As soon as Hotch hung up with Emily, he rounded the team up in the conference room.
"Hotch, where's JJ and Emily? Weren't they supposed to be here by now?" Morgan asked.
"Morgan, Emily is on her way. JJ is missing." Hotch explained.
"What?!" Was everybody's response at the same time.
"I think our killer may have her. He abducted her from a cafe which fits his MO. He always abducts his victims from public places. She also has blonde hair and blue eyes." Hotch said.
"This is not good. How is Emily holding up?" Reid asked.
"I don't know. I barely talked to her, she said she would be here shortly." Just as soon as Hotch said that, Emily ran through the door.
"Hotch, we have to do something! JJ is in the hands of a rapist and killer! We have to get her back unharmed!" Emily said all in one breath.
"Emily, calm down. We'll get her back." Hotch said.
"Yeah? Before or after that freak kills her?" Emily asked, her voice breaking.
Hotch didn't know what to say t that, but he knew he'd try his damn best to get her back alive, no matter what it took.
"Emily, why don't you have a seat?" Rossi suggested.
"I don't think a seat is what I need right now, when my girlfriend is out there in the hands of a serial killer!" Emily said.
"Emily, I need your head in this, or I will have to take you off the case." Hotch said.
That seemed to calm Emily down.
"Right, okay. Where do we start?" Emily asked calmly.
"We start with the last victims. We know they were all abducted from public places. Get Garcia on the phone, Morgan." Rossi said.
Morgan nodded and called Garcia, putting her on speaker.
"You're on speaker, Garcia." Morgan said.
"Garcia, we need your help." Hotch said through the phone.
"Anything my little furry crime fighters." Garcia said in her usual chirpy voice.
"Garcia, I need to tell you something. It's about JJ." Morgan said.
"What about her?" Garcia asked, her tone getting worried.
"She's missing." Morgan said and there was only silence on the other end.
"Garcia?" Morgan asked.
"Why? Who has her?" Garcia asked after a minute.
"We think it's our killer, but we're not sure yet." Morgan said, but he was actually kind of lying. He was sure it was their killer.
"You're going to get her back and nothing is going to happen to her, right?" Garcia asked.
"We're going to try our best." Hotch said after Morgan couldn't respond.
"What do you need me to do?" Garcia asked.
"I need you to cross reference all of the victims and see if you come up with something they have in common." Hotch said.
"Okay. I'll call you back when I have something." Garcia said, hanging up.
"Now what?" Emily asked.
"We profile our guy." Morgan said.
After they had worked a little on the profile, Garcia finally called.
"What do you have for us, Garcia?" Hotch asked.
"They all went to the same gym except for JJ." Garcia said.
"Could be that JJ was just in the middle of the investigation and since she was his type he figured, why not?" Morgan suggested.
"Alright, give me the name of the gym." Hotch requested.
Garcia gave them the name of the gym and they drove there.
They requested the names of the members of the gym and went back to the precinct.
"Garcia I need you to cross reference..." Morgan's voice stopped suddenly as he stared at the paper wide-eyed.
"What is it Morgan?" Hotch asked.
"There's a Josh Jareau here." Morgan said.
"Guys, he was arrested for domestic violence and rape when JJ was 12, but was released on a technicality. He's her father." Garcia said.
"Oh My God!" Emily said.
"Garcia do you have an address?" Hotch asked.
"Yes I do." Garcia said.