiles who smiled sheepishly.
Scott and Stiles pull up, and offer Jackson Whittemore a ride to get help. Allison's father takes whatever device he'd planted in Jackson's car and leaves, claiming to have fixed Jackson's problem.
"That wasn't creepy at all dad" Allison said looking at her father oddly. "Hey I needed t find out if he was a wolf. Be glad I went for safe route and not the other one" Chris said with half a smile.
As Allison and Lydia are hiking in the woods, Allison mentions that Jackson asked her to the winter formal before revealing that she knows that Lydia kissed Scott in the coach's office. Allison pulls out a bow and arrow to test out the arrow her Aunt Kate left her. It explodes upon impact with a tree.
"I'm sorry about that" Lydia said raising her hand like a guilty child. Allison looked at her friend before looking back at the screen. "That thing is dangerous" Stiles mumbled over to Scott who nodded his head.
Back out in the abandoned parking lot, Jackson tells Scott to make him a werewolf. Scott tries telling him how hard out there it truly is for a werewolf, with Jackson claiming he can handle it. Jackson says that just because Scott has a hard time with his werewolf abilities doesn't mean that he won't know how to handle it. He claims that Scott has all the power in the world, but doesn't know how to use it.
"He is partially right there" Talia began. "All betas have problems controlling themselves. But yes Scott you do have a lot of power in you. You just need to learn to use them properly".
Out in the woods, Allison hears a noise and gives her bow to Lydia for safekeeping while she investigates. She accidentally uses a stun gun on Scott, who gives her back her necklace, claiming he found it at school. She hugs Scott, then walks away.
"Painful way to greet someone" Laura winced. "I'm so sorry" Allison turned to Scott who was smiling, "You already said that. And look we are hugging now", Allison smiled to that.
Stiles sees his dad working late and gets him some whiskey, which he uses to intoxicate his father, in an effort to get information about the case.
"This boy is going to send me to the grave way before it's my time" Noah groaned rubbing his face while Stiles laughed nervously.
He finds out some useful information. All the people previously killed by the alpha had some connection to the Hale fire. The bus driver was an inspector fired for fraud. The video store clerk and guys from the woods were arsonists.
"So it isn't mindless murder" Cora muttered, "it's all about vengeance" she said looking at her uncle who was staring intently at the screen
He also finds out that Derek's eyes blind the camera mugshots of himself. His father, under the alcohol, finally unveils in a sweetly touching scene how much he misses both talking to Stiles and Stiles' mother.
"Oh Noah" Claudia say cuddling into her husband who holds her close. Stiles looks at his father with sadness in his eyes. "Guess I wasn't the only one" he thought to himself.
In his room, Scott gets a call informing him he will need to get an extension on his paper if he wants to pass the class. Allison visits Scott, and begins to tell him the suspicions she has about her family. They're interrupted by Scott's mother, who is going on a date. Needing more time to prepare, she has Scott head down to the door for her, but before he even turns the knob his wolf senses act up. Peter Hale is at the door, taking Scott's mom out on a date.
"Guess a coma and a deranged personality hasn't made your playboy side go extinct" Talia said with a roll of her eyes. "I still got it" Peter silently cheered ignoring his sister.
Back in the locker room, Jackson is confronted by Derek. He convinces Jackson that he'll turn him into a werewolf, and Jackson follows him eagerly. On their date, Scott's mom notices that Peter has missed the turn for the restaurant. In an effort to save his mother, Scott has Stiles rear end her car. Peter tells Scott he is truly impressed by Scott's cunning, and reveals Derek's plans to kill Jackson.
"Guess even lunatic me doesn't like the brat" Peter thought to himself with a mental snort.
Derek takes Jackson to the Hale House and explains that everything he wants is inside. Inside, Jackson realizes he's seen the house before in his dreams. Jackson realizes that Derek is going to murder him and begs for his life. Derek explains that there's a reason no one is there to protect him. Scott appears to save Jackson, and reveals his full werewolf form to him.
"Finally a werewolf brawl!" Stiles whooped. "10 dollars on Derek!" Laura shouted much to the displeasure of Derek. "50 on Derek" Stiles said earning him a surprised look from his best friend. "What!? Do you really expect you can beat him in this fight?" Stiles asked. Scott thought for a moment, "True" he said with a shrug and a smile.
Before they can face off, however, wolfsbane bullets riddle the house and hit Scott. Derek helps him escape, and then opens the door to a blazing white light.
"Must you hunters ruin everything!?" Stiles said with a groan. Chris and Victoria looked at the boy with an amused look on their faces.
In the woods Scott passes out and awakens to find his boss, the vet tending to his wounds.
"You knew!?" Scott asked looking at his boss who shrugged. "It seems I do" Deaton said with a smile. "You might not be the alpha doc but you sure do have great timing" he said with narrowed eyes. Something told him that there was much more to this vet than what meets the eye.
Allison finally gets tired of waiting for Scott and responds to a text from Aunt Kate. In an underground facility, she reveals a captured Derek Hale in full werewolf form.
"Why is he shirtless!?" Laura asked the hunters. "Your brother got captured and probably is going to get tortured and all you care is how he is shirtless?" Chris asked with a raised eyebrow. Laura shrugged, "Derek is a big boy, he will get out" she said with an air of confidence as the next episode began.