Just want to say thank you again to everyone who has read, reviewed, favorited and alerted this story. I love writing it and I'm so happy you all enjoy it. :)
It was Easter and Rachel was impatiently waiting for Finn in his living room to return home from breakfast with Kurt and Blaine. The only one who knew she was sitting in his house was Kurt because he had helped her plan this whole thing. She wanted to surprise Finn and the only way she could do that was to have a co-conspirator.
It had been six weeks and four days since the last time Finn and Rachel had had sex and both of them had been going a little crazy. Ever since the Mardi Gras incident Rachel had been somewhat apprehensive about jumping back into the sack. She wanted to give her body some time to get used to the birth control and she honestly was still a little freaked out. No matter how freaked out she had been though, around week five her hormones were getting the better of her and she was ready to move on from the experience. The only problem had been that they hadn't been able to find a good time or place.
That week Carole had vacation time so to her surprise, Burt had booked them a "Cruise-to-Nowhere" that weekend leaving from New York City. She had felt somewhat bad about missing Easter but Kurt and Finn had assured her that it wasn't a big deal. No one in the house was really religious and as for the Easter Bunny, neither had received a basket from him for years. They also really urged her not to feel bad because they both just wanted Burt and Carole out of the house. It wasn't every day that they had the place to themselves.
This was where Kurt came in. Upon learning that Burt and Carole would be gone for the weekend, Rachel came up with the idea that she and Kurt should surprise their boyfriends with special dates. Kurt liked the idea and so began the planning. Kurt would take Saturday as Rachel had to be home for Passover but she could do Sunday morning. While Rachel's family wasn't that strict on following all the rules of Judaism, they did like to have seder on the first and second nights of the holiday.
Kurt had planned a beautiful and romantic quiet night in for him and Blaine and Rachel had assisted by helping make dinner while Kurt got ready and getting Finn out of the house. He joined her family for seder and even though he was very confused by the whole tradition he really appreciated being able to share in the experience with Rachel. Finn also appreciated Leroy letting him into the house with his manhood still connected to his body. He could tell he really wasn't Leroy's favorite person.
The next morning it was Kurt's turn to assist Rachel with her date. All Rachel asked of Kurt was that he take Finn to breakfast around nine am and not allow him back into the house until at least 11. She needed some prep time. Rachel also requested that Kurt make himself scarce after dropping Finn back off at the house. It was nearing 11:30 and Kurt still hadn't texted that they were on their way back yet.
"What the hell?" Rachel practically screamed to the empty room. She was getting severely annoyed at the situation and she was getting cold. It was early April, not August. Sitting around waiting in the most scandalous outfit she had ever purchased seemed to be turning out to be a horrible idea. Until she finally received a text from Kurt that they would be there in about two minutes.
Rachel quickly checked her appearance in the mirror and was very satisfied. This was by far the most revealing of any of the cute little outfits she had ever worn for Finn. Obviously he'd seen her completely nude before but Rachel personally thought there was something more alluring about showing off just the littlest bits of skin. It kept a sense of mystery to everything and it was fun to have Finn undress her.
She checked that the jelly bean trail she had made from the door to where she was waiting was still intact and quickly went back to her seat. Seconds later she heard the door open. Rachel could hear Finn putting his keys on the table and assumed he was hanging up his coat. Then she heard his footsteps coming towards her. Her heart raced at the anticipation.
Finn thought it was weird that Kurt and Blaine weren't coming into the house. The place was empty and they could pretty much have the whole upstairs to themselves as Finn would be too busy playing videogames on the big screen in the living room. He wouldn't even notice Kurt and Blaine up there. Rachel had said she was busy with Passover or whatever so she couldn't come over which was disappointing. They hadn't spent any alone time together in weeks and Finn missed her. This weekend would have been the perfect opportunity to reconnect.
As Finn waved goodbye to Kurt and Blaine from the door, he entered the house. He locked the door then put his keys on the table like always and turned to remove his jacket to hang on the hook. That was when he noticed the jelly beans on the floor. He hung his coat up and followed the line of the colorful candy in the direction of the living room. As he rounded the corner his mouth dropped at the sight before him.
There Rachel was, sitting on the rocking chair his mother had just bought for the living room in the sexiest thing Finn had ever seen. It was a white lacy teddy that had halter straps and a V that went all the way down to just above Rachel's panty line. The only thing keeping the two pieces of fabric that covered Rachel's boobs from completely uncovering her chest was a little strip of lace that connected the two parts right underneath her breasts. The lace fabric wrapped around her lower back and through the sheer skirt that barely covered anything, Finn could see the lacy lower half of the teddy she wore. On her feet were some pale pink heels and on her head were some pale pink bunny ears. He was willing to bet that a little pale pink cotton tail had been conveniently placed on her backside as well.
"Happy Easter, Finn. I'm sorry this bunny didn't bring you a basket of candy but I did bring you something else that's pretty sweet," Rachel said in a low, playful voice as she stood up and sashayed over to Finn. He had yet to move a muscle. When she reached him, Rachel leaned forward and placed the gentlest of kisses on his neck. That seemed to knock him out of his stupor.
He gulped. "What are, uh, are you doing here? I thought you had Passover or something," Finn asked as he looked at Rachel. She smiled shyly at him.
"I fibbed a little so I could surprise you. I do need to be home by five o'clock though so we should make the most of the time we have together." Rachel leaned up and locked her lips with Finn's. She started maneuvering him around the living room to get him back over to the rocking chair. When the backs of his legs hit it, Rachel pried herself off Finn and pushed him down into the chair. He pulled his shirt off and Rachel undid his pants. Finn pushed his hips up so Rachel could pull his jeans off but she left his boxers on.
Rachel placed her knees on either side of Finn's thighs and straddled him. The chair rocked forward with the shift in weight that Rachel forgot to account for and she nearly flew off, losing her bunny ears in the process, but Finn had managed to catch her. "D'you wanna move to the couch instead?" he asked as the chair steadied.
"No, I like this chair. I just have to remember to balance." Rachel put her hands on the back of the chair to steady herself then sat her butt on Finn's thighs. She could see the tent growing in his boxers and smiled. It had been weeks since she had induced such a reaction in Finn. Rachel didn't realize just how much she missed it until that moment.
This time, accounting for the shift in weight, Rachel leaned forward to kiss Finn again and ran her hands down his bare chest. He wrapped his arms around Rachel and pulled her against him and moaned as he felt her nipples press into his chest. No matter how many times he felt that, it never failed to elicit a sound of pleasure from him.
Finn ran his hands up and down Rachel's back and sides as she moved her hands down to his waistband. She teasingly ran a finger along the top of it then slowly pulled it down letting his erection free. Rachel pulled her mouth from Finn's and stared down at it. She licked her lips and gently ran her fingertips over the sensitive skin. Finn's head fell back and he took in a sharp breath.
Rachel grabbed one of the condoms she had sitting on the table next to the chair and carefully opened it. Carefully and very slowly she rolled it onto Finn to be sure it wasn't her that could cause another tear. Once she was satisfied, Rachel pulled the now extremely wet fabric covering her center to the side and dipped her finger into herself. She bit her lip and stared at Finn as he watched her play with herself. It was a huge turn on for him.
Once Rachel had spread the wetness around to really get herself going she was more than ready to get Finn inside her. She grabbed the back of the chair again and shifted forward so that all she had to do was push the chair back and Finn would be thrust up into her. Rachel held herself as still on the chair as she could and pushed back.
"Oh God," she moaned out as he pushed into her. Rachel sank lower onto him, wanting him as deep inside her as he could get. Continuing to try holding herself still, Rachel moved the chair again. Finn understood now why Rachel didn't want to move to the couch so he helped her by rocking the chair himself.
Rachel moved her hands to Finn's shoulders and looked down to watch him entering her over and over again. While it felt good it didn't feel all out amazing, at least not until she angled her hips forward a little. At the new angle and with the rocking, Rachel barely had to do any work. She closed her eyes and just let the sensation take over her body. Every thrust brought her closer and closer to achieving that sweet release but just before she could feel herself let go, she pulled herself off Finn. He whined in disappointment. "What are you doing?" he said through ragged breath.
She stood up and pulled him up from the chair. They walked over to the couch, Rachel pulled his boxers down then she pushed him on to it. He loved her forcefulness.
"I want to try something," was all she said as she kicked her heels off and placed a foot on the couch to step over Finn. Her lady parts were right in Finn's face before she sat down in his lap keeping her knees bent against his torso. Finn was very excited. He and Rachel had never tried this position before, not that they'd had sex on a rocking chair prior either… Finn thought the day was just beyond awesome at that point.
Rachel guided him to her opening again and once he was inside her she leaned back as far as she could and placed her hands on the floor. She had remembered just a few moments ago a position she had read about in Cosmo and now she wanted to try it. Rachel began thrusting her hips back and forth and as she did so she opened and closed her legs.
Finn let out a moan as he felt Rachel's walls clamping around him tightly. He looked down at her thrusting up and down on him and he knew he'd never be able to forget the image of Rachel's wet center gliding over his penis again and again and again. Really though, he never wanted to. This was by far the hottest thing they had ever done. She just rode him like that for what seemed like forever until he could finally feel himself getting ready to explode. "Rachel," he breathed out. He could hear her whimper in response and knew she was getting close herself.
For a moment Rachel looked up at Finn and could see the familiar 'o' forming on his face signaling that he was about to come. She could also feel him twitching inside her. Rachel arched her back to try to pull herself up to meet Finn again but as she did so Finn hit her spot right on and she shuddered suddenly gaining her own release.
Rachel cried out in ecstasy as her body trembled at the force of her orgasm and her back arched even more as her legs tightened around Finn. The fantastic sensation lasted for about twenty seconds and as soon as it was over she slumped down like all her bones had turned to jelly. She had been so wrapped up in her own orgasm she wasn't even sure if Finn had had his.
Once she sat up about a minute later though, she had her answer. Finn was gripping Rachel's thighs lightly and his head was back against the couch with his eyes closed. He looked so peaceful and euphoric. Rachel slid off him but leaned against his chest, her head next to his. Finn turned his face and kissed her forehead. "You are the most awesome girlfriend ever," Finn stated with a lopsided grin.
Rachel smiled at Finn's words. She could never get enough adoration from him, especially after sex. It was nice to know that all her hard work was appreciated in every aspect of her life. "I love you," Rachel said before planting a soft kiss on his cheek.
"I love you," Finn replied looking directly into Rachel's eyes. Before he could lean in to give her a kiss and possibly get things going again, Rachel stood up quickly and began to walk away. Confused, Finn stood up himself. "Where are you going?"
"I don't know about you, but I'd like to take advantage of the fact that no one is home. I'm going to the kitchen." Rachel winked at Finn and as she turned around to continue walking, she untied the strings at her neck and let the fabric fall away from her body. With a sly grin on his face, Finn grabbed the condoms on the table next to the rocking chair and quickly followed Rachel into the kitchen.
He may not have received any chocolate that Easter, but Rachel wasn't lying when she said she brought him something sweet. They had sex in practically every room of the house, except his parents' or Kurt's because that would just be creepy, and every time Finn felt like he and Rachel were growing closer and closer. They had finally moved on from Mardi Gras. Yeah, Easter was definitely Finn's new favorite holiday.
Just a quick piece of info about Mardi Gras since GeekyGleek asked and I can't pm. That was not originally a holiday I was going to write about but once I remembered it and realized the date, it fit in perfectly with what I wanted to do for St. Patrick's Day so you all got an extra smutty chapter before all the angst. Also, even though they're in Ohio I see no reason they wouldn't know about Mardi Gras. I live in Buffalo, NY and I know about it and know people who celebrate it. Rachel was just using it as an excuse to get Finn naked. Nothing wrong with that if you ask me. lol Also a little spoiler alert, a left over question from Valentine's Day may be answered in the next chapter. )
