*The next morning with the BAU*

The team got up early and met in the hotel lobby to head over to the station. Everyone was half asleep but it wasn't hard to tell one of their own was missing,

"Hey you guys, has anyone seen Melissa?" questioned Prentiss.

The looks on everyone's faces confirmed they had all been wondering the same thing. Reid was the one who spoke up.

"She's probably with Officer Bleakney. She went out with him last night and the probably just spent the rest of the night with each other." There was an edge in his voice as he spoke.

David grimaced a bit, his step daughters sex life was not something he wanted to think about.

"If that is the case, then they'll be at the station waiting for us. Let's go." Hotch gave Reid a disapproving look, meaning to say the last part of his explanation was a bit too far.

The team headed out to the station expecting to find Melissa and Officer Bleakney going over anything about the case, that however was not what they discovered.

"Good morning Agents." greeted Officer Grant.

"Good morning Officer. Where are Agent Melissa Rossi and Officer Bleakney?"

"What do you mean?" asked Grant puzzlingly, "I thought they were with you."

"No, last night Agent Rossi and Officer Grant went to the crime scene to look at something Officer Bleakney found. When Melissa wasn't at the morning meeting today we assumed they were here together." replied Reid, now looking concerned.

"Wait a minute, if they aren't here, then where are they?" asked Morgan.

The team and Grant all exchanged worried looks. Hotch pulled out his cell phone, dialed a number and put the phone on speaker."

"Garcia's magic lamp, what wishes do you wish to have granted?"

"Garcia, this is serious, I need you to track Melissa's cell phone. Now."

"Yes, sir. Right away."

The tapping sound of Garcia Typing away on her keyboard was the only sound that could be heard. Silence soon followed then a loud beep.

"I'm so sorry, I tried, but I can't pick up the signal. It's either dead or off."

"Alright, thanks Garcia stand by."

With that Hotch hung up the phone and looked up at Grant.

"Officer, send out two missing persons reports. The person who grabbed Miss Rodriguez now has one of my agents and your co-worker."

*With Melissa*

I woke up in a small windowless room. The only thing the room consisted of was the bed I was laying on, a small night stand on the right side of the bed, and a door, which I was presuming was locked.

My head ached and I couldn't tell if it had only been an hour or two since I had been at Sarah's house with Caleb, or if it had been all day.

Caleb! Shit! He had sent me a text telling me to get out of the house. I hope he's alright.

I sized up the room hoping to find a flaw that would get me out of there, but of course nothing. So I choose the next best thing.

"HELP! IF ANYONE CAN HEAR ME HELP!"

I yelled that about three more times before I heard footsteps coming towards the door. I froze in terror when the door handle started to giggle.

When the door opened I was shocked to see what I saw.

"Caleb!" I yelled.

"Melissa, I'm glad to see you're ok. You look very good."

The last part caught me off guard.

I looked down and saw I was wearing the same blue jeans, purple t-shirt, and black ballet flats as I had been the previous night.

"Caleb, what's going on?"

He closed the door and walked up to me.

"Amazing. I talked to you for months, and you don't even recognize me." he seemed pissed.

"What are you talking about? I just met you like two days ago!"

He started laughing.

"No! You met me when you were a junior in high school! Remember?"

He brought his hand up and I was sure he was going to hit me, but instead he went to his mouth and pulled out… a pair of fake teeth?

Yup, the perfect white smile was now replaced with an awkwardly formed set of teeth. That's when it clicked. He was the guy who took Sarah, he called me when he took her, he was in the back of our prom picture. The bad smile, the southern accent. It all made sense.

"Oh my god. Dan?"

"Finally you realize it! My god! I was so afraid when you came back to Maine you'd recognize me instantly, so I got the fake teeth and hoped a name change would protect my cover, and it did. You know, for an FBI agent, you're pretty slow."

"You took Sarah, didn't you? That's why you had me go to the house with you. The text you sent me was to make me think you got attacked to, but it was actually you! Everything was a lie, everything!"

"Ding ding ding! We have a winner. But, just so you know, not everything was a lie. That kiss was true. I've wanted to do that since we first met when you were in high school. Plus I had to think of some way to get that geek to back off."

"Spencer? What are you talking about?"

"Man, you really are stupid. He's in love with you! He's constantly staring at you! I knew if I didn't make a move, then asked you to go to the house with me, he's talk to you, and you being in love with him, would listen and not go. If I had you distracted, then he wouldn't be able to stop you."

"I'm not in love with him."

"Bull shit you aren't! I see the way you look at him and talk to him!"

"Okay, whatever! Why the hell did you kidnap me?"

"Because, I'm in love with you. I have been since we first met on that chat site. We talked for hours and you were gorgeous, you still are. And we promised we would meet each other one day, and the day I went to meet you, you were all over some guy."

I knew he was talking about prom night.

"Then when I went to see you the week after you graduated you were gone. I moved up from North Carolina and waited for you to come back. I changed my name, and became a police officer. Then I heard you were working for the BAU and was told you were never coming back to Maine. I knew I had to find a way to get you here."

"And that was by taking Sarah."

"Ahh. Now you're catching on. I knew if I got her, I'd get you. And I was right. I've waited so long to get you alone."

"What are you going to do to me? To Sarah?"

"Well, since I'm assuming people are going to be looking for us soon, I'm sending an anonymous tip to the station in a few weeks about our location. You and I will leave and be together forever, while Sarah stays here and is found."

"What about while we wait for that time to come?"

"While we wait, I'm going to have some fun with you."

With that he stepped forward grabbing my waist and pushing me onto the bed.