I would just like to say thank you to everyone that reviewed my last chapter. It means so much to me to receive a review, good or bad. Please continue to review. The more reviews I get, the more motivated I am to update sooner.

So, for the people who told me how they wanted the next chapter to go, thank you. Most people wanted to have them start explaining and then go into a flashback, so that's how this chapter is done. Please let me know what you think.


"It actually wasn't our first time together," Lucas said.

"What do you mean?" Haley asked, more confused than ever.

"We kind of lost our virginity to each other in high school," Peyton said.

Peyton and Lucas waited for someone to say anything, but the room remained quiet. Haley was looking at them in complete shock and Nathan was just looking down. Finally, Haley couldn't hold it in any longer.

"Are you serious?! Why didn't you tell me?! And why did you even do it to begin with?! What the hell is wrong with you guys?!" Haley screamed.

Nathan grabbed her by her waist and pulled her to him. "Hey, Hales. Calm down. I'm sure there's a reasonable explanation for all of this. You just got to give them a chance to explain."

"You're right," Haley said, soothed by Nathan's words. "I should at least give you guys a chance to explain. What happened?"

Lucas and Peyton looked at each other.

"Um... Hales, I don't think I really feel comfortable telling you what happened that night," Lucas said, scratching the back of his head.

"Yea. I mean it was a long time ago. Can't you just let it go?" Peyton asked.

"No, Peyton! I can't just let it go! If you guys didn't feel comfortable explaining it, then why did you tell us to begin with?" Haley yelled.

"I don't know. I just thought it was appropriate that you guys knew the truth. I didn't feel right lying to you guys about it, so we told you. That doesn't mean that I want to tell you everything leading up to it," Lucas explained.

"Luke, you know how Haley is. She's gonna want to know everything, so you might as well tell her now," Nathan said.

Lucas and Peyton looked at each other again. Lucas drew a deep breath and looked at Haley.

"Fine. But whatever gets said today, never leaves this room. You got that?" Lucas asked Haley.

"Yes, Luke. Of course," Haley obediently said.

"Alright. You might as well make yourself comfortable, because it's kind of a long story," Lucas said.

"Ok," Haley agreed happily.

She pulled Nathan by his hand into the living room and sat down next to him on the couch. Lucas and Peyton hesitantly followed them. Lucas sat down on the other side of the couch next to Peyton.

"Ok. So it happened at the End of Senior Party in high school. Peyton and I-" Lucas began.

"Wait," Haley interrupted. "Can I go make some popcorn? The baby's craving it."

"Sure, Haley," Lucas said laughing.

She got up and ran into the kitchen, Nathan, Lucas, and Peyton all waiting silently for her to return. A couple minutes later she returned, carrying a huge bowl of popcorn.

"Want some?" She offered Lucas and Peyton.

"No thanks, Hales."

"Alright. So continue with the story," Haley said.

"So, as I was saying, it happened at the End of Senior Year Party in high school."

Flashback

The End of Senior Year party was taking place at Peyton's house. It was one of the biggest houses in Tree Hill, and her mom being dead and her dad being away at sea, made it the perfect place for a party. Almost every senior at Tree Hill High was there, and her house was covered in wasted teens.

Peyton was in her room, needing to escape the loud music and partying. She wasn't really in the party mood, but once Brooke suggested she throw the party, there was no backing out. Peyton was sitting at the edge of her bed, lost in thought, when the door opened, Lucas walking in. The noise poured into the room, but was blocked out again when Lucas shut the door.

"Hey, Peyton," Lucas said.

"Hey, Luke," Peyton said, looking down.

"I was looking for you. Why aren't you out there having fun? It is your party after all." Lucas moved to sit next to her on the edge of the bed. He turned his head, fixing his eyes on her. She was wearing a black pair of skinny jeans with a shirt that he noticed was new. Over that, she wore her favorite leather jacket that Ellie gave her. She looked beautiful, as always.

"I'm just really not in the party mood." She answered, looking up to meet his gaze. His eyes were so intense, she began to feel her heart rate speed up. Brooke was the only one who knew about her 'little' crush on Lucas. That surprised her considering how obvious she thought she made it. She quickly scanned him over, taking in his appearance. He was wearing a pair of dark blue jeans with a while t-shirt. He looked hot, as always.

"I know what you mean." Lucas said, standing up. He casually looking through her record collection. "I don't want to leave this place. I'm really gonna miss it."

"Yea. Me too. But that's not why I'm so bummed," Peyton whispered just loud enough for Lucas to hear.

He immediately walked back over to her, kneeling down and looking deep into her green eyes. "Peyton, what's wrong? You know you can tell me anything. Did something happen with your dad? Did you get in a fight with Brooke?"

Peyton shook her head. She rubbed her hands over her face. "It's kind of embarrassing actually."

Lucas nodded, urging her to continue.

"I just don't want to go to college and still be a...virgin." She looked at him, expecting him to laugh, but he didn't. "It's stupid-"

"No," Lucas interrupted. "I know exactly what you're talking about."

"Why? You're still a virgin?" Peyton asked jokingly.

"Actually, yea." Lucas watched Peyton's eyes widen in surprise. "I mean, it's not like I haven't had the chance. I just haven't found anyone I think I would enjoy losing it to."

"Me too. I want to lose it to someone who I won't look back on and regret losing it to. But now, I just want to get it over with."

"Yea. Skillz is actually out there right now, trying to hook me up with a girl."

"Wow! And you're in here with me?" Peyton smiled widely, obviously messing with him. "You better get out there."

"I'd rather be with you," Lucas said honestly. He knew he had surprised her again by the way her green eyes flashed.

Peyton didn't know how Lucas's words had such an effect on her. She wanted more than anything for him to be the guy she lost her virginity to, even more so finding out he was a virgin as well. He pushed one of her stray curls behind her ear and smiled at her.

She couldn't take it anymore. She reached over and kissed him. She pulled back immediately, afraid he didn't want that to happen. She watched him slowly open his eyes, looking at her like she was the only person in the world. He stood up, bringing her with him by her hands, and kissed her. Just a simple kiss, but it had so many effects on both of them.

They stood like that for a little bit, arms wrapped around each other's bodies, gently kissing. Strangely, it felt normal. Finally, Peyton pulled back.

"What wrong?" Lucas asked, obviously thinking he had done something wrong.

She quickly shook her head. "Nothing. I just...I mean, do you really want to do this?"

"Yea. I couldn't think of anyone more perfect to do this with than you."

Peyton smiled at him. He was just about to kiss her again, when she pushed away. "Wait. There has to be some rules. We can't just do this and not have any boundaries."

"Of course," Lucas agreed.

"Great. Rule Number One: No more kissing on the lips."

"What?" Lucas asked, clearly not pleased with this rule.

"I'm sorry, Lucas. We're both leaving to colleges hundreds of miles away from each other, and kissing always adds more feelings to everything. I just don't want to make things any harder than they already are," Peyton explained.

"Fine," Lucas finally said.

"Rule Number Two: This is just a one time thing. We can't keep this up."

"Alright."

"Finally, Rule Number Three: No one can ever find out."

Lucas smiled at Peyton. "Ok. I accept these rules." He was about to continue where they left off, when he suddenly froze. "Anywhere but the lips, right?"

Peyton managed to nod her head at him, wishing she could take the first rule back. He moved his lips to her neck, sucking and nipping at it. She turned her head, giving him a better angle. She was so lost in what his lips were doing to her neck, she hadn't noticed him slide her jacket off her shoulders. When it hit the floor, the sound caused her to focus again. Due to the state he had now put her in, she decided to speed things up.

She paused Lucas's movements to pull off her shirt. She reached down and lifted his shirt from his body as well. His upper body was now fully exposed, and she had always admired it whenever it was. Now, she took this as a perfect chance to lower herself and leave kisses along his toned abs. He let out a small moan and she stood up again. He reached down and unbuttoned and unzipped her jeans. He pushed them down as low as he could without crouching down. She stepped out of them and he eyed her body. She was now only in her underwear, and he could no longer hide the bulge in his pants that had been there the moment she kissed him.

He lead her to her mattress. Her knees hit the edge of it and she collapsed onto it backwards. Lucas hovered over her bringing his lips back to her neck. She brought her hands down until they slid over his extremely noticeable erection. He let out a loud groan and knew he would not last with her touching him in this way. She seemed to realize this and stopped her actions to unbutton his button. She pulled down his zipper at a tortuously slow pace. He let out another groan when her hand brushed across his member, and she loved the effect she had on him.

Lucas kicked off his jeans, hurriedly, wanting to remove all clothing between them as soon as possible. He was now left in only his boxers, while she remained wearing her bra and panties. He moved his hands behind her and unhooked her bra. He pulled it off, her helping him by sliding her arms through the straps. His breath caught in his throat at the sight of her breasts. He recovered quickly, not wanting her to feel self conscious. He placed her right breast in his mouth, happy to find her nipple already hard. With his other hand, he palmed her left breast. She let out moans of delight. He switched sides, mimicking what he did to the first breast.

Lucas pulled away from her chest and moved his lips to her temple. He left wet kisses along a trail down her body, coming to a stop near her center. He paused briefly, giving her a look to make sure it was ok. She nodded her head at him, and that was all he needed. He placed his hands at either sides of her panties and tugged them off. He threw them onto some random place in her bedroom, mesmerized by the sight in front of him. Peyton Sawyer was completely naked, and she was all his.

He brought himself back up to place more kisses to her chest. While she was distracted, he placed his hand near her center and entered one finger into her. She let out a loud moan and arched her back slightly. He smiled at how wet she was for him. He pulled his finger in and out of her, marveling at how tight she was. He had only continued that notion for a couple of minutes more, when she had her first orgasm. He placed light kisses around her body, allowing her to catch her breath.

When she finally recovered, she looked at him. "Ok. I'm ready."

Lucas was about to begin, but realized he didn't have any protection. "Peyton, I don't have any-"

She reached into her dresser drawer next to her bed and pulled out a condom. She handed it to him and he raised his eyebrows at her, questioningly. "I'm always prepared."

"Thank God," Lucas said, kicking off his boxers and sliding the condom on.

He positioned himself at her entrance, drawing in a deep breath. She didn't need to tell him to be careful because she knew he already knew. She completely trusted him and knew he would never hurt her. They locked eyes.

Lucas slowly began to enter her. No matter how much it was killing him to not slam into her, he remained slow. When he was about halfway in, she winced slightly. He immediately felt guilty and stopped his movements.

"It's ok," she promised.

He nodded reluctantly and continued. When he was fully inside of her, he gave her time to adjust. She smiled at him, letting him know she was ok, and that he should continue. He went in and out of her slowly, still acting cautious. He was surprised to hear her encouraging him to go faster. He sped his movements a little, already feeling close to his release. Again, he increased his speed. She did the exact opposite of complain, so he began to charge into her. Within seconds, they were both calling out each other's names, having had their orgasms at the same time.

He collapsed next to her on the bed, both breathing heavily. He wrapped an arm around her, bringing her closer to his side. He placed a sweet kiss to her head and covered them with her sheets.

"Well, that was-," Peyton began.

"Amazing," Lucas finished.

"Yea. Way better than I ever expected."

"Same here." Lucas closed his eyes, as did Peyton, and they fell asleep.

End of Flashback

"And that's how it all happened," Lucas concluded.

"Aww!" Haley exclaimed, tearing up. She pulled out tissues from her pocket that she had obviously planned on using. "That is probably the sweetest story I've ever heard! Tell it again!"

"Haley," Nathan scolded. "They just finished telling it."

"I know, but wasn't it sweet?" Haley asked her husband.

"Yes, Hales. It was very sweet."

"You know what? Some popcorn actually sounds pretty good right now. Can I have some, Hales?" Lucas asked.

"Honey, I finished that a long time ago," Haley said with wide eyes.

"What? That whole thing?" Lucas questioned.

"I told you the baby was craving it," Haley said with a shrug.

They all just laughed.

"Well, if it's going to my niece or nephew, then it's alright," Lucas said.

"Speaking of that," Haley said looking at Nathan. "We actually wanted to talk to you guys about something."

"Haley and I have decided that we want you two to be the Godparents of our unborn child," Nathan said.

"Really? I'd be honored," Peyton said, beginning to cry tears of joy. She stood up and engulfed Haley in a strong hug.

"Wow, Man! This means a lot to me," Lucas said, doing the same with Nathan.

They all settled back down again once they had all hugged and said thanks. They were watching a random sports game when Haley started talking.

"So, last night was your guy's second time then?" Haley asked.

Lucas and Peyton looked at each other.

"Well..."


Hey, Everybody! I hope you all enjoyed the chapter. Again, I'm going to let you guys decide how you want me to write the next chapter. Should I explain why that was not their second time in another flashback? Or should I just continue writing from the starting point of the next day? Or should I do a little time jump? I don't know, you guys decide. Please review and let me know what you think. Reviews are greatly appreciated :)