"Raoul, why did we come to the rooftop?" Christine said as they got up to the roof top. He walks up to her and held her arm and said "I'm sorry Christine, but I felt like someone was watching us so I panicked"

She guest that he thought that Katherine was watching them; she took a breath and ask "ok, what is it you want to talk about?"

He nodded and replied "Christine, I want you to travel with me"

She pulled he's hand from her arms "what why?"

"Christine, you been busy for seven years, and I never get to see you, so I want you to travel with me and we can get married" she backed away and shook her head "no I can't, I have to look after the two twins you seen" it was the only lie she could come up.

"That's something I want to talk to you about too, if you are looking after them, why do they look like you soo much?" her heart started beating fast, how is she going to tell him a lie.

Behind a horse statue Katherine was listing, but got worried when he said that last sentences "come on mom, think of a lie you can tell that fop" she said under her breath.

"Umm, because….. They just do" weakest lie she ever told. He raised an eyebrow and shook his head "Christine, when people are looking after someone's kids, they don't look like them, your hiding something are you?" She was getting scared; she is hoping that he doesn't find out the truth.

"W-w-well some people can look like different people"

"Well that's true" she took a long breath, but he continued "but still, your still going to travel with me and we'll be married" that's something she can't do, she had twins with Erik, and they promise to be together. She shook her head and said "no Raoul I can't"

When Katharine heard that she smiled "I guess that means that he won't be having my mom as his wife" but her mind woke up she heard him yell "WHAT, WHY NOT!?" she sighted and said "because, for the last seven years my career has gone up and I have grown famous with my singing, and plus I have the twins I'm looking after for a couple more years".

His eyes grow wide "what are you saying"

"We are not going to be together Raoul, I'm sorry but we can still be friends" she turned for the door, but he grabbed her arm and asked "Christine tell me the truth, those twins, are they yours, and don't lie to me"

She sighed "I guess I can't keep it in any longer" she looked down and said "Raoul, the twin's are-"

BANG, BANG

Two shots rang out, Christine look up and saw Raoul on his back "oh no" she turned and saw Katherine, holding a gun.

"You followed us?"

She nodded "yes, I did not trust him one bit, so I followed you two"

Christine got down and listened to his heart "he's still alive" Katherine gowned when her mother said that "great, now I have to put a 3rd one in him" Christine grabbed the gun from her.

"What happened here" a familiar voice called from behind, the two girls turned and saw it was just Erik and Christian. Christine got up and said "nothing"

Christine turned and saw his sister and asked "did you shot him" she nodded "yea, but mom said he is still alive" Erik and Katherine both gowned. Christine pulled Raoul's shirt off and saw where she shot him "it looks like you only shot him in the shoulder cap and his right hip"

Katherine pulled out the memory stuff and said "can I do this mom?" she sighted and nodded, then a weak voice came from Raoul "C-C-Christine" she turned to him "why didn't you tell me that you have two kids with that man?"

Christine tried to think of something, she looked down at him, and before she could say anything Katherine covered him face with the stuff and he passed out.

"Dad, have I ever told you that you make amazing stuff?" Katherine said.

Christine turned around and told Erik to take the kids down and she will call the mangers. When he did Christine dragged Raoul down stars, she was amazed how he was still asleep.

A little bit later

The mangers called for help and a few doctors and nurse came to carry him to the hospital "oh Raoul, please be ok" she said silently as she watch them take Raoul away. End of chapter 11

I'm sorry if you were hoping that Raoul died, but I didn't want him to die, I hope you liked this chapter and please comment on the story.