I don't own My babysitter's a vampire, Avenue Q, or the song "Fall for you" by Secondhand Serenade.

"Hey baby!" a few guys whistled, passing the blond beauty. She smiled in return, whisking by them. She went inside the nearest café to get a coffee, even though she really didn't need it.

"No way, I love Secondhand Serenade too." a female voice said from a nearby table.

"Dude, awesome!" a male voice said, and he began to sing."The best thing bout tonight's that we're not fighting...could it be that we had been this way before... I know you don't think that I am trying...I know you're wearing thin down to the core...but hold your breath because tonight will be the night that I will fall for you, over again...don't make me change my mind...or I won't live to see another day, I swear it's true, because a girl like you is impossible to find, impossible to find.."

Erica stood, staring at Benny in shock. That song...it triggered something. A memory... He had sung it for her, maybe. It was still a little fuzzy, though...

"Benny?" Erica approached the table. The girl sitting with him glanced up at Erica in surprise and shock.

"Erica." Benny's face lit up. He glanced sideways at the blond girl with him. "Erica, you remember Della, don't you?"

"Sure." Erica ignored her. "You...sang that song to me, didn't you?" Benny glanced at her, eyes wide.

"I did." he said. "The day after Sarah left, when you were worried...and I sang to you about how I was going to fall for you again...like how I fell for you when you were kinda nerdy."

"That's...really sweet." Erica said.

"And we started to date. Do you remember it, Erica?" Benny asked, eyes hopeful.

"Not all of it." Erica admitted. She looked at Della. "It was nice to meet you." and she walked away, not knowing why her heart was aching.

"She is such a snob." Della asked. "Acting like she didn't know who I was...we've been at the same school since elementary!"( A/N: I have no idea if they really met in the series, but I just did it)

"She has a concussion." Benny blurted. "That's why."

"Oh." Della giggled nervously. "Sorry...I didn't-"

"It's okay." Benny shrugged. Della stayed silent for a while. "Hey...why so mute?" Benny grinned suddenly at her. "So, you ever heard of Avenue Q?"

...

"I don't get it." Ethan slammed his fist on his desk. "Why does Jesse have to disappear now? He and Sarah haven't been to school the past few days!"

"Maybe they're on at their honeymoon!" Rory suggested. Ethan gave him a look that could kill (good thing he's immortal,huh?).

"Where does Jesse normally hide?" Ethan asked. "Shouldn't you know?"

"No...maybe Erica does, though!" Rory exclaimed.

"Where do you think she is?" Ethan said.

"Probably with Benny." Rory shrugged. He grabbed Ethan's wrist and flew off before Ethan could protest...or move.

...

"Benny! Yo, Benny!" Rory yelled, bursting into the cafe. Benny and Della looked over at him, each of them drinking cups of coffee.

"Hey, Rory. Ethan." Benny said.

"Benny? Della?" Ethan glanced them over. "You and Erica broke up?"

"No." Benny answered quickly.

"Hi." Rory stared at Della, lovestruck. Della smiled in acknowledgment.

"Does...she know about this?" Ethan glanced at Benny.

"Yeah..." Benny said hesitantly. "Hey Della...hang out here for a sec? I need to talk to Ethan. Rory, sit for a bit." He hesitated to tell Rory, a bit concerned of Rory's, well, Rory-ness.

"Sure." Della agreed. Rory eagerly sat down across from her while Benny led Ethan outside.

"Benny, where's Erica. I need to talk to her." Ethan said.

"Ethan, she lost her memory!" Benny exclaimed. "Like, most of it! She didn't even know she was a vampire!"

"That is a problem." Ethan chewed the inside of his cheek. "Benny, I know Jesse is planning something with Sarah. I need to find her..."

"My guess? Check his place. Dude, his place is seriously sweet. If I had a crib like that, I'd want girls over too." Benny said.

"I guess I will." Ethan said. You want Rory to stay, or should I distract him while you get away?"

"He can stay." Benny said. "Just me and Della...well, it can seem kind of date-like. We were just both lonely, and both had nothing to do...dude, Erica stopped by, too. She seemed like she started to remember a bit. Me, being stupid, didn't go after her. What if she forgets again? E? Are you listening?"

"I know, Benny." Ethan said. "You should try to find a way to reverse the spell."

"I've poured over my spell book, but it's no use." Benny sighed. "Any idea for Sarah? Cause she went wonky on me..."

"And she's with Jesse." Ethan said. "Can you look in your book for any idea to reverse the spell on her?"

"Sure thing." Benny agreed. "Be careful, E."

"Don't worry." Ethan shrugged. "It's not the worst that's happened."

"True." Benny said, and he went inside. Ethan shoved his hands in his pockets and he started to walk.

...

"Jesse, what is she doing here?" Sarah stared, disgusted, at Annie.

"Just a bit of...security." Jesse said, wrapping an arm around Sarah's shoulders. "Don't worry, she is just here to make sure that Ethan boy doesn't come here." At the mention of his name, Sarah's fists clenched up. Jesse noticed this and gently uncurled her hands. "I said not to worry!"

"Relax, girl." Annie shrugged. "I don't want any trouble. Besides, I'll be doing you a favor by taking that Seer's blood."

"She's not going to affect anything between us, Sarah." Jesse promised. Sarah smiled.

"Okay." she said, glancing at Annie. Jesse let the two chat away while he left. Interesting, he thought. She's being friendly towards her... which means she hates her as well.

...

"This place looks empty, Benny." Ethan said into his cell phone.

"Just go inside, dummy!" Benny answered."And now, cause I need to get the door. My pizza's here." with that, he hung up. Ethan sighed, his dark eyes shifting around the place, before he hesitantly approached the front door.

The sound of footsteps became evident after a few seconds. The door swung open, and Ethan's jaw dropped.

"But...you're...you're..."Ethan said.

"Tha name's Annie, kid." the pretty blond "nurse" smiled, her fangs extended.

"Where's Sarah?" Ethan asked.

"Oh, you mean the girl who hates you?" Annie purred. "She's out today. Off hunting for a few new fledglings for us." Of course, Sarah was really in the house, but Annie's job was to keep her in and Ethan out.

"She doesn't hate me." Ethan snapped.

"Oh, did I hurt your feelings?" Annie sneered. "You should be going, boy. I'm rather...hungry today." she flashed her fangs again. Ethan jumped backward.

"I won't leave without Sarah." Ethan said stubbornly.

"Can't you take a hint?" Annie snapped. "She doesn't like you. In fact, the only way she'll be happy is when you're gone...for good. Unless you want me to make that happen, I suggest you go." Ethan stared at Jesse's house desperately, hoping to see Sarah in a window. But nothing.

"Fine." Ethan said at last, walking away.

...

"Spell to reverse split personalities spell...no...spell to cure warts... ew...spell to reverse fairy dust effects...ooh, gotta remember that one... nothing." Benny closed his spell book, tired.

"Benny? Are you still up?" Benny's grandma entered the room.

"Grandma, I need a spell to remove memory loss and a serious case of bitch-itis." Benny said.

"What?" Grandma Weir said, frowning at her grandson's profanity.

"Erica lost her memory, and Sarah's really mean now." Benny said. "All effects of a spell, but..."

"Oh, dear."Grandma Weir sighed. "Benny, the memory-loss spell is a weak one, but will require effort none the less. You must do something that can trigger an emotion, and the person's memory will flood back. You know Erica enough to do that."

"Easy enough. And Sarah?" Benny asked.

"Well I don't know." his grandma admitted. "Her being mean to you...why, that's hardly a spell. Lots of girls are, aren't they?"

"Thanks for the self-confidence booster, Grandma." Benny grumbled, disappointed that even an out-of-date old lady could peg him as a loser.

"Well, what I mean is, you'va handled rejection so well before and I think.."his Grandma began.

"Grandma!" Benny said,horrified. "I didn't ask her out! Her behavior is just...weird. She hates Ethan...and me, and she's all over Jesse."

"Could be the vampire transition, Benny." Grandma Weir pointed out. "Your friend Erica became like that." Benny thought about it. True, Erica had been all over Jesse even after Sarah was her best friend, and before, she wasn't afraid to talk to Benny in school. Still, it seemed so...un-Sarah.

"But why now?" Benny pressed.

"I don't know, I'm afraid." his grandma sighed.

"But it can be a spell, can't it?" Benny insisted. "Because that's not how Sarah is!"

"That's not how Erica is either, Benny." Grandma Weir said sadly. "I'm going to go now. Stay out of trouble." Benny waited until she left, then scanned his book for a spell like Sarah's.

"Hm...Opposite mind spell." Benny read. "This could work. But I'll need to find her first..."

I hope this was good. Please review... and thanking all my reviewers for last chapter! You are amazing: Brooke equals awesome, Princesakarlita411, Etharahxlover, Team Ethan Morgan, bellafan22, and my guest review!