It had been a week since Kurt caught Blaine kissing another boy, and he had not spoken, returned calls or text messages from Blaine. Kurt thought Blaine was the boy of his dreams until Blaine betrayed him and cheated on him. It was so hard for Blaine to think that the one guy that he really did care about was not speaking to him. He tried to send him flowers and chocolates with little notes, but when he walked by Kurt's house he saw them all in the garbage cans on the side of the road, he didn't know what else he could do.
(In Kurt's room)
Kurt was lying on his bed and had been there for the last week the only time he got up was to go to school, which was hard enough avoiding Blaine since they were in 3 classes together, and to the bathroom. When he heard a knock at the door, it was Finn; he had seen the flowers and candy left for Kurt on the front door step from Blaine in the trash unopened. He wasn't sure what was going on exactly and he wanted to help his step-brother out in any way he could.
"Hey Bro." Finn quietly said while opening Kurt's door slowly.
Kurt just acknowledged him with a muffled groan, since his face was lying flat against his pillow.
"What is wrong? You've been so down in the dumps for the last couple days and I don't know if you know there have been bouquets of flowers and candy from Blaine being delivered to the house daily."
"You don't think I know that?" Kurt yelled.
"Dude, relax just trying to talk to you."
"I know. I'm sorry for being in such a bad mood. Just not really up to talk about that certain person."
Finn walked in more to sit on his bed and was confused but fuming at the same time. "Hold up, what's going on? Did Blaine do something to you?"
"Nothing really except that when me and the girls went on our weekend trip we went to the movies and while I was in the bathroom Blaine came in with another guy. And at first I was thinking that it might be a cousin, until they kissed."
Finn stood up right away furious, his face heating up to the redness of a fire engine. "He cheated on you? I'm going to kill him!"
"Finn, don't. That won't help the situation." Kurt pleaded.
"He needs to be taught a lesson that if he hurts my brother he isn't going to get away with it Scott free." Finn ran out Kurt's door and down the staircase and out the front door, Kurt followed him.
All of their friends were coming over to hang out and check on Kurt, they were all outside when Finn came stampeding through the door almost knocking them all over.
"Dude, what the hell is the matter with you?" Puck asked.
"I'm going next door to kill Blaine!"
"Why in the world are you doing that?" One of the girls asked.
"When you girls and Kurt were at the movies last weekend I guess when he went to the bathroom he saw Blaine with another guy and he thought they were friends or something, but this 'friend' and Blaine started kissing and Kurt saw the whole thing."
"He what?" they all said in synchronized.
"Yeah that is why I am going over there now!" Finn yelled as he ran next door.
**Knock… Knock…**
"Hi Finn, how are you?" Elizabeth said quickly as Finn ran into the house passed her.
"Hello Elizabeth is Blaine here?"
"Yes he is upstairs in his room."
Right as Elizabeth was about to close the door the rest of the Glee Clubbers had pushed their way through shocking Elizabeth. 'What is going on?' she thought. Then last but not least Kurt came running through the door apologizing for everyone else's rude behavior of not even saying 'Hello'.
By the time that Kurt had gotten to the top of the stairs after sprinting a short by tiring way (since he was not really the runner type,) all he heard was screaming; mostly from Finn.
(Blaine's Room)
"Finn…. What is going on?" Blaine looked at him with truly scared and inquisitive eyes.
"What's going on? WHAT'S GOING ON? You really are going to pull that card right now after what you did to my brother!"
Blaine's eyes went from wondering what was going on to completely bugged out of his head and looking like he was about to cry. He now knew that Finn had found out about the whole movie theater thing and he was VERY upset.
"Just let me explain… Kurt wouldn't give me the time to fully explain what happened that night."
"Explain… EXPLAIN! What needs explaining? You kissed another guy while you were dating my brother, you lying, over-gelled, hoity-toity cheating pig!" Finn's voice continued to get louder with every word that came out.
With the thought of Finn using the word 'hoity-toity' everyone took a second to look at each other as if to say to themselves 'Did he just say what we think he just said?'
"Finn stop!" the voice came from the back of the crowd and everyone turned around to see what was going on. The voice was Kurt's.
"Kurt, he hurt you really badly. He cheated on you." Santana interjected.
"I know that; I was there." He gave her an irritated death glare, which made her back off.
Blaine did not see Kurt's face until he had pushed his way through his group of friends so that he was right in front of Blaine as he just stood there.
"So you wanted to fully explain?" Kurt asked.
"Yes, you didn't give me a chance to the night that it happened."
Finn took that comment the wrong way and almost lunged at Blaine for giving Kurt the attitude that he thought he heard. Kurt held out his hand in front of Finn to stop him. He looked at everyone that had now backed Blaine into a corner in his room.
"Guys, let us talk." Kurt said.
No one moved; they all just continued to stare at him.
"ALONE!"
"No way!" Puck yelled.
"Thanks Puck, but I'll call out if I need help. And you've taught me I need to stick up for myself." Kurt looked at Puck with adoration. Puck looked around at the others as if to say 'Yeah I taught him that. See I can have a good idea every once and a while!' Everyone left the room as Kurt closed and locked the door to make sure no one was able to sneak back in.
"Kurt, I am so sorry about that ni…" Blaine started
"Blaine you hurt me really badly."
"Yes I know that I did, but"
"There is no reason for a 'but' to be in that sentence."
"Okay I get that. What I meant was that…"
"You better start explaining!"
"KURT!"
"What?"
"That's what I've been trying to do but you won't let me finish."
Blaine started to explain about the misunderstanding that happened that night and how he should not have just sent flowers and candy that he should have had the guts to come over and try to talk to Kurt to his face and explain exactly what happened. After Kurt found out that he had been a total jerk to Blaine by not letting him explain what happened he got upset. Blaine did not fully understand what was going on until he saw tears streaming down Kurt's cheeks as he sat down on Blaine's bed and covered his face.
"Kurt, why are you crying?" Blaine asked.
Kurt mumbled into his hands as he continued to cry.
"Kurt I can't understand you. What did you say?"
As Kurt lifted his head from his hands he almost shouted. "Either you're lying to me or I'm the worst boyfriend to ever live!"
"How could you say that? You are the sweetest, kindest, gentlest," as he looked Kurt up and down "fashionably dressed guy in this state!" as he finished he gave one of those Blaine smiles that always made Kurt melt. But he had to stay strong he had to figure out a way to make sure Blaine wasn't lying to him.
"So that boy you were with who was he again?" He asked Blaine making sure he could keep his story straight.
"His name is Jasper. He is my cousin's friend and all THREE of us were supposed to go out that night but my cousin got the stomach flu and his mom quarantined him to the house and said that he couldn't come."
"Okay?!"
"You still don't believe me. Okay let's try this." Blaine walked over to his computer and pulled up his video chat, hoping to god that his cousin was online. He saw his name and clicked on it which brought up the video feed of his cousin still looking a little pale and with a green hue to him. "Hey Derick. How are you feeling?" Blaine asked while Kurt slowly inched forward to get a better look.
(Video Chat)
"Hey *cough…cough* Blaine. I'm still sick, but definitely feeling better because my fever is down from 102 it's only at 100 now." Derick replied. "Who's the skinny boy that looks paler than me behind you?"
"Derick! Don't be mean! I know you're sick but I can call your mom and tell on you I am not grown up enough to not be a tattle tale."
"Relax Blainey, I'm just kidding. About the paleness part not about the, who is he?"
As Blaine was about to speak annoyed by his cousin calling him 'Blainey' he felt a soft hand on his shoulder and that voice in that tone that he missed so much for the past week. "I'm Kurt. And by the way I'm not pale I am the color of porcelain."
Blaine melted under Kurt's touch that he hadn't felt in so long, it sent him into some sort of day dream until… "OHHH, you're Blainey's new boyfriend! He wouldn't stop talking about you the whole weekend he was visiting. 'Kurt is this… Kurt is that… blah blah blah.' And by the look on Blaine's face I can see it is a good thing that I'm not there in person. But anyway what's with the call?"
"I wasn't exactly totally honest about the night last weekend you were really sick and Jason and I saw the movie…"
"Yeah, which I can't believe you went to see without me!" Derick said with an annoyed snarling in his voice.
"Derick please will you let me finish?"
"Fine finish."
Blaine took in a deep breath and exhaled because he knew his cousin had heard this story already but it was still hard to say. "As I told you before, Jason and I had gone to the bathroom before we left and we were talking and out of nowhere he kissed me."
"Yeah you told me that part. And that Kurt would be crushed if he ever found out."
"What I didn't tell you was that Kurt and his girlfriends' had decided to go to the movies that night too and to the same theater." Derick could partially see where this was going but he let his Blaine continue. "Kurt had gone to the bathroom and was in the stall when it all happened."
"Kurt I'm so sorry…"
Kurt interjected. "Why are you sorry? You weren't there."
"Yeah it still is my fault because if I was Jason would not have had the guts to do it and also I didn't let him know that Blaine was seeing anyone. It didn't come to mind because I didn't think anything would have come out of it other than a friendship. It is entirely my fault." Derick explained.
"Derick it is not your fault. You were sick what were you supposed to do?" Blaine and Kurt said at the same time, they both looked at each other with a smile knowing that they were still so in sync that they almost read each other's minds.
"From the reaction that you both just had to that I can tell that it is time for me to go and let you two talk."
(Derick has logged off)
Both of the boys looked at each other with a smile once again and they both opened their mouths at the same time to tell the other "I'm sorry."
Blaine caressed Kurt's cheek as he wiped the left over tears away. As he did this he stared into Kurt's robin egg blue eyes and thought to himself 'How could I be so lucky to have such an amazing guy care about me so much.' He was so entranced it took him a second to realize that Kurt had pulled him into a deep kiss. Once he realized what was going on he kissed back and they both walked towards Blaine's bed never letting go of the kiss, they finally got to his bed and Kurt lay on top of his boyfriend.
As Kurt pulled back he said to Blaine, "I cannot believe that I ever thought that you would cheat on me. I was acting like a pre-madonna and it was ridiculous of me to act that way."
"Kurt don't talk like that you are not a pre…"
Kurt looked at Blaine as if to say 'Are you serious? Have you met me?'
"Fine you can sometimes be a pre-madonna, but you're my pre-madonna and also I can totally understand the reaction that you had to seeing that other boy kiss me." Blaine explained. "But I'm glad that you know that I would never intentionally hurt you in any way shape or form."
Both boys went back to kissing each other and this went on for a while, it had been long enough for Santana and Puck they had started getting bored and decided that they were going to pick the lock and let themselves in. As Puck was figuring out what type of lock it was Santana pulled out a bobby pin from her hair and a nail file from her purse. Puck just took them without a thank you and started to pick the lock from the outside.
"I'm almost there…" Puck exclaimed. "Yes, got it!"
"Okay what is going on in here?" Santana started to belt out but got quieter as she saw both boys wrapped in each other's arms on Blaine's bed asleep with the biggest smiles on their faces.
"We should probably go and also apologize to Elizabeth for just barging in her house like we did." Rachel whispered as they were walking down the hallway to the stairs.
They all agreed. As they all went to leave the Anderson house each one in the order of the line they were leaving in apologized for their rude behavior earlier, it took a good jab to the gut of Puck to get an apology out of him but he did finally apologize.
"I'm sorry Elizabeth for how rude we were earlier." Puck said with his face drooping and holding onto his ribs, where the small but very fierce when she wants to be, Rachel had elbowed him.
"I should have had my phone out to record this moment in history that will most likely never happen again. Hang on can we do it over?" Finn said with a sly smirk.
"You better get running before I beat you, Bro. I might have a busted rib because of your hobbit girlfriend over there but I can still beat the crud out of you." Puck said lunging towards Finn causing him to jump because it surprised and frightened him.