Disclaimer: I do not own My Little Pony, and I do not own The Hunchback of Notre Dame or the movie's songs.
Pony Le Pu-Cathedral
Evening mass was beginning at the cathedral and the deacon was walking around the cathedral waving the holy water to bless the church with monk ponies in brown hoods behind him while the monastic choir began to sing
Confiteor deo
Omnipotenti
Beatae Mariae
Semper Virgini
Beato Michaeli Archangelo
Lights were now going off all over Pony Le Pu, but the scene was now shifting to the Palace Of Justice.
Sanctis Apostolis
Omnibus Sanctis
Pony Le Pu-Palace of Justice
Mareister was looking out the window starring at the cathedral of Pony Le Pu as they were in the middle of their evening mass. He didn't have his hat on, and he was about to sing.
Beata Maria
You know I am a righteous man
Of my virtue I am justly proud
Mareister was now walking down in his church to the fireplace with a big cross over it continuing to sing while looking up at the cross.
Beata Maria
You know I'm so much purer than the common, vulgar weak, licentious crowd
Mareister looks at the roaring fire in his fireplace awaiting answers to his questions.
Then tell me Maria
Why I see her dancing there
Why her smoldering eyes still scorch my soul
I feel her, I see her, the sun caught in her raven hair
Mareister starts to see a vision of Twilight dancing inside of the fire.
Is blazing in me out of all control
Mareister is feeling scared, and backs away from the fire.
Like fire, Hellfire, this fire in my skin
Mareister then pulls out the handkerchief from the Festival of Fools, and rubs it on his face
This burning desire, is turning me to sin
As he looks like he was going to tear it apart, he gets on his knees praying. Then a whole bunch of faceless monks wearing red robes appear.
Mareister: It's not my fault
Monks: Mea Culpa
He runs down trying to explain to the illusions.
Mareister: I'm not to blame
Monks: Mea Culpa
Mareister: It is the alicorn the witch who set this flame
Monks: Mea maxima culpa
Mareister: It's not my fault
Monks: Mea Culpa
Mareister; If in god's plan
Monks: Mea Culpa
Mareister: He made the devil so much stronger than a man
All of the illusionary monks started to turn into fire, and fly away into the fireplace. Mareister continued with his singing.
Protect me Maria
Don't let this siren cast her spell
Mareister still could only see Twilight in the fire dancing right in front of him.
Don't let her fire sear my flesh and bone
Destroy Twilight Sparkle
He holds up the handkerchief, and the vision of Twilight is still dancing in the fire.
And let her taste the fires of hell
It started to look like her own soul was coming out of the fireplace, and it looked like he wanted to give her soul a kiss.
Or else let her be mine and mine alone
Then the door knocks, and opening the door was one of his guards.
"Minister Mareister, the alicorn has escaped," said the guard.
"What?" Mareister questioned in disbelief.
"She's nowhere in the cathedral, she's gone," the guard told Mareister.
"But how? I…never mind," Mareister said as he was shaking his head, "Get out you idiot. I'll find her."
The guard left and closed the door.
"I'll find her if I have to burn down all of Pony Le Pu," Mareister said to himself as he went back to singing in front of the fireplace.
Hellfire, dark fire
Now alicorn it's your turn
He shakes the hankercheif.
Choose me or your pyre
Be mine or you will burn
Judge Mareister slams the handkerchief into the fire, and it burns up into ashes. He then starts to back away from the fire.
God have mercy on her
The room turned red, and shadows of those monks were appearing inside.
God have mercy on me
But she will be mine
Or she-will-burn
The shadows were leaving the room, and Mareister just got on his knees that he will find Twilight Sparkle. Then the room went dark, and he just put his head down ending his hellfire crazy moment.